News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Thursday January 17, 2019 @02:31PM (#18933793)
Radeon 7 (Vega 20) is a major overkill for gaming though. It looks more like a 3D rendering targeted card. Upcoming Navi cards supposedly should be more gaming oriented and more affordable.
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by vertexFarm on Thursday January 17, 2019 @03:12PM (#18934147)
As somebody who uses my cards for rendering in my freelance work and hasn't played a AAA game since my teenage years, I'm definitely hoping to see AMD kick some ass and competitively drive down some prices. Especially since they actually seem to give a shit about linux drivers. Those saints!
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Thursday January 17, 2019 @03:38PM (#18934393)
Sure. Open source Linux drivers is exactly why I'm using AMD and not Nvidia.
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by TwoNineA on Thursday January 17, 2019 @02:40PM (#18933851)
Not overkill in 4K gaming or high refresh rate gaming.
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Thursday January 17, 2019 @02:42PM (#18933876)
I think 4K gaming is a red herring really. At least at present. Here is a nice video on the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ehvz3iN8pp4

Nice optimum today are monitors with something like 2560x1440 and up to 144Hz adaptive sync. And you don't need Vega 20 with crazy expensive 16GB VRAM for that. Hopefully Navi will fit that use case well and will have less availability issues than Vega 10 (56/64) cards.

Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by floatboth on Thursday January 17, 2019 @03:47PM (#18934471)
There's more to gaming than latest AAA hits and stupid ultra settings. I have a 4K monitor, I play games with an RX 480, it works pretty well.
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Thursday January 17, 2019 @03:55PM (#18934556)
If you have a limited use case - sure. 4K is nice let's say for adventure games that don't require rapid animation. But for more general usefulness, 4K is an overkill that doesn't have affordable GPUs to back it. I'd take higher refresh rate over resolution (to a point) when there is a choice.
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by floatboth on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:30PM (#18935287)
My very affordable RX 480 does 60-100 fps in GTA V at 4K (unless MSAA is turned on which, don't).
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:33PM (#18935314)
Depends on the game. I bet it won't pull that off with the Witcher 3 for example.

I've being using the same RX 480, and it produced ~40-50 fps in TW3 at 1920x1200 on max settings (no hairworks) in Wine+dxvk on Linux. Something like Vega 56 already hits 60-80 fps in the same setup. 4K would be way too heavy for anything.

Also, as the above video suggests, better antialiasing obscures resolution issues. Sure, if you don't use it, you need more resolution to compensate.

Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by floatboth on Friday January 18, 2019 @06:01PM (#18943952)
Yeah, Witcher 3 is pretty heavy, I haven't really played it much yet, but it was okay with tweaked settings and 3200x1800.

> max settings

I don't remember presets in TW3, but I bet there's MSAA and various heavy shader effects enabled.

Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:30PM (#18950376)
It is pretty demanding indeed. But visuals are improved noticeably too, so it's worth it to have a better card for better framerate in it on max settings.

Unlike TW2, it's not using any super crazy double pass anti-ailasing which they called "ubersampling", so it's reasonable on max, even if demanding. But having that and 4K is already too much for any single GPU :)

Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by elif on Thursday January 17, 2019 @03:11PM (#18934144)
> high refresh rate gaming

> up to 144Hz adaptive sync

you are agreeing with him...

In my personal experience, I need every watt of performance out of 2080ti to approach achieve a consistent 180-240hz.

Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Thursday January 17, 2019 @03:30PM (#18934317)
> you are agreeing with him.

Not really. For 2560x1440 resolution you don't need so much VRAM (that's what makes Radeon 7 so expensive). So it is an overkill and not very practical for gaming. It's probably a really good 3D rendering card though.

> I need every watt of performance out of 2080ti to approach achieve a consistent 180-240hz

I think 144Hz is more than enough. More would be an overkill as well. And Vega 64 and upcoming Navi should handle 60-144 fps well at 2560x1440.

Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by elif on Thursday January 17, 2019 @04:31PM (#18934842)
I am happy that 60-144 fps is acceptable for you in the games that you play.

However, your experience is far from an objective characterization of competitive gaming. 60 FPS spikes are called "cancer" in such circles.

Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Thursday January 17, 2019 @04:33PM (#18934852)
Spikes issue is not about > 144 fps really, it's about frame times uniformity. You can have no spikes at 60 fps as well, as long as your frame times are not wildly jumping around. And you can easily have them at high framerates, if something isn't right.
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by Mirioron on Thursday January 17, 2019 @09:27PM (#18936561)
>Not really. For 2560x1440 resolution you don't need so much VRAM (that's what makes Radeon 7 so expensive). So it is an overkill and not very practical for gaming. It's probably a really good 3D rendering card though.

It's overkill, because most GPUs don't have anywhere near that amount of memory and performance, but if they did then games would use up all of it.

Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Thursday January 17, 2019 @11:38PM (#18937079)
Theoretically, anything could happen. But we are talking about existing options, and also how practical they are.
Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by izacus on Thursday January 17, 2019 @04:07PM (#18934630)
This video is a bit silly - the differenences in image resolution on a 65" TV between 1440p and 4K is still very noticable, especially since PC games mostly don't support adaptive resolution tech from consoles. As such, I still had to go with a high-end nVidia to get a non-crappy FPS and good looking UIs in PC games on a TV.

4K gaming might be a red herring on small desk monitors, but more and more of us are gaming on large living room TVs with PCs plugged in next to consoles.

Re:AMD is edging closer to breaking Nvidia's graphic dominance by shmerl on Thursday January 17, 2019 @04:40PM (#18934909)
This video is a bit comical, but it makes a valid point. Consoles and TVs are even worse examples in this context, since they don't even aim at 60 fps, let alone at anything higher than that.

If you are OK with low framerate, then sure, 4K can be appealing. But higher framerate improvements are generally quite noticeable, so console makers try to downplay them.