IE, using voice commands is a downgrade IMO. Voice commands are not directly discoverable, and there's a lot more magic boxes.
I have yet to find a use case for modern voice control that required more than a passing thought about how to word things. Even my technologically illiterate parents can use these devices with relative ease, especially compared to smart phone and desktop computer UIs. Have you actually tried out these devices or are you just assuming they're as bad as they were 20 years ago?
Compare this to the number of taps required to do so in the hue app
Also, an interaction I had last week:
add x to my shopping list.
ok, I will add x to my shopping list, anything else?
. . .
But I can't add a list, add pears, apples, and oatmeal to my shopping list.
So If I have raw chicken on my hands and want to add shit to my list, it takes so god damn long that I want to punch the fucking thing.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18706651
[1] https://developer.amazon.com/blogs/alexa/post/36ca7d4c-cd98-...
Yes, you're right, the voice interface is not the astronomical leap that the cellphone was. But why is that your cutoff line?
My voice assistants offer a lot of benefit to me. Especially with kids, I don't always have a free hand to pull out the cell phone. When my daughter was an infant, it was super convenient to ask it to play soft music as she was falling asleep without having to put her down. Now it's super nice to be able to set multiple timers as I cook with just my voice, instead of trying to fumble with multiple timers on my phone or stove.
I'm not paranoid to think that they are recording everything, because I understand that there would be no ROI for the company to do so with the storage and bandwidth that would be required. And therefore there really isn't much tradeoff at all. Google is already recording every search I do -- does it matter if I use my phone or my Google Home?