News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by genericresponse on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:09AM (#18988759)
Are we going to ignore that Google responded that they published this as part of a legal defense rather than a lobbying effort. From the article: "We're not lobbying for changes to any rules." Rather, she said, Google's claim that the Obama-era protections should be overturned was "a legal defense that we included as one of many possible defenses"

I'm not saying that makes it right, but I see a difference between pushing for it as an independent agenda and using it to defend yourself from a legal filing. IANAL, but Legal arguments tend to be set up as: They are wrong because of argument 1, and even if you don't agree with argument 1 they are wrong because of argument 2, and so on through argument n. You include everything that's relevant in that list to preserve it for future appeals even if you have some pretty weak or controversial arguments.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by pdpi on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:33AM (#18988956)
> Are we going to ignore that Google responded that they published this as part of a legal defense rather than a lobbying effort.

You can't have your cake and eat it too. I'd go as far as to say that this actually makes it _worse_, not better. Saying that that those protections are important is easy when there's nothing at stake. The fact that they then called for their overturn when the chips are down is how you know what they really think about it.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by koboll on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:37AM (#18989000)
It's silly to equate a legal defense with a belief though.

I may not have the belief, personally, that spontaneous crimes of passion deserve a light sentence, but it would be malpractice for my lawyer to therefore not advance that argument if, god forbid, I was convicted of a murder. Whether I committed the murder or not, and whether or not I believe those sentencing guidelines should be extrapolated to wider society, as a lawyer you have an obligation to use every tool in your arsenal that can help your client. It has nothing to do with your own personal or political views on whether those tools should exist.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by topspin on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:24AM (#18989419)
> It's silly to equate a legal defense with a belief though.

It's actually silly not to. As was said; when there is something at stake their story is something other than what they offer while placating outrage. I can't fathom rationally choosing to believe meaningless pillow talk over the black and white filings of Google's representation in a court.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by pdpi on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:50AM (#18989120)
Had they argued that the Obama-era rules didn't apply to this case for some reason, I would've agreed with you. But the argument is that those rules should be overruled. That is precisely arguing that your preferred outcome for this case should be "extrapolated to wider society", as you put it.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by koboll on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:00AM (#18989195)
If those two arguments would have been equally effective, then perhaps you would be right. I would bet that that wasn't the case, and that's why Google's attorneys advanced the argument they did. Perhaps you are right but they advanced both arguments to be safe, as a higher parent comment suggested.

But it's hard to tell, because the article is vague on these points. It refers to their actual argument only as "urged the National Labor Relations Board to undo that precedent". What exactly does that mean? It's written as if they submitted a policy brief, but it sounds more like they were arguing a prior decision by the NLRB was incorrectly decided, based on previous precedent. Which is something attorneys do all the time and much less dramatic, sans the lobbying-esque framing here.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by rootusrootus on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:47AM (#18989085)
Assertions of certain politicians to the contrary, corporations are not people, and Google wasn't defending against a crime of passion.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by koboll on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:50AM (#18989119)
Sure, I wrote a contrived example. But the onus, I think, is on the critics in this thread to provide the theory of legal ethics under which attorneys should refrain from advancing the most effective defense of their clients if doing so might cause public relations concerns. It's my understanding that zealously defending their clients within the bounds of the law is among an attorney's highest obligations.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by rootusrootus on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:05AM (#18989249)
In my view, the lawyer is absolutely obligated to present all viable (in their view) legal options to their client. But the buck stops with the client -- they decide which legal arguments to make.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by pdpi on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:18AM (#18989365)
To use an equally contrived example of my own — there's plenty of jurisdictions where arguing something along the lines of "look at how she was dressed, she was asking for it" will get you off the hook on rape charges. Would you still argue that an attorney who makes that argument is merely "advancing the most effective defense of their clients"? Or would you find that conduct reprehensible both for the attorney, and the client who allowed the attorney to use that line of reasoning?

Ultimately, it's your own choice what lines of arguing you present, and you don't get an ethical freebie just because it's "effective".

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 24, 2019 @12:23PM (#18990683)
> To use an equally contrived example of my own — there's plenty of jurisdictions where arguing something along the lines of "look at how she was dressed, she was asking for it" will get you off the hook on rape charges.

Rape is an unusually problematic situation because consensual sex and unconsensual sex produce a lot of the same physical evidence, and it's possible for someone to consent but after the fact have regrets or experience social pressure.

That leaves you having to evaluate evidence of whether or not there was consent. If you're a falsely accused defendant trying to rebut a claim that she didn't consent, what evidence of that do you propose to use?

Also notice that look at how she was dressed is a particularly ineffective "get out of jail free card" when the accuser was a nun dressed in her habit.

The implications of that, i.e. that you're more credible if you dress conservatively and don't attend frat parties, are very politically inconvenient.

But a black man has a constitutional right to carry a handgun, which also makes it more likely that he'll be shot by the police who will use it as a defense. It would be better if these trade offs didn't exist, but how do you propose to make them not?

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by stale2002 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:02PM (#18991814)
It is not about "making a proposal to make sure these tradoffs don't exist".

Instead it is about morally judging someone for making a morally reprehensible argument.

If there is some country in the world where black people don't have equal rights, and a company uses this as a legal defense for it's behavior, then I am going to judge the company as being full of horrible horrible human beings.

One does not get a free pass for your behavior, just because it is legal. Onr instead should get judged for the horrible person that one is.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:12PM (#18991897)
Someone is a horrible person if they are falsely accused of something and use the argument that most effectively allows them to avoid being falsely convicted of it?

It seems to me if you have a country where some people don't have equal rights, the problem is the law, not any individual defendant. That's the easy one to fix, in the sense of knowing what should be done. Much easier than trading false positives against false negatives when there is no way to actually know what happened.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by stale2002 on Friday January 25, 2019 @04:01AM (#18996582)
I am saying that if you make an argument in court that says "This law should be overturned!" as google literally did, then I am going to assume that this means that you think the law should be overturned.

And I will judge you morally if I believe overturning this law is a bad thing.

A company is responsible for it's actions. And if it's actions in court cause a good law to be overturned, as is their stated argument, then I will judge them very poorly for this.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by AnthonyMouse on Friday January 25, 2019 @03:46PM (#19002333)
The problem is that everything is always complicated.

If employees use the company's email system to discuss politics, then the company's email system contains their policy views, which may not be the company's. Then the company gets sued by someone else who gets a copy of those emails and uses the employees' personal views as evidence of the company's official position.

A solution to that would be to have the law be that political discourse can't be used as evidence of policy or intent in a court case. That might be a good solution, but there may not be support for it in the existing law.

The alternative would be to prevent employees from using the company's official channels for their political discussions, to create a brighter line between official and personal speech. Arguing for the second thing is worse -- it has a lot of other problems -- but arguing for the first thing may not be possible under existing law, leaving it as the company's only apparent alternative to avoid liability. What are they supposed to do then?

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by stale2002 on Saturday January 26, 2019 @04:38PM (#19008663)
> What are they supposed to do then?

What they should do is follow the law, and not try to get rid of worker protections.

I don't care that it has negative effects on them. I am going to judge them morally, for trying to get rid of a good law.

The whole point of laws is to prevent companies from doing bad things, that might be in their interests.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by Rylinks on Thursday January 24, 2019 @11:32AM (#18990140)
there's plenty of people who think defending a criminal at all is ethically dubious. Depriving criminal defendants of the most effective defense by applying social pressure to their attorneys is not a good road to walk down.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by yourbandsucks on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:19AM (#18989376)
The legal system treats them as entities very similar to people. It's not a statement of principle, it's a statement of process.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by sjg007 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:54AM (#18989151)
I'm guessing stock holders would argue that there's a fiduciary duty to get the best legal defense and the lawyers have a similar mandate. Still you would think that Google would not mount such a defense on the basis of a moral principal.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by akiselev on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:09AM (#18989286)
IANAL but "We're in an extremely competitive industry and we might lose all of our best people if we do this" is a perfectly good reason to give shareholders. It only breaks fiduciary duty if the executives have concrete data that their actions will have zero impact on hiring, which is a stretch.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by geodel on Thursday January 24, 2019 @12:22PM (#18990677)
> we might lose all of our best people if we do this

This is the argument media seems to be making for long time. So far instead of all not even 0.01% seems to have shown conviction and left Google. Or it just might be the case the best people seems more concerned only with technical issues at work.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by nabla9 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:56AM (#18989169)
Court room is an adversarial game, everything the defense or prosecutors say should be considered in this light. They should use every argument to defend themselves.

Google has fiduciary duty to not lose money unnecessarily. The corporate policy is completely different from legal defense when sued.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by jschwartzi on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:05AM (#18989246)
This is fine, but then you can't claim the moral high ground if your legal defense is that employees don't actually have the rights that your policy says they do.

It's worth noting that people don't like doing business with hypocrites either, so Google has a fiduciary duty to avoid pissing its customers and employees off by systematically eroding their rights through legal arguments as well.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by nabla9 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:46AM (#18989647)
If I think that castling should be removed from the chess rules. Am I a hypocrite when I use it when I play with others?

In the same way proposing laws that would limit legal tax evasion loopholes and using those loopholes is not a hypocricy. They work at different levels.

Wanting to change rules (laws) so that everyone must play with the same rules and using rules until they are changed is not hypocrisy.

Court battle is like debate competition, you can use arguments you don't believe in.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by kamarg on Thursday January 24, 2019 @11:36AM (#18990195)
> Court battle is like debate competition, you can use arguments you don't believe in.

Except that court battles have consequences. If you use an argument you don't believe in for a debate competition, you aren't going to overturn laws designed to protect people from those with more power. If you do it in court, there's a possibility that you're going to make many lives worse.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:18AM (#18988824)
> they published this as part of a legal defense rather than a lobbying effort

We live in a common law system [1]. Case law, regulatory proceedings, statutes and constitutions are all law. What ultimately matters is outcome.

We don't know the details of the case they are defending against. We don't even know if there is one. Either way, there is lots of ground between "this right shouldn't apply here" and "you should take it away." Google chose the latter.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law

[dead]
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by SquareWheel on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:28AM (#18988918)
I see you found a way to call them a "shill" without saying it directly.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by resters on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:38AM (#18989008)
The grandparent comment is noteworthy among HN comments for being so eagerly apologetic for the kind of corporate/branding hypocrisy that Google used to position itself against.

It makes me wonder if someone posted it in an attempt to make Google look bad even though the comment purports to defend Google.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by close04 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:35AM (#18988975)
Perhaps not a shill but definitely providing a distorted interpretation of what the article says as clearly as possible:

Official filings

> Google’s attorneys wrote that the 2014 standard “should be overruled” and a [...] precedent [...] should be reinstated.

Google spokesperson

> We're not lobbying for changes to any rules

Reconciling this information into an opinion that only gives credit to PR words, while completely ignoring lawyers' actions is strange.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by wang_li on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:13AM (#18989321)
Lobbying is talking to legislatures and regulators in an attempt to change laws/policy. Arguing in court is trying to do an end run around the legislatures and regulators. Big difference.
Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by close04 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @11:56AM (#18990409)
> Arguing in court

Lobbying is not limited to specific venues if that's what you mean. It's "attempting to influence the actions, policies, or decisions of officials in their daily life, most often legislators or members of regulatory agencies". Isn't the NLRB exactly such an agency, given its power to undo a precedent?

Whether you do it by "urging" them in a justice court or "influencing" them on a tennis court it's still the same even when arguing semantics.

Arguing in court that this specific case doesn't fall under the regulation is just arguing in court. Arguing to undo the regulation is literally lobbying. They are asking people with the power to regulate to undo regulation. Read this as you wish.

Unless the Bloomberg article is misleading in the way it words the story then I believe my comment is pretty accurate.

Re:Google Urged the U.S. to Limit Protection for Activist Wo... by close04 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @09:20AM (#18988838)
> but I see a difference between pushing for it as an independent agenda and using it to defend yourself from a legal filing

> In filings in May 2017 and November 2018, obtained via Freedom of Information Act request, Alphabet Inc.’s Google urged the National Labor Relations Board to undo that precedent

Are we going to pretend that "lobbying" and "urging" are different concepts? It simply represents their views, and they're trying to push them into reality.

> Lobbying, persuasion, or interest representation is the act of attempting to influence the actions, policies, or decisions of officials in their daily life, most often legislators or members of regulatory agencies.

Also, are we going to pretend that they are not actually doing this because a spokesperson used the right words in a PR statement? You can't claim to use it "just" as a defense but you don't actually want it or even believe in it. You do it because you want a specific outcome. And given the vile nature of Google in recent times I wouldn't expect better from them.

P.S. Oh, double digit downvotes in just a few minutes on all comments I made in this thread. Nothing to see here. o_O

P.P.S. And still rolling in as I edit. 10 downvotes in just 5-6 minutes for pointing out that OP is (deliberately) misrepresenting what the article states very clearly.