Ask HN: Career change at 40: bootcamp, degree, other?
I am considering whether I should do a coding bootcamp, an online degree through a US institution, or a degree in Germany[1], or to continue to work/study on my own until I can get a job (remote or local).
I started in CS when I was in college in the late 90's, but I switched away from that and earned my degree in philosophy (focus in logic and ethics). Back then I learned C and Java. Then HTML, CSS, and PHP3. I built a few dozen websites on my own, and I contributed to the production of about 600 or so. But, that was a long time ago, and I'm not interested in web development so much any more.
When I switched from Windows to Gentoo GNU/Linux about 10 years ago, I started learning Bash scripting and some sysadmin basics, just for fun/interest.
A couple of years ago, I started to learn Python 3, and I have dabbled a bit in Common Lisp. Python led me to machine learning, which I really like, but I'm not 100% sure I want a career in ML anymore (I thought I did maybe a year ago, and I still might -- I really like it).
I have written a lot of code over the years, but I don't have anything that would really qualify as a portfolio, or much that I feel like I could turn into a portfolio.
I guess this is the main reason I have been looking at doing something like a bootcamp, or cheap online degree--though money really isn't the issue. Or should I just start to work on a portfolio of projects?
I have also worked professionally as an editor many years ago, which came out of an incomplete foray into a master's degree in technical writing.
If you had the time and money, would you do a bootcamp, or a degree, or work on your own?
[1] My German is around B1-B2 level, and I would work to improve this dramatically if I were going to try for a local degree.
Why completely throw away your experience as a lawyer? I am starting a company in the legal-tech domain and it'd be very valuable to have someone with experience in both sides of the world.
Law is like IT - even if you get a job in a completely unrelated field, as soon as your past gets out, you'll find yourself inundated with requests to "just take a look at this." Might as well use that experience to your advantage first.
So I would suggest looking at the question from this angle. What excites/motivates you enough to invest some time in it? What kind of job or context do you see yourself working in? If you are academically oriented, getting a degree will probably bring you the most satisfaction while you figure out the next step. If you’re more practically minded, I would suggest building your own one-man business, capitalizing on your interests and expertise (ML to automate lawyery stuff?)
Given your past experience, I don’t know what you would learn in a bootcamp and (in my opinion) a bootcamp on your resume has weak signaling power. I would suggest looking at apprenticeship degrees, where you’re at school part-time and work the rest of the time. They’re pretty common (in France at least) and some of them are explicitely targeted at people who already have had a first non-IT career. The upside is that you’ll get to work early on (these schools will usually help you find a company). The downside is that you’ll be working in a junior position. But, aside from starting your own business, I don’t see how you can avoid that.
FWIW, in my company we have an apprentice data scientist who used to be the GM of an industrial company in Asia! He caught the data science bug a few years back and he’s having a blast going back to school and learning on the job.
If I could get to a point where I could help solve problems in AI R&D, then that's what I would probably do. I mentioned that my philosophy undergrad focused on ethics and logic. If I could find a way to work on building systems that have ethics as a primary concern (ethical algorithms, ethical artificial intelligence, etc) then I would like that.
I have really enjoyed my self-study in machine learning, and for a while I thought for sure that's the path I would take. Right now I am not as sure. I just don't have a good sense of what I should do to keep going down this route if that's what I want to do, other than trying to get into a data-sciecne-type degree program perhaps.
I have no issue with starting in a junior position. I don't care about the money or the power or the prestige specifically -- I just want to do something interesting and fulfilling. I have already had the chance to make lots of money in my life, and I just don't care that much, so junior (engineer/data scientist/etc) is fine. Also, it's easy not to care about money so much when your partner earns so much; I realize that I am in a fairly privileged place of not having to worry about money right now, but that's just where the universe has put me for now.
Otherwise, I am really into Linux and FOSS stuff. I don't know if I would like kernel dev or embedded software as a career, but that's a possibility.
Re junior positions, they’re often not the most interesting jobs, unless you have a specific interest in learning the ropes (or you love fixing bugs and handling JIRA tickets ;) - hence my remark.
A final thought: if working remotely is on the table, i.e. if you’re not explicitely looking for a local job and the accompanying social interactions, maybe you can look at working remotely for a US company. Hit the latest “who’s hiring” post, look at remote job postings that sound interesting, and contact the recruiter to see if your profile could interest them and if not what you would need (degree, portfolio, previous experience) before applying again.
Self taught programmers take years to make up for their missing education. If you have the time to learn from very smart people for a couple of years, I don't know why you wouldn't do it.
Even so, this can easily lead to resentment and arguments, (and also self-doubt), if the other part doesn't start earning enough soon. So it's not like "family income" is a solved problem, even if one partner brings in all you need.
My lawyering requires a significant amount of court hearings, which I will be unable to do from Germany. I do very little transactional work that I might be able to continue in Germany, so a career change is a realistic and logical move. It just happens to coincide with wanting to make the change as well.
Family income, as long as she keeps her job, is pretty much a solved problem for us. She makes a lot of money. Waaaaaaay more than me.
I do not need to work necessarily for income but because I want to work. This has been the case for us for many years now.
But I do appreciate your sentiment.
Unless I knew for certain that I couldn’t do solo work, or knew for certain that I couldn’t muster the discipline, I would say “work on your own” in the beginning.
If I am to take your harmonious financial arrangement at face value, which you reaffirm in another comment, understand that your situation is probably very enviable to many. Make the most of it.
You didn’t specify but I assume you expect this situation to hold for at least a year, maybe two or three years? That’s great. And you already dabbled in ML, and you “really like it”? Well, its the remote option, but this is what I would do :
1. I would brainstorm a project about applying ML to law, or my field of law[0]. This is not completely unheard of, as I’m sure you’re aware.
2. If I come up with some holy grail ideas, I would put them aside for later. I would then try to find something to start with that is very simple, maybe something that would have helped me day-to-day in my previous lawyer life. Maybe something much smaller that would be a necessary but not sufficient item for one of the holy grail ideas, or like I said some small but obvious value added day-to-day lawyer stuff.
3. After I decided on the project, I would apply the Amazon way of working backwards, a. Create the press release: Describe in simple terms what you’re going to build b. 20 most frequent questions: Answer in clear, simple terms (& iterate until it is very clear what you’re going to build) c. UX Document: How are my users going to interact with this d. Keep the above simple, don’t overdo it.
4. So you came up with your first project, now you have to skill up. Since you dabbled in ML maybe you are already familiar with the ML learning angles people recommend on this site (fast.ai, Coursera etc). I would research and make a decision which ones to start with first (maybe you’ve already completed some) and focus on completing them together with all the relevant exercises etc. In parallel, I would be on the lookout about what I need to learn for the project and continuously apply what I learn to the project.
5. Out of necessity, you are probably going to need to dabble in integrating frontend web and mobile stuff. Research and decide on learning path based on what concrete things you actually need in your project.
6. Once you feel you know enough to build the shittiest and dumbest version of your idea build the shittiest and dumbest version of your idea before continuing a new online course in your studying plan.
7. Put your code on the web when you have the shittiest and dumbest version of your idea working and keeping updating it. I would upload two separate things as projects a. the software/product that the end user will use that has everything in it. b. The ML component as a separate project. Don’t let the frontend stuff detract from the ML stuff. Imagine someone with better web and mobile skills wanted to use your ML-law work to make something more polished. They could use this.
8. Now you have a portfolio, don’t you? You could go on building the next item on the road to a holy grail, or you could continue iterating on this as you learn.
9. Meanwhile, you could start applying with your portfolio for remote work at AI tech companies targeting law or NLP areas (more general overlapping domains) , or law firms that are scared of tech who don’t want to be the nokia or blackberry of law in the future (this is probably the unlikelier of the two, since this tech would disrupt billable hours). In the former, you would be the “domain” guy for the tech, in the latter you could be the “tech” guy for the domain. Your skills and background will be unique.
10. Alternatively, or in parallel, start selling what you built. Cause looked at it another way, this is identical to have received seed funding for 1-3 years to start a company.
Sure when you start working with others you may soon feel you’ve missed out on some fundamentals, but this is what I would do in terms of opportunity cost. By the end, you will have a unique background and you will be working in a niche area suited to your background, your weaknesses will matter less. After this, if I still felt iffy and it still didn't matter if I got a job or not, then I would consider a online degree through a US institution, but if its a very good program.
Anyway you asked me what I would do, obviously might not be the best advise (disclaimer).
[0] assuming doing anything related to law or your field of law doesn’t instantly fill you with dread or actively demotivate you in whatever you’re doing. If I hated law, the general outline would still be the same. Coming up with a project idea that kept me motivated and that I thought would be of use to others might take a little more time to find. I wouldn’t be able to use my law background for applying for work for maximum effect, so there would be no binding narrative between my previous lawyer life and what I’m doing now, that might make it more difficult to sell myself to potential employers. But with a portfolio that would matter less.
Everything that I have learned related to programming, hardware, networks, etc in the last many years has been on my own. I have run my own law firm for more than 10 years now. I believe I am capable of self-motivating and being productive.
But, you know, you never know.
I have also had success in formal academics. Sometimes I feel like it'll really boil down to picking one option and seeing what happens.
My main concern in wasting a bunch of time by picking an option that won't get me anywhere, but there's never a guarantee against that anyway.
Self-directed learning is ok if that's the best you can do, but having the structure of an academic setting is absolutely invaluable. You'll immersed in an environment where those around you are doing the same thing, and the value from discussing difficult concepts with others is impossible to overstate.
Self-directed learning will put you in a bubble of the overhyped web technologies. What is extremely hard to understand from the outside is that there's an ENORMOUS hidden level of much more interesting problems and work in fundamental engineering. But it doesn't get discussed online much, because it's more difficult to get into, and there's no point arguing with people online when they don't have the background to participate.
Happy to discuss my thoughts further if you have questions
There are some interesting programs around. I don't think I will qualify for a masters program yet, so where do I look at bachelors degrees?
In Germany, I think they are all in German, which means improving my German quite a bit (I don't think my level of proficiency is sufficient).
I have looked at a few post-baccalaureate online degrees, where if you already have a BA/BS then you just complete the major coursework requirements and they grant you a degree. That is definitely interesting, but it's sometimes hard to judge the quality of the institutions or what their degree would actually get me.
If you don’t have to or don’t have the urge to enter the job market in the next 2-3 years, an on-campus degree might be ideal. For this to be really an option you should ask just someone who teaches advanced German how fast they think you can pick it up while living in germany in order enroll in an engineering program at a german university. If you live close to a decent school and the time required is not an issue, do that. While you do that you can also do the” working on your own” thing and drop/pause it when you start your degree.
Otherwise, I have only come across master programs taught in english at german universities, not a bachelors, and those have a b.sc. as a prerequiste. If you were very close to the dutch border, maybe dutch universities could be an english option :)
The online options:
1. A “masters” that doesn’t require a B.Sc. The only thing with a reputable name attached to it that I’ve come across is the one by Penn through Coursera. [0]
2. An online B.sc. (e.g. Oregon state etc)
3. DIY curriculum for working on your own. Where you look at the MIT and Stanford B.Sc. curriculum and match the course topics with highly recommend MOOCs and textbooks [1][2]. The advantage of this is that you can do this while advancing your german and drop it if you start a local degree.
Going back to your goal:
>If I could get to a point where I could help solve problems in AI R&D, then that's what I would probably do.
If you want to do this at a company with an R&D program (e.g. [3]) that has no age bias you would probably need:
1. CS Fundamentals: to pass the CS fundamental whiteboarding/interview questions.
2. AI/ML related domain knowledge : to pass those types of questions
3. Experience in AI/ML software development: to get interview
Going down the degree route would cover 1 and a little of 2. You would need the “working on your own” specialization/portfolio phase after you finish the degree, or do it in parallel in order to cover 3.
Alternatively, if money will never be an issue, you can “help solve problems in AI R&D” by staying in academia or doing it as an independent researcher.
> I mentioned that my philosophy undergrad focused on ethics and logic. If I could find a way to work on building systems that have ethics as a primary concern (ethical algorithms, ethical artificial intelligence, etc) then I would like that.
Cool, that kind of made me think about the relationship between ethics and law. it would be interesting to have legal tech advising on the legality of issues and have ethical tech suggesting changes to laws to cover the gaps of unethical lawfulness.
[0] https://www.coursera.org/degrees/mcit-penn
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16745042
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18793849
[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18796552