Re:Linear Algebra by Jim Hefferon – free textbook
by tejuis on Monday January 28, 2019 @07:14AM
(#19016874)
It is easy to agree with these findings. In general it is important for humans to get answers to WHY. History answers typically to WHY questions and to some extent also examples, i.e. you see by example WHY the theory works.
Re:Linear Algebra by Jim Hefferon – free textbook
by faitswulff on Monday January 28, 2019 @08:51AM
(#19017378)
What other books have you found helpful other than the Chatterjee text?
Re:Linear Algebra by Jim Hefferon – free textbook
by sriram_malhar on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:29AM
(#19018132)
Did you mean "Statistical Thought" by Chatterjee?
Re:Linear Algebra by Jim Hefferon – free textbook
by roenxi on Monday January 28, 2019 @05:23PM
(#19021626)
Oh, sorry, yes I did. "Statistical Thought: A Perspective and History". The first half is basically all the schools of thought on how probability theory and the real world interact; so I keep thinking of it as a philosophy book.
While you are right, a related issue is that most maths textbooks are atrocious at most aspects that aren't writing pages of equations. There is almost nobody sitting at the 3-way intersection of great mathematician, great writer and great educator who can then write great textbooks.
I've found books with terms like "History" and "Philosophy" in the title are much better places to learn about mathmatics; combined with wikipedia for formulas and details. Any book with excercises but no solutions or historical context has turned out to be basically useless to me, even as a reference (wikipedia is usually better for simple stuff).
I've got something like 4 books on statistics on my shelf at the moment. The only one that I've actually manged to read and learn something from has been Chatterjee's Philosophy of Statistics, because it talks about what techniques were developed in context of which problem, failed alternative approaches, explains what was confusing to some of the greatest minds in the history of statistics, etc. This has been vastly more useful in setting up a framework for what the world of statistics looks like that I can attach a whole bunch of proofs and suchlike too. It has been enlightening in a way that textbooks can't really manage.