Re:How Oregon ensnares mentally ill people charged with low-...
by phren0logy on Sunday January 27, 2019 @08:01PM
(#19014760)
It is real and relevant, and already accounted for in the concerts about limiting personal liberty. The usual mechanism to address this is to require more than one clinically trained person to agree, which holds them for a few days until it can be heard in court and decided by a judge. This requires it only illness but immediate danger to self or others. This has had the unintended consequence of conflating mental illness with violence. Always trade offs...
Re:How Oregon ensnares mentally ill people charged with low-...
by 75dvtwin on Sunday January 27, 2019 @09:02PM
(#19014963)
WRT
> The usual mechanism to address this is to require more than one clinically trained person to agree, which holds them for a few days until it can be heard in court and decided by a judge.
It seems the above would only work (meaning that it would prevent abuse) if:
a) the 'clinically trained persons' affiliate with different political fractions
b) there is no 'federal-level' oversight hammer that can strip them of their credentials for testifying against the wants of the currently ruling political fractions
c) The judiciary system overall is free from 'selective-outrage' ( Which is, unfortunately, some would say, not the case for US, Canada, France, UK, Australia, not even mentioning known oligarch/dictatorships countries out there )
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_abuse_of_psychiatry_...
Is that "inherent capacity for abuse" overstated?
I'm less afraid of the corrupt psychiatrist than of the one sincerely convinced that people who think like I do are sick.