News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by dbingham on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:31AM (#18953783)
For the love of all that is holy, can we please just admit that our current methods for studying nutrition _do not work_, that we need better ways to handle this sort of complex system, and the mean time, the best knowledge we have about what constitutes a healthy diet really can just be summed up as "eat food, not too much, mostly plants". The head spinning speed with which new "scientifically supported" diet announcements come out -- which almost always contradict each other -- is almost certainly contributing to the undermining of the lay person's trust in science at this point.

We need to stop it, stop trying to apply clearly mismatched tools to this problem and reconsider our whole approach.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by nonbel on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:36AM (#18953820)
The idea of "mostly plants" was arrived at using the same methods you don't seem to trust. Why are you ok with that one?
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by dbingham on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:46AM (#18953908)
A couple of reasons, it's the only thing that does seem to consistently match across all the studies. Though, there are plenty of counter examples of cultures that have an almost all meat diet and are perfectly healthy, there are other factors involved in those cultures that don't apply to your average first world eater -- the meat is mostly wild caught for instance.

The other one is environmental efficiency. While I don't buy that a vegan diet is the most sustainable diet -- there are sustainable agro-ecology systems that include meat by necessity to make them work, and the vegan diet relies heavily on certain monocrops that massively damage the planet in their own right -- it does seem pretty clear that we cannot continue to consume meat at the rate it is consumed in the western diet and stay sustainable.

The other thing is that it's a really broad guideline, not a specific prescription. As a broad guideline for health and sustainability for those living in western culture, it seems pretty reasonable.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by ianai on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:53AM (#18953953)
My take away from reading about diets and health has included:

1. We really have a lot to learn about food and biology.

2. Not all carbs are created equally. We may even need whole, new classifications of carbs beyond fiber/starch/etc (just my suspicion though). this is where Keto/meat and fat diets get results. Replacing processed carbs with nearly anything may be an improvement. Doesn’t make nearly anything healthy.

3. Different people digest different foods differently for varied reasons.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by admax88q on Sunday January 20, 2019 @02:25PM (#18955000)
Not all meats are created equal and most studies about diet do not control for that. There's a difference between McDonald's beef patty's and grass fed beef.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by pakitan on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:18PM (#18954117)
> Though, there are plenty of counter examples of cultures that have an almost all meat diet and are perfectly healthy, there are other factors involved in those cultures that don't apply to your average first world eater -- the meat is mostly wild caught for instance.

The more obvious and probably more important factor, that doesn't apply to the average first world eater is there are very few of those that have a diet consisting predominantly of meat. Most meat eaters today still have significant portion of their calories coming from refined carbs and they usually avoid fatty meat, which is a staple for those cultures you mentioned.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by nonbel on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:50AM (#18953936)
>"Two reasons, it's the only thing that does seem to consistently match across all the studies."

Not saying I agree (I haven't looked, but surely "all" is an exaggeration...), but if you don't trust the researchers to know what they are doing this could easily be due to bias or including mcdonalds/etc as "meat". Ie, eating less fast food is correlated with not eating meat.

>"The other one is environmental efficiency. While I don't buy that a vegan diet is the most sustainable"

This has nothing to do with health.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by zzzeek on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:17PM (#18954114)
> This has nothing to do with health

Are you an agricultural scientist? How do you know that? How do you know the quality and purity of the soil from which the food grows and the aquifiers which hydrate it didn't affect the nutritional quality of the food itself? I think such impacts have already been observed.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by nonbel on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:28PM (#18954193)
>"Are you an agricultural scientist? How do you know that?"

Ok, I should have spoken more carefully. First, I believe that literally every single thing we can observe is correlated with every other thing (although this correlation may be weak/negligible). So there is nothing that has nothing to do with any other thing.

>"How do you know the quality and purity of the soil from which the food grows and the aquifiers which hydrate it didn't affect the nutritional quality of the food itself? I think such impacts have already been observed."

Definitely, there seems to have been a great amount of vitamin/mineral depletion. Usually this is chalked up to intensively farming (high-carb) grains (rice, wheat, corn) that really no animal should be eating much of:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221451411... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Revolution

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by sbuttgereit on Sunday January 20, 2019 @01:40PM (#18954690)
In principal, I disagree conflating two different types of advice/goals like you are in your original comment (1. a statement about what is/is not healthy to eat, 2. what or what not is ecologically sound, made clear in your second comment to which I'm now replying) without making it clear that you are making that leap. The two goals may prescribe some contradictory action.

For example, lets pretend for a moment that the worst sort of ecologically disastrous forms of industrial farming happened to produce the most healthy and nutritious food; it's conceivable GMO could well spark that debate not unlike that. Do you make a single statement saying to eat good organic food to stay healthy without also making the statement you're compromising the health portion in balance with ecological concerns?

I think making a simple health statement without also being fully clear about also making an environment statement also erodes trust if found out.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by dbingham on Sunday January 20, 2019 @02:12PM (#18954926)
You can remove the second reason and it's still just as valid. But that said, this kind of thinking is exactly the sort of problem we have when looking at complex systems. You can't examine any piece of it in isolation. Health is not isolated from environment.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by fpoling on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:33PM (#18954230)
In Mongolia people eat only meat from horses, sheep and camels. Mongolia is at the top charts regarding the dearth from heart deceases and cancers especially the liver cancer. And this is in a population that was exposed to this diet for thousands of years and where the meat comes from the most humanely treated animals.

One may argue that the statistics is biased towards people from cities where doctors have a better chance of diagnosing the causes of dearth and where people eat much more processed meat than in rural areas, but then the average lifespan in Mongolia has been increasing despite people moving to the cities. In addition there is a small population of ethnic Russian who moved to Mongolia 100 years ago after the revolution. They show the same patterns of deceases.

Disclaimer - I am vegan for ethical reasons.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by pakitan on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:50PM (#18954335)
Yet, somehow, Mongolians seem to have a slightly higher life expectancy than Indians, who generally subsist on plant-based diets.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by nonbel on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:44PM (#18954306)
Sounds like people with health issues over there are also living "harder" lives:

>"Cerebrovascular diseases, ischemic heart diseases, perinatal deaths, influenza/pneumonia/asthma and tuberculosis were the leading causes of AM in the past eight years in Mongolia. The AMR [amenable mortality rate] was higher in remote western provinces with harsh weather conditions, high poverty rates, lack of human resources for health, and poor infrastructure." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4767514/

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by CamTin on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:41AM (#18953863)
It at least has the definite benefit of being less resource-intensive. If you accept the premise that we're just guessing what the right diet is, we may as well guess the "cheapest" option.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by hirundo on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:49AM (#18953926)
The paleo diet is based on a different guess: "As long as we're guessing we may as well guess the options most likely to be compatible with our evolutionary adaptations." This seems completely incompatible with picking the cheapest food, but healthier.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by CamTin on Sunday January 20, 2019 @01:57PM (#18954804)
I'm not saying I agree with the premise (that we really have no idea what a healthy diet looks like), but given the situation where are all diets are equally likely to be healthy, picking a cheap one makes sense.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by hirundo on Sunday January 20, 2019 @02:22PM (#18954984)
Yes, if we know nothing about food except for its price, it's reasonable to chose based on price. But do you really think that's true? There's no credible basis for selecting one food over another based on its nutrition?

I wonder if this is the point of much of the smoke blown into nutrition research by Big Food. People get so confused they think wtf, if the big brains can't figure it out, how am I supposed to. I'll just buy that, it's cheap and tasty.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by CamTin on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:00PM (#18955242)
Do I really think that the rational thing to do is always only eat the cheapest food? No, I don't. I was reacting to the premise, which is that all diet advice is as likely to be correct as any other. This is clearly a false premise.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by nonbel on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:43AM (#18953880)
This has nothing to do with resource consumption, it has to do with health/longevity.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by everdev on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:16PM (#18954109)
Look at our teeth, mostly plant chewing teeth.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by pakitan on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:29PM (#18954200)
Yet our gut is optimized for a meat based diet. Our digestive system resembles more the one of lion than the one of our closest cousin - the chimpanzee.

In his book "Sapiens", Yuval Harari talks about how we literally drove into extinction something like 90% of the biggest animals on Earth. And that wasn't because we competed with them for the juiciest grass fields.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by nonbel on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:31PM (#18954215)
My teeth chew meat just fine. They wouldn't work so well as weapons, but humans devised tools for that purpose long ago.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by throwawaymath on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:28PM (#18954187)
Is that true? How do we determine that our teeth are primarily intended for eating plants?
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by zeroname on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:43AM (#18953879)
> a healthy diet really can just be summed up as "eat food, not too much, mostly plants"

Absolutely not. We do know enough about malnutrition to say that this statement is false.

It has also been demonstrated that "zero carb" diets have all sorts of short-term desirable outcomes, such as weight loss or controlling diabetes. Your "don't eat too much, mostly plants" diet fails here.

What we don't know is the long-term outcomes of that (or any other) diet. Frankly, I'd rather risk a shorter life than continue a life of obesity, which is also associated with higher mortality.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by zzzcpan on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:52AM (#18953946)
"eat food, not too much, mostly plants" - you can't really generalize to that, as climate and lifestyle are very important too. Someone living in cold places might not even be able to survive on that advice.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by ramraj07 on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:12PM (#18954081)
Why not?
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by throwawaymath on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:15PM (#18954099)
Because it can be very difficult to find affordable plant-based food in cold regions, especially if you're trying to make that food the majority of your diet.

People looking to derive most of their nutritional needs from plant-based food need various kinds of infrastructure around them if some or all of those plants can't be naturally grown nearby. Generally this means transporting them from a hospitable growing environment or making the local environment artificially hospitable.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by zzzcpan on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:40PM (#18954283)
You also need to eat a lot of food just to keep your body warm if you are exposed to cold a lot.
Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by appleiigs on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:50AM (#18953937)
I think the only universally derided food is sugar.

And carbs is too big of a category. Basically food racism - declaration of a entire population of food as good or bad doesn’t help.

Re:A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long by perfmode on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:19PM (#18954123)
*Prejudice