News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by AsyncAwait on Sunday January 20, 2019 @09:23AM (#18953155)
I really can't recommend Mastodon highly enough.

The interactions on there are just so much more organic than on Twitter. You get to actually have discussions with people, instead of aiming for as much snark as possible.

Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by kabacha on Sunday January 20, 2019 @10:56AM (#18953555)
I feel the opposite. I don't use twitter but Mastodon is kind of an echo chamber.

1. There's no way to discover content. Sure you can search for tag but that's absurdly inconvenient. The pinable UI is borked and awkward as it allows to subscribe only to one tag. The language filter is laughable at best.

2. There's just so much spam. Just take a look at public or local timeline - if you're not on a small isntance it's just people doing the same pointless messages like "umm spaghetti"

3. Only now proper moderetion tools are introduced - before you'd get suspended with a mysteri 403 error where you can't even log out lol. This was heavily abused by mastodon.social administrator and every github issue closed and purged.

I'm so sad to see Mastodon overtake actually well thought out social networks such as Diaspora*. I'm not even touching how much of a step back the whole Fediverse is to XMPP or Federation protocols.

Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by AsyncAwait on Sunday January 20, 2019 @02:18PM (#18954954)
> 1. There's no way to discover content. Sure you can search for tag but that's absurdly inconvenient

Coincidentally, there's a new directory feature to help with just that. Just go onto any 2.7 instance that has it enabled and /explore would list users you might want to follow based on somolar interests, i.e. [1].

1 - https://mastodon.social/explore

> There's just so much spam.

Either go to a particular interest instance if you want to see a useful local timeline, or follow people and then look at your personal timeline, which is not really different than how Twitter does it.

> Only now proper moderation tools are introduced

Moderation tools have been pretty robust for a long time.

> This was heavily abused by mastodon.social administrator

Mastodon.social is based in Germany and has to follow local speech laws, which are more restrictive than in the U.S. It also has several moderators, not just the admin. But you can just join a U.S. based instance, which is the whole point of federation.

Now if your content is such that no respectable instance wants to take you, there's still the self-host option, which is quite straight forward with Docker, but perhaps also reconsider why you're getting banned.

Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by legostormtroopr on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:31PM (#18956311)
> Now if your content is such that no respectable instance wants to take you... perhaps also reconsider why you're getting banned.

Except, there are multiple "wrongthink" lists that are used to auto-ban entire instances [1][2]. Technical merits of Mastadon aside, the community very much encourages echo chamber behaviour - hell on of the reasons for un-federating an instance is "apparent free speech zone". And to top it off, this is a viral list. If your instance federates with "wrongthink" instances there is a very real chance you'll get banned too - just for not banning the "wrong" people.

[1] https://github.com/dzuk-mutant/blockchain/blob/master/list/l... [2] https://toot.cafe/about/more#blocked-instances

Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by gregknicholson on Monday January 21, 2019 @02:12AM (#18958325)
This is a social problem, only exacerbated by technology. There's no technical solution.
[dead]
Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by oAlbe on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:18PM (#18955334)
Are you suggesting there is no free speech in the EU?
Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by y4mi on Sunday January 20, 2019 @04:32PM (#18955741)
Technically, there isn't...

But the US doesn't have it either, if you take it literally. Free speech is basically a misnomer. You can only have it in a society if you define the free speech to only apply to some generally agreed upon limits.

I.e inciting rebellion, lynchings or similar have no place in society, but is technically free speech in the literal sense

Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by yogthos on Sunday January 20, 2019 @04:40PM (#18955779)
Same here, I've been on it for about a year now and I prefer it to Twitter in every single way. One example is that you can turn off tracking boosts and retoots in the notifications. It's complete noise to me, and I find it's just distracting. Twitter splits notifications between all and mentions, but there's no way to stop notifications for things other than mentions. This is just one of the many little things that result in a much nicer user experience for me.
Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by bdz on Sunday January 20, 2019 @09:48AM (#18953264)
>You get to actually have discussions with people

Ofc. Mastodon by nature is an echo chamber. Choose your own enclosure and find people who agree with you. The only difference that Mastodon is the first where that's the main selling point

Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by _red on Sunday January 20, 2019 @10:29AM (#18953445)
The trope of "X is an echo-chamber" needs to die out. You say it like high-trust communities are a bad thing.

All productive interest groups are that way by their nature (HN is that way too). The opposite simply devolves into lowest common denominator garbage...instagram models posing with their breakfast, twitter outrage-porn, etc.

Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by sp332 on Sunday January 20, 2019 @01:58PM (#18954815)
And in the bad old days of the internet, people wouldn't just pick one group to be part of. You could have different personas on different sites and decide how much to participate with different groups. This is harder to do with Twitter and Facebook because they only run one instance. E.g. there's no "fringe science" echo-chamber Twitter, but that means the fringe science people just get thrown in with the rest of Twitter.
Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by sp332 on Sunday January 20, 2019 @10:28AM (#18953439)
Sometimes it's just nice to have a conversation, you know? Not everyone is looking for an argument or criticism 100% of the time.
Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by AsyncAwait on Sunday January 20, 2019 @09:59AM (#18953315)
I get what you're saying, but disagree. I receive plenty of pushback, but we have a back and forth and it can often be quite stimulating.
Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by toyg on Sunday January 20, 2019 @10:20AM (#18953399)
There is also self-selection: early adopters will always be, on average, more knowledgeable than mainstream users, which usually correlates with politeness and civility.
Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by contravariant on Sunday January 20, 2019 @10:45AM (#18953499)
You can have the ability to make an echo chamber without making one.

The truly dangerous situation is one where you don't have any control and an echo chamber is made for you.

Re:Mastodon 2.7: Highlights from the changelog by h1d on Sunday January 20, 2019 @05:24PM (#18956006)
Isn't it due to the ratio of highly motivated people being more on Mastodon or does anything else makes it so? Like HN vs Reddit.