News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CNC milling with open source software by Animats on Friday January 18, 2019 @02:58PM (#18942416)
Yes. This article is about very low end CNC, just 2D routing.

Using a Dremel tool as a CNC router never works very well. The motor isn't constant speed, slows way down under load, and can overheat. The bearings can't take side loads for long, either. It's been tried. A Bosch router from Home Depot works much better. Those can cut wood all day. You can take off the handles, leaving a motor cylinder that can easily be clamped. Also, enclose the electronics in something that will keep the dust out. If the stepper motors are not dust-tight, they also need dust protection.

You need dust removal. Any CNC router doing useful work generates sawdust in huge quantities, much more dust than hand woodworking. Absolute minimum is a Shop-Vac sucking dust from the cutting area.

Trying to make a machine tool from low-end 3D printer parts does not work very well. There are some far better open source CNC wood router designs. The Maslow project [1] is especially clever and very useful, since it can make furniture-sized wood parts on a low-cost machine.

[1] https://www.maslowcnc.com/

Re:CNC milling with open source software by dekhn on Friday January 18, 2019 @05:23PM (#18943670)
I have to repeat the points in this comment. I've worked extensively with low-cost CNCs, and they can't really do anything more than light engraving of aluminum and slow cutting of wood. There are some straightforward physical reasons for this (there is no cheap and fast replacement for mass and torque).
Re:CNC milling with open source software by aj7 on Friday January 18, 2019 @08:33PM (#18944690)
You’re absolutely right. If you’ve been around industrial grade equipment, it’s painful to watch hobbyists fiddle with equipment that is not very productive, and soon abandoned.
Re:CNC milling with open source software by Animats on Saturday January 19, 2019 @01:23AM (#18945631)
You don't even need a commercial product like a ShopBot. There are some good low-cost DIY projects and kits using Bosch palm routers. Repurposed 3D printer parts are far too wimpy for this.
Re:CNC milling with open source software by joshuas on Friday January 18, 2019 @06:00PM (#18943935)
There are two types of dremels in the world, those about to overheat and those that are burned out.