News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by renewables on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:19PM (#18950531)
So, knowing the way technology works, one has to figure older legacy systems are painful to deal with. Not always, but usually.

Knowing that most code deployments for server side software cannot claim the benefits of total rewrite from scratch, many of us would love to get a chance at trying exactly that.

What would this assessment look like for a nuke-to-nuke replacement, instead of nuke-to-wind/solar?

In other words, if they abruptly terminated use of all the aging nuclear plants today, and immediately started building totally new, highly modern nuclear power facilities, how would that stack up against this research favoring renewables?

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by wongarsu on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:34PM (#18950591)
Nuclear power doesn't look that great from a cost standpoint once you factor in decomissioning of the plant after use, storing the waste from both fuel and decomissioning (some of it basically forever), etc. A lot of those have been externalties payed by the government, making it profitable for the operating company, but that shouldn't cause us to build more.

If you used modern cutting-edge designs things might look differently, but anything that is actually being built are updated versions of designs from the 70s. Nobody wants to spend lots of money on research and take the risks with building more radical new designs.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by DennisP on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:11AM (#18952477)
Nuclear plants are required by law to save up capital as they go for decommissioning themselves.

They used to be required to pay into a fund for long-term waste storage, and that fund has about $40 billion now. But after the Yucca Mountain project was shut down, the nuclear operators had to store the waste in concrete enclosures on their own properties, so they went to court saying they shouldn't also have to pay the government to do nothing. In 2013 the courts agreed.

There are actually a lot of companies that want to spend money on R&D and build radical new nuclear designs, including Terrapower, Moltex, Terrestrial Energy, Flibe, Thorcon, Elysium, and many others. In the U.S. the NRC makes this extremely difficult.

A couple years ago I got to sit in a meeting between representatives from about a dozen of these companies and a former head of the NRC. The reactor people said their biggest problem was that the NRC requires a near-complete design before they'll even look at it, and then they give a straight yes or no. If yes you still just have a paper reactor, and if no then you're done. The design process costs several hundred million dollars and you have no idea whether the NRC will let you do anything with it. It's a very difficult environment for investors.

The reactor people said just a more phased process would help a lot. The NRC person dismissed their concerns, said it wasn't the NRC's job to help develop new technology or promote nuclear power, and wasn't interested in climate change.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by toomuchtodo on Sunday January 20, 2019 @04:51PM (#18955830)
I can understand that this makes new nuclear development in the US a non-starter. Why is the outlook for nuclear just as abysmal in the UK and China though if their regulators are not as disincentivized to permit innovation?
Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by godelski on Sunday January 20, 2019 @05:20PM (#18955989)
I don't know about the UK, but China has been building new reactors. In fact, that's what's gotten some reactors to a TRL status where they can build them in America.

But from people that I've talked to in the UK, they seem to be more afraid of nuclear than Americans. This seems to be a common trend in Europe. Many people citing radioactive mushrooms from Chernobyl.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by DennisP on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:12PM (#18956224)
China has spent over a billion dollars on molten salt reactors, was partnering with Terrapower on a fast reactor project until the Trump administration stopped it, and has a bunch of other GenIV reactor projects in progress.

Another bright spot is Canada, whose regulators are much friendlier to reactor R&D. Terrestrial Energy has gotten through the hardest part of their licensing process, and expects to have a demo MSR operating by 2025 or so. Seeing their success, Moltex has moved into Canada as well, after making little progress with UK regulators.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by cbhl on Saturday January 19, 2019 @11:19PM (#18951036)
There's probably an actual software rewrite in there somewhere, too. Like, for dual-redundant shutdown routines or something.
Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by toomuchtodo on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:22PM (#18950541)
> In other words, if they abruptly terminated use of all the aging nuclear plants today, and immediately started building totally new, highly modern nuclear power facilities, how would that stack up against this research favoring renewables?

Probably not well.

https://www.technologyreview.com/s/612564/chinas-losing-its-... (China’s losing its taste for nuclear power. That’s bad news.)

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/jan/17/hitachi-set... (Hitachi scraps £16bn nuclear power station in Wales)

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/31/climate/nuclear-power-pro... (U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned)

https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/hinkley-point-managemen... (Hinkley Point management is the perfect illustration of how not to conduct a modern energy policy)

https://www.tampabay.com/news/business/energy/trigaux-abando... (Trigaux: Abandoning another nuclear project, Duke Energy mimics its failed Levy plant)

https://www.wfae.org/post/duke-cancels-florida-nuclear-proje... (Duke Cancels Florida Nuclear Project, Plans Solar Expansion)

Shutting existing nuclear without ramping renewables would be catastrophic. Best case scenario is extending their operating licenses 10-15 years in the future until generation capacity has been replaced. It only takes about a year to replace the generating capacity (including capacity factor) of a nuclear generator (which takes ~10 years to build) with renewables.

In the US, there are 65 pressurized water reactors (PWRs) with a combined capacity of about 65 GWe and 33 boiling water reactors (BWRs) with a combined capacity of about 34 GWe – for a total capacity of 99,221 MWe. ~50% more than this amount of generating capacity is coming online as utility scale solar over the next five years in the US. Five years! Replace the entire nuclear fleet with replacement nuclear in five years? Never.

https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2019/01/01/solar-tsunami/ (Developers have applied to build 139 GWac of large-scale solar projects in the territory of six grid operators – around five times what is currently online across the country – and that figure doesn’t even cover the entire United States. By any metric, we are looking at an unprecedented boom in solar development over the next five years.)

To really get a good idea why this is the case, check out the maps on the right side of https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/#tabs_unit-4, and compare the maps between generating units coming online in the next 12 months to the map of generating unit retirements in the next 12 months. All new generation is solar, wind, and natural gas. All retired generation is primarily coal or nuclear.

To be blunt, no further commercial nuclear generation will be built. Maybe we subsidize renewables more? That'd be swank.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by regnuables on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:33PM (#18950823)
That didn’t really answer the question. It was just a blanket statement that it’d be a bad idea.

The links all just point to trends. The inventory just says the way things are. And then a map of actual plans? Who asked about actual plans?

That wasn’t the question at hand. The fundamental question at hand was the difference between old versus new nuclear technology, whether or not whatever the actual plans are.

But yeah, just drop links and say no. Really great. Top notch discussion.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by toomuchtodo on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:36PM (#18950834)
Several of the links I posted explain that new reactor designs were used, and that estimated cost overruns exceeded almost $15 billion in some cases (South Carolina). Can you be more specific about what evidence you're looking for that nuclear, built today, isn't cost effective besides the various citations I've provided? I've provided more information below, and if that isn't sufficient, feel free to email me with additional questions. The TLDR is "Nuclear kept getting more expensive, renewables plummeted in price, and the growth of energy demand in first world countries plateaued".

From the Union of Concerned Scientists:

https://www.ucsusa.org/nuclear-power/cost-nuclear-power

> The first generation of nuclear power plants proved so costly to build that half of them were abandoned during construction. Those that were completed saw huge cost overruns, which were passed on to utility customers in the form of rate increases. By 1985, Forbes had labeled U.S. nuclear power "the largest managerial disaster in business history.”

> The industry has failed to prove that things will be different this time around: soaring, uncertain costs continue to plague nuclear power in the 21st century. Between 2002 and 2008, for example, cost estimates for new nuclear plant construction rose from between $2 billion and $4 billion per unit to $9 billion per unit, according to a 2009 UCS report, while experience with new construction in Europe has seen costs continue to soar.

Feel free to read the entire blog post to understand exactly why nuclear is so expensive it can't be built. There is also a link to a report the UCS published in 2009 and a financial analysis published in 2011 that goes into great detail.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by pjc50 on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:34AM (#18952558)
> Who asked about actual plans?

It's no use saying it would be great in theory if it turns out not to work or be cost effective in practice. This problem dogs a lot of technologies but nuclear has a particularly bad case of making promises that it doesn't meet in practice.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by Iwan-Zotow on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:31PM (#18950810)
> Duke Cancels Florida Nuclear Project, Plans Solar Expansion

And what Floridians are going yo do at night? Fornicate?