News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by _pius on Thursday November 11, 2010 @03:51PM (#1895189)
I'm reminded of what Malcolm X said to the civil rights demonstrators:

Be peaceful, be courteous, obey the law, respect everyone; but if someone puts his hand on you, send him to the cemetery.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by Locke on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:18PM (#1895300)
I don't necessarily disagree with the original article or this sentiment. However, I have a hard time reconciling telling your child to stick up for him or herself when bullied vs "send him to the cemetary" or "As soon as he turns around, hit him in the back of the head as hard as you can. If you’re much smaller, pick up a hard object and do it."

These are children and their judgement is not always the best. Do you really want to risk that your child kills another child by accident while following your advice?

Will your child know how far is far enough? Is there a chance he or she might over-react to a situation that is not truly threatening?

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by roc on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:46PM (#1895413)
Do you think the bullies know how far is far enough?

Bullying escalates. If you don't trust your kid to make a judgment at some point, it's basically a matter of time before they get seriously injured themselves.

I'd rather teach my kid to stick up for himself and have the mistakes happen at the level of "knocked out tooth/broken finger" than letting things escalate in the first place.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by seldo on Thursday November 11, 2010 @05:12PM (#1895517)
So your kid gets beat up. Then your kid beats up the bully. Then the bully comes back with a knife the next day. Or a gun.

Bullying does escalate. Therefore, teaching your kid to escalate on their side as well just makes it happen faster. The solution to escalating warfare is to break the cycle.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by chc on Thursday November 11, 2010 @05:39PM (#1895620)
The point is that it only escalates when it's not deterred. "Break the cycle" is a platitude, not advice. What is involved in breaking this cycle, if not stopping the bullies?
Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by invisible on Thursday November 11, 2010 @07:37PM (#1896021)
The bullying cycle is this: bully on day #1 -> bully on day #365...repeat. I have witnessed people in school be bullied and them just ignore/deal with it politely and it didn't work for them until they freaked out and fought back.
Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by roc on Friday November 12, 2010 @01:35PM (#1898616)
That's fighting. Not bullying.

Bullying is typified by a victim being picked-on mercilessly because he never fights back. Because the bullying tears him down. Because the bullied is a victim.

Bullying isn't a contest for the bully. They do it precisely because it isn't. They're not trying to 'win', they're trying to make someone else feel as bad as they feel. If they can't do that, because the victim refuses to be victimized, they find a new victim or find a new outlet.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by sossles on Thursday November 11, 2010 @08:53PM (#1896212)
If your kid actually wins the fight, it humiliates the bully, then there's a risk that it will escalate.

If your kid just gives the bully a few bruises but ultimately loses the fight then they've sent the message that they're not an easy target, and the bully has saved face.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by siculars on Thursday November 11, 2010 @06:36PM (#1895834)
> The solution to escalating warfare is to break the cycle.

That is not true. MAD worked in the cold war. The solution is to let the other side know you will not go gentle into that good night.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by jules on Thursday November 11, 2010 @05:48PM (#1895659)
That's not the way it works in my experience. I'd also rather have it your way, but it just doesn't work.
Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by masklinn on Thursday November 11, 2010 @05:10PM (#1895510)
> However, I have a hard time reconciling telling your child to stick up for him or herself when bullied vs "send him to the cemetary" or "As soon as he turns around, hit him in the back of the head as hard as you can. If you’re much smaller, pick up a hard object and do it."

The second one no, but the second one is mostly an exaggeration for "don't be the one who starts fights, but be the one who ends them". Cemetery is probably a bad idea as it'll breed revenge, but going at it until they are physically unable to fight back is probably a good idea.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by angrycoder on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:34PM (#1895361)
I really think you are just playing semantics here. The quote wouldn't be nearly as effective if it read:

"Be peaceful, be courteous, obey the law, respect everyone; but if someone puts his hand on you, hurt him just enough so that he leaves you alone - but don't kill him."

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by Locke on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:46PM (#1895419)
The quote is fine. I worry about this glorification of violence. The original article and this thread seem to be filled with adolescent fantasies of revenge against bullies past and future.

I hope this is mainly internet posturing and bravado.

I'm not sure every child has the perspective to recognize hyperbole. There are times when violence may be necessary, but that doesn't make it any less horrible, whether justified or not.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by dasil003 on Thursday November 11, 2010 @05:04PM (#1895485)
The "glorification of violence" is too intellectual a concern. It's an idea balancing precariously at the top of Maslow's hierarchy of needs.

It's unfortunate that violence is sometimes necessary in school, but it is because bullying isn't taken seriously by the administration. Bullies spend all their time making trouble, so they get good at doing psychological damage and flying under the radar of authority. But the damage they are doing is potentially severe. Bullies usually have severe problems at home, and I feel bad for them, but they mustn't be allowed to spread their self-loathing virally by means of systematic low-grade abuse to anyone who is an easy target (ie. the weird ones, the free thinkers, the people who don't conform, and thus are more likely to bring something new to the world when they grow up).

If administrators took this more seriously and started expelling these kids, then that would get the attention of their deadbeat parents, and violence would not be necessary. However in reality, school is like prison, and sometimes violence is the answer.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by ErrantX on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:54PM (#1895448)
Yes, that is a problem. It is one reason I don't advise kids (that I talk to about such problems) to take this approach.

One thing I actually disliked about the post is the way he has de-humanised bullies. When in reality the correct approach is to feel sorry for them - because they have all manner of deep seated issues. Not in a lovey-dovey way (which, he is right, is silly) but in an adult comprehending way.

The act of your violence is a potential learning experience for them too. Too much vitriol and anger and they may come away harbouring deep resentment, and later come back at you with escalating violence. But a short sharp shock could teach them some important truths.

For the most part, the really bad bullies I suffered at school are already failures in adult life. With the one exception of another bully who also got beaten up (not by me) late in the school system - he was dramatically changed after that and is currently one of the nicest and most successful adults I know (although there were other factors swinging in his favour).

So sympathy, but not hippy-love. Violence, but not retribution.

It is a tough balance.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by angrycoder on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:53PM (#1895444)
Well, that is the difference between the bullied and the bully, the bullied feels remorse after committing violence.
Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by bena on Thursday November 11, 2010 @06:07PM (#1895736)
Over-reaction is the only reaction.

If you don't want the other side to escalate, take it there first and do it fast. If you are truly worried about escalation, then by induction, all fights are fights to the death because beating the bully "just enough" will lead to the bully coming back with more firepower. Lather, rinse, repeat until firearms are involved.

So, you over-compensate. You do everything within your power to kill him and hope someone can stop you or they run away. If you don't take shit from anybody, people will stop trying to give it to you.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by varjag on Friday November 12, 2010 @08:47AM (#1897585)
> I'm reminded of what Malcolm X said to the civil rights demonstrators:

Malcolm X, the supremacist dude who had Nazis at his conventions, is a really bad role model for your children.

Edit: why the downvote? He was supremacist, and Nazi connection is well documented: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_supremacy#Alliances_with_...

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by _pius on Friday November 12, 2010 @01:51PM (#1898683)
Your own reference refutes your claim.

From the Wikipedia article:

"In 1965, after breaking with the Nation of Islam and denouncing its separatist doctrine, Malcolm X told his followers that the Nation of Islam under Elijah Muhammad had made agreements with the American Nazi Party and the Ku Klux Klan that 'were not in the interest of Negros.'"

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by varjag on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:14PM (#1898793)
OK, but you don't object the supremacist part? Good, we are on the same page.

Now, notice the "after break-up" part. Have a look at this photo:

http://www.nationalgalleries.org/collection/online_az/4:322/...

She was doing an essay on Malcolm X, these fellas attended one of his conventions. The one in the middle threatened to make a lantern out of her (Arnold is Jewish).

In her later interviews she mentioned that many people get really upset when they see this photo, and exhibition curators often objected to its inclusion.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by _pius on Friday November 12, 2010 @10:45PM (#1900197)
OK, but you don't object the supremacist part? Good, we are on the same page.

Um ...

She was doing an essay on Malcolm X, these fellas attended one of his conventions.

While remaining agnostic to your point, it's troubling that you keep citing references that don't support it. The caption on that photo makes no reference to these Nazis being in attendance at a Malcolm X rally.

Re:Son, as soon as someone puts their hands on you... by varjag on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @03:12AM (#1909478)
I read it in Arnold's interview, years ago in a print magazine.

But I now took an effort to find a reference for you:

http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/features...

Grep the text for "Rockwell".

  Rockwell was listening to a speech by Malcolm X – the Nazis and Black Muslims 
  had formed an alliance – and this was the real reason Arnold was there. 
So as you see my initial point stands. A person who is a supremacist and hangs out with Nazis is a bad role model for children. Would you agree?