News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by llimllib on Friday November 12, 2010 @01:41PM (#1898640)
I'm sure that my behavior does not reflect my answers on this test. Given the numbers, I calculate expected value and answer rationally. In real life, a) the values and percentages are much less clear and b) even if they weren't I know I don't follow them as rationally.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by mian2zi3 on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:08PM (#1898758)
Same here. The only "interesting" choice was when the safe/risky options had the same expected value.

The percentages are much less clear, as are the payoffs. I was attracted less by the monetary payoff of the entrepreneurial life than the other, less tangible benefits: responsibility, control, independence, learning opportunities, challenge, etc. I'm not attracted to safety, I'm afraid of boredom.

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by siglesias on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:05PM (#1898749)
This is the point that I'm trying to get at. For Arrington to assert that entrepreneurs are "different" because they like risk, adventure, he is claiming that they knowingly choose bad deals. He is saying that these bad deals are compensated for not by money, reward, but the thrill of doing a startup. Hmm.

We get a thrill from gambling sometimes even though we know that the odds are stacked against us. Arrington is drawing the same analogy for entrepreneurs, and that's a bad analogy. It's a romantic notion, but I don't think the monetary valuation of an entrpreneurial venture is negative in the minds of entrepreneurs.

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by StavrosK on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:35PM (#1898905)
"Would you rather have a $100k steady job, or a 5% chance to make $1m in a year with a startup?" -> Definitely startup, even if the expected utility is half.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by siglesias on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:44PM (#1898940)
Would you pay 50k to join a startup and work for free as a consultant?
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by siglesias on Friday November 12, 2010 @05:10PM (#1899509)
And just so everyone knows what I mean by this, 50k is the opportunity cost of the other job that's being forfeited. This means that the "thrill" of working in a startup must be worth at least 50k.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by dazmax on Saturday November 13, 2010 @11:30PM (#1902525)
But part of the thrill would be the possibility of the million.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by StavrosK on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:46PM (#1898954)
What is this, an anchoring exercise? :P Are you asking if I would pay to work in a startup? No, I can start my own for free.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by ahoyhere on Friday November 12, 2010 @08:19PM (#1899928)
IMO, you're right about the romanticism, but it'll be hard to tell anything from this survey because of the tendency for nerds to overthink!

Tell you what: I tried to go with my gut feeling on every question. I am very risk-averse, but the idea of gaining money doesn't mean that much to me. Winning $100 vs $1000 isn't that emotional for me. Oh, sure, I'd like $1000 but I don't even care about $100. I thought about scaling the numbers up til they mattered to me, and decided I'd almost always take the sure thing because I could turn that money into a higher amount thru investing it in expanding my product.

But I would gladly pay $250 instead of even a slight risk of losing $1000. (Or whatever the numbers were I've forgotten already!) IRL, I've bought a new car because I'd rather pay a couple grand more than have the uncertainty of potential repair bills, etc. Clearly I hate negative unknowns.

That risk aversion has clearly influenced the type of "startup life" I've chosen. My products are "boring," but quite profitable. No funding, no 80 hour weeks, no sleeping under the desk, and no potential to be gobbled up by Google, either.

Nevertheless, I find this far less risky than having a job, because nobody can fire me from my own company! Plus, I'm not miserable because people are always screwing with my work.

That said, I think part of the special startup mindset is similar to the people who will bet more on dice they've rolled than dice rolled by someone else... whether a startup is acquired feels like something they can control, however irrationally.

Maybe you could ask what people believe is the average chance of acquisition for a startup in general, and what they believe their chance is?

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by JoshCole on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:17PM (#1898804)
Completely agree, this felt more like a test of basic math skills than a test of behaviour. In real life it tends to be a lot harder to be able to calculate expected value, with some exceptions especially with card games.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by powrtoch on Friday November 12, 2010 @05:03PM (#1899480)
Then why didn't you answer according to what you think you would actually do? The idea of the test was to gain insight into your personality with regard to risk and reward. If you can't honestly see yourself accepting a (.4 * $1000) loss over a $50 loss, then you answered incorrectly according to what the question was actually asking.

Personally I had the same dilemma, but I found it revelatory to really look inside myself and see if I could do what expected utilities would dictate. It was especially difficult on the loss questions, as I have very little capital to my name.

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by cheald on Friday November 12, 2010 @05:23PM (#1899537)
I think the problem is that risk always has to be calculated against reward, and in this test, it was always reward-against-reward or risk-against-risk.

For example, let's take one of the loss scenarios and pretend that it's some wacky hosting cost.

* $50 guaranteed loss - paying $50 for 100GB of bandwidth

* 0.04% of chance of $1,000 loss - paying $2.50 for 100GB of bandwidth, but an extra $997.50 for unlimited bandwidth if you go over 100GB.

If I don't expect to do much traffic, I'll take the 4% chance; I project I might do 20GB of traffic during the term of the contract, so I will save 20x as much money. My product has a 4% chance of going viral. If I lose the contract lottery, it's because I've won the product lottery, and that 4% means I've got a rapidly-growing product that is going to make me a lot of money. The risk of that extra $1000 is well worth knowing that I'm not going to have to move my product between hosting providers when the blogosphere in in a mad frenzy about my internet tortilla delivery service.

That's completely different than a scenario wherein the hosting provider says "This is a variable contract; you owe us $2.50 for 50 GB of bandwidth, but each month we pick one of our 25 customers and they pay $1,000." There's no way in hell I'd sign on for that. There is no indicator of success correlated to the risk there.

Without context, I'm not sure that these questions are all that useful. You point this out yourself - the risk questions will be interpreted variably depending on the individual's resources and perspective. I can absorb a $50 loss trivially, so if the reward is equivalent, I'll choose that.

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by radu_floricica on Saturday November 13, 2010 @04:20AM (#1900616)
When comparing to the rational choice, I did what I do in real life: added a safety margin. If anybody tells me there is a 10% chance for a project to succeed, I will always subtract a couple of percentage points for unforeseen circumstances.

You treated it like a school test, looking for the "right" answer. To paraphrase Nicholas Nassim Taleb, if a coin falls head 100 times straight, the chances it will fall tails the 101 time are 50% only in academia - in the real life the coin is fixed.

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by groby_b on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:10PM (#1898765)
Well, I think that's true for pretty much all surveys. If you are reasonably intelligent, it is actually hard to not figure out what is really asked and give answers based on how you would react instead of how you should react.

I've never seen a survey that wasn't easily manipulatable. So I guess we have to rely on people to try to be honest...

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by aristidb on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:29PM (#1898875)
Behaving on expected value is not rational.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by dirtyaura on Friday November 12, 2010 @03:16PM (#1899085)
Exactly.

Choosing between

a) 100% chance of $10 vs 10% chance of $100

is very different question than choosing between

b) 100% chance of $100K vs 10% chance of $1M.

or

c) 100% chance of $1M vs 10% chance of $10M.

I think many people will choose 10%/$100 combo of a) just for the thrill.

The latter two are of course dependent your financial situation, but hit an interesting sweet spot for YC crowd.

What would be your choices?

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by joshu on Friday November 12, 2010 @04:28PM (#1899345)
As I said in another comment, i tested this exact question out on mechanical turk: http://joshua.schachter.org/2008/09/amateur-economist.html
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by llimllib on Sunday November 14, 2010 @11:12PM (#1905191)
Behaving based on expected value is the only rational choice.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by JoeAltmaier on Friday November 12, 2010 @03:12PM (#1899066)
There was no beta attached to the time-value of money - so it was no way to measure the risk.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by rkosai on Friday November 12, 2010 @04:09PM (#1899280)
Based on all these "rational actor" responses, I take it none of you purchase insurance?
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by anamax on Friday November 12, 2010 @05:42PM (#1899595)
Actual rational actors understand that extreme loss has a disproportionate effect. (In other words, losing $100k is more than 1k as expensive as losing $100 for most of us.)

Naive rationality may be easy to analyse but that just means that the GIGO transfer doesn't cost much.

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by moron4hire on Friday November 12, 2010 @04:28PM (#1899347)
I have car insurance because it is legal mandated. I don't have health or life insurance.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by joshu on Friday November 12, 2010 @04:24PM (#1899331)
I certainly don't on things I can easily afford to replace.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by gojomo on Friday November 12, 2010 @04:29PM (#1899351)
Only when it's legally/contractually required (car/financed-house), or comes with negotiated discounts (health), or handles a catastrophic/risk-of-ruin situation (chronic disease/business liability).

Insuring against small losses is a net financial loser, or else the insurance company wouldn't offer it.

Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by Natsu on Friday November 12, 2010 @03:37PM (#1899172)
I'm glad to see that I'm not the only one who calculated EVs.
Re:Are Entrepreneurs Pirates? 4min Test for HN by Behavioral... by siglesias on Friday November 19, 2010 @03:40PM (#1922713)