News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by amelius on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @05:29PM (#18916187)
> That's why I'm always annoyed at the 'another referendum would tarnish democracy' line

I'm annoyed for another reason: first, in 1975, [1], there was a referendum that asked the British people if they would want to join the EEC. Then, in 2016, there was a referendum that asked them if they would want to leave the EU. So if there can be a second, then why can't there be a third?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_European_Union%E2%8...

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by neffy on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @05:37PM (#18916269)
The other precedent is the ratification of the Maastricht treaty, where it was rejected by referendum in Denmark for example 50.7% vs 40.93% - so again very close - amended, and then passed - by a second referendum.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maastricht_Treaty

The failure by both Corbyn and May to acknowledge the need for a second referendum, imho, should raise the question of whether the UK is really a democracy any more.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by flukus on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @07:26PM (#18917166)
> The other precedent is the ratification of the Maastricht treaty, where it was rejected by referendum in Denmark for example 50.7% vs 40.93% - so again very close - amended, and then passed - by a second referendum.

You call it a precedent, I'd call it an example of how undemocratic the EU is. The same situation came up with the treaty of nice and then again with the treaty of Lisbon when Ireland rejected them, the EU love making people vote until the get the "right" answer.

That's why they generally avoid letting people vote on it's continued expansion.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by Zenst on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:21PM (#18916686)
Just after the original vote in 2016, Tusk admitted that the EU needed reform. Cameron (UK PM of the time) in 2015 went to the EU seeking reform, he was palmed of with some token concessions for the UK. 2016 we had a vote, since then it has been a cluster of chaos with every opportunity for personal limelight being sought over any sane approach.

May's deal wasn't a deal the UK was looking for on either side and in effect was a weaker form of what article 50 was and is. Yet also locked the UK into the EU with no say until a final trade deal that the EU approves was agreed. In short, a terrible deal as not only less say than as with article 50, but also given all the cards to the EU when it comes to making a deal. Sheer madness at any business level of thinking.

So what have we got, a divided kingdom instead of a united one. You can go down this side, that side avenue for eons, both sides did some epic flaws and lies.

SO how do we move on.

Firstly - cancel article 50, then reenact it again. That is within EU rules and avoids needing any yay or nay from EU. Bit of a gaming the system, but at least resets the clock and allows time for second referendum. Equally it means going back to the start, but article 50 also allows early leaving.

Yes I agree now, a second referendum is needed; BUT it has to be done in a way that respects the first vote, otherwise you will still end up with a divided kingdom. You do this by combining the results of the first vote with the second vote. You allow again as with the first vote 16 year old to vote and have a say and the final result is what we do and that frankly has to be either. 1) Stay in the EU, but equally get fully behind it this time and fix what is wrong - start by a EU Health Service, that oversight has always irked many with the EU ethos to free access to basics, health being one. Curtly what the EU people want over a Army, least all those I know think so. 2) If we leave, we go WTO, plan for that and if the EU wants to sort a deal out, fine, we will run with a direction and anything else is good. Least can do trade deals with other countries and the whole focus upon the EU at the expense of ignoring those avenues is very blinkered.

But one aspect many overlook. The UK has on many votes in the EU history, singularly or instrumentally held the EU back from advancing, with financial services regulation and taxation being one area that stands out. This hampers how the EU has progressed and as it stands, and been detrimental. So putting the money aside what the UK pays in - has anybody really asked the question of the EU people - is the EU better of without the UK?

I would also add, that a second referendum should see all MP's remain neutral and they all focus on facts, over opinion. Also all avenues are equally explored from a worst to best case and presented to the public. The public love facts and a full picture, let them have that and vote without pontificating peer-pressure. Let it be fair.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by pjc50 on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:47PM (#18916909)
> and fix what is wrong - start by a EU Health Service, that oversight has always irked many with the EU ethos to free access to basics

I don't understand this argument - "give me hard Brexit OR EU NHS"?

> a second referendum should see all MP's remain neutral and they all focus on facts, over opinion. Also all avenues are equally explored from a worst to best case and presented to the public. The public love facts and a full picture, let them have that and vote without pontificating peer-pressure. Let it be fair.

Pure cloud cookoo land. If they were capable of this level of honesty we wouldn't be in this mess. The public aren't too keen on facts either.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by Zenst on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @07:08PM (#18917060)
It was an example, not a one or the other argument, sorry you misinterpreted it, and I can only put that down to how I presented it. My bad, sorry.

As for MP's being neutral, well, it's not impossible, and would be refreshing and well needed change. Otherwise we will just repeat the same old mess with no central point of facts and impartiality to look at for contrast. Making the whole vote a futile mess that will only end up with the same divide, whatever the outcome.

If only the EU stepped back and said we are looking at reforming certain area's, offering up something new to vote upon, at least that would appease the sense of democracy. Otherwise it would be seen as some as another case of the EU not liking the result and being told to vote again. Which is how they will see it, more so as that is what they feared publicly before the referendum and got shot down by the other side for lies.

So to say it is complicated is an understatement. But some grounding is needed and the MP's being neutral and not taking sides, same with parties. Would only help.

But then, much in politics that is flawed and in need of reform. Yet we can't even agree upon a digital voting system, let alone the ability to use more than a single character.

Imagine if Twitter had a limit of one character and you could only post once every 5 years. Think of the level of debate and productivity that would be achieved with such limitations and that is what politics is too the people and we call that democracy.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by jmmcd on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:41PM (#18916855)
> Firstly - cancel article 50, then reenact it again. That is within EU rules and avoids needing any yay or nay from EU.

This is not possible. The recent judgement that UK could unilaterally cancel A50 was predicted on a "good faith" cancellation, not gaming the system.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by Zenst on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:56PM (#18916972)
Actually it is technically viable, going by the judgment. Though I'd still class that as gaming the system. I'm not seeing anything in the judgement that would prevent such an approach.

https://twitter.com/EUCourtPress/status/1072039706123210752

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by jayalpha on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @02:22AM (#18918904)
As far as I know, this was not a judgment but a "legal opinion".

Gaming the system is easier in a codified law system. The not in "good faith" is something from the common law system. I would not bet on it that your approach would work.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by Zenst on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @03:15AM (#18919115)
The aspect of a second referendum would be the good faith balance that would plicate the EU. Though politically such avenues would be along the lines of leaking that option, then asking for extension and face saved on both sides.
Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by makomk on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:24PM (#18916714)
Bear in mind that the second of those referendums didn't happen until two decades after the EEC we'd originally signed up to was massively and fundamentally changed in nature. Now we're talking about having another referendum two and a half years after the previous one, before the result of the last referendum has even been implemented. That's quite a difference and it very strongly suggests that we're only seeing calls for another referendum now because the last one came to the "wrong" result.

(Also, we didn't actually get any referendum on joining the EEC. The 1975 referendum was on whether we'd stay in and came with very similar warnings about the perils of leaving to the more recent referendum. One has to wonder whether, if that'd ended in a leave vote, we'd have had a second referendum several decades sooner than we did.)

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by rst on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:59PM (#18917000)
The second referendum featured a Leave campaign that effectively promised, among other things, continued access to European markets on pretty much as-member terms; indeed, immediately afterwards, David Davis, placed at the head of the negotiations, was promising a deal that secured "all the benefits of membership".

That deal was not available, and so the result of the second referendum cannot be implemented. If you want to claim a democratic mandate for the departure options that are available (May's deal, leaving you tied to the EU on disadvantageous terms, or no deal, and immediate, massive disruptions in cross-border commerce), you'll need another vote.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by rbanffy on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:31PM (#18916765)
I wouldn't say it's because it's the "wrong" result but that only now you could make an informed decision because only now you can see what a Brexit looks like.

To be fair, it could be seen since 2016, but now it can no longer be honestly ignored.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by joshuahughes on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:44PM (#18916879)
I don't think we're seeing "what a Brexit looks like". We're seeing the fumbling of a government who gave the British people a vote in 2016 and whose bluff was called. They didn't want and, more importantly, didn't expect the result they got, and stupidly had done nothing to prepare for it. And for the last two years, they've petulantly gone through the motions of negotiating a deal that they would dearly love to fail. In light of all that, it's entirely unsurprising that the process has been a catastrophic mess. However, it doesn't give anyone the freedom to give up on what most definitely was a democratic decision.
Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by rbanffy on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @05:48AM (#18919749)
I don't think they hoped it'd fail. There was no chance of anything better than the kind of deal Norway has - they pay, obey the rules and have no say - as opposed to what the UK now has - they pay, obey the rules and have a say.

A democratic decision on a poorly formulated question at best. Democracy assumes informed decisions by the people and this was anything but. The leave campaign made every misrepresentation they could in order to paint a rosy future we all knew would never be possible.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by int_19h on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @08:50PM (#18917619)
The second referendum was on the broad question of leave/stay, without the fine details. It is widely accepted that a lot of people voted without understanding the details.

Now there are specific options on the table. It seems only fair to allow people to vote on no-deal, the best deal they could get, or no Brexit at this point.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by specialist on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @07:01PM (#18917017)
Accepting the result normalizes the illegal campaigning and foreign influence.

If the leave decision was truly the will of the people, then holding another referendum shouldn't be a concern, if only to reaffirm the legitimacy.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by sievebrain on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @05:32PM (#18916224)
Maybe there can ... in another 40 years? You seem to be ignoring the rather large difference in time being proposed here.
Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by mpweiher on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @05:59PM (#18916504)
You are ignoring:

a) the narrow outcome

b) the non-binding nature of the vote

c) the fact that leave overspent + cheated

d) the fact that what was presented as "leave" was an impossible lie

  (the cake-and-eat-it option)
e) even if you disregard the cake-and-eat-it faction, both "cake" and "eat it" were under the "leave" umbrella. Doesn't hurt to first settle whether you would prefer "cake" or "eat it" and then hold the referendum.

Oh and of course:

"In a 52-48 referendum this would be unfinished business by a long way." Who said it? Yes, Nigel Farage.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by benmmurphy on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:35PM (#18916791)
In reply to point c)

The government spend £9.3 million pounds sending a pro-EU leaflet to every household in the country. That is more than the £7 million campaign spending cap. This is the leaflet in question: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...

The leaflet doesn't even pretend to be neutral.

I think it is ridiculous to claim that leave overspent+cheated compared to remain. I think both parties played loose and fast with the rules. It just so happens remain is basically in control of the institutions and the bulk of media in the UK so you only really see one side of the story.

Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by flukus on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @05:52PM (#18916416)
That's not a second referendum, it's a fundamentally different one because the EEC is not the EU. If there had been a vote to join the EU (and on the other changes since) then it would have a lot more legitimacy and this mess probably would not exist, one way or the other.
Re:Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament by notahacker on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:34PM (#18916780)
There's a different name to the organization and a different cohort of voters, and certainly there was a case for offering voters a chance to ratify or reject Maastricht and Lisbon treaties (which may or may not have reduced the mess). But the EU fundamentally is what the EEC set out to be in 1957, far more clearly than the current Brexit options resemble the various 2016 pledges about a post-Brexit UK's aims resemble the respective deal and no-deal options actually on the table.

Free movement of workers and capital, common policies in agriculture etc, a European Investment Bank and Social Fund redistributing member states' tax revenues, legislative oversight, a European Council, Commission and Parliament are all in the original Treaty of Rome. The EEC was smaller then, of course, but it didn't hide its intent to invite more countries to join. And the UK completely avoided participating novel EU projects like the Euro that voters clearly didn't want.