Most of the solutions proposed in this thread for one-off bounties here have already been implemented for years, which is why I am convinced that (with the current level of funding), bounties don't work.
Sometimes, I’d have my company pay $50 to merge a pull request :-)
When I find an issue on GitHub requesting a new feature or reporting a bug that is important to me I should be able to throw down $5+ bucks to incentivize someone to fix it. I also know that I would personally contribute to OSS more if it didn't feel like I was doing community service but rather actually getting paid for my time.
If you want that, you probably should look at UpWork instead of GitHub. Bounties are a nice way of prioritizing things, but most OSS projects won't get the kind of OSS contributions they want for the kind of money they need, simply because the kind of contributors they want can get 10x better pay on the job market, so why they should bother with OS when they can freelance?
Discounting the recent trends of companies open-sourcing stuff to build a market for themselves elsewhere, open source was always, first and foremost, doing a community service. This aspect is why OSS developers put time into it instead of getting extra paid work.
It would still be nice for those who are interested in working on those issues regardless of payment.
A person who wants to pay for a bounty would need to submit an issue, and the maintainer estimate it's complexity. At that point, the person filing the issue could click "Buy this issue" if the maintainer has bandwidth.
Again, not easy -- and I'm sure the UX / business / execution would be delicate.
Some ideas that I frequently wish existed:
1. It would be neat if there was some sort of place in Github where people could upvote interesting project ideas, i.e. "Load testing tool in Go"
2. I'd also love to have a way to say, "I can devote 1-5 hours a week to this project" and be notified when someone tags an issue as 'help wanted'
3. Harder, but still do-able (I think). A place for open sourcers to organize a "team" to get a new project off the ground. I often think that there _must_ be other people interested in the same sort of projects I am -- but we have no way to "discover" each other unless you're some high profile Twitter user.
4. Moderation for trolls. Some people frequently open issues that frustrate maintainers. While they can just create a new account, I think creating a small barrier to entry would do some good.
5. A way for companies / individuals / etc. to donate to maintainers through Github. I think this would be a huge incentive for people to continue their work long-term and not just "hand over" repositories to people with ulterior motives.