News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by nkozyra on Saturday January 12, 2019 @10:54PM (#18894959)
I don't think the actual study[1] takes the kind of correlation=causation approach this snippet does.

That said ...

> In addition to distributing report cards earlier in the week, schools could consider including messaging to help prevent corporal punishment that crosses the line into abuse. But that’s a sticky issue in Florida, where some counties still allow corporal punishment in public schools. (Florida’s not alone: 19 states still allow schools to hit students, according to the Gundersen Center for Effective Discipline.)

This is absolutely insane. It's 2019. I grew up in Florida and remember "the paddle" from my elementary school days but had assumed it had been stricken by now.

[1] https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/article-abst...

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by educationdata on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:17PM (#18895038)
What is absolutely insane? The existence of "corporal punishment" or "physical abuse"?

According to the quoted sentence ("prevent corporal punishment that crosses the line into abuse"), corporal punishment is not the same as abuse. The article also says: "Corporal punishment may include pain but is not supposed to result in injury; corporal punishment resulting in injury is physical abuse."

So the line is whether the punishment resulting in injury. But it is not clear what is counted as "injury".

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by nkozyra on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:22PM (#18895052)
> What is absolutely insane? The existence of "corporal punishment" or "physical abuse"?

Corporal punishment as administered by schools.

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by educationdata on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:35PM (#18895092)
It is just not illegal, it does not mean the schools or teachers are actually doing it.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by DanBC on Sunday January 13, 2019 @06:05AM (#18896176)
Schools and teachers are actually doing it.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by mirimir on Sunday January 13, 2019 @12:05AM (#18895185)
Yeah. What about punishment resulting in emotional injury?

All that corporal punishment teaches is that it's OK for the powerful to punish the weak.

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by nearbuy on Sunday January 13, 2019 @12:32AM (#18895277)
All punishment results in emotional injury. That's what punishment means...
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by mirimir on Sunday January 13, 2019 @01:40AM (#18895473)
Of course. And punishment tends to produce damaged people, who hate themselves because they're bad. Because, you know, they must be bad, because they've been punished. And because they're bad, and hate themselves, they take it out on others, whenever they can get away with it. So it's a recursive cycle of punishment.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by kabouseng on Sunday January 13, 2019 @02:08AM (#18895542)
Citation needed for that statement. Corporal punishment has been a part of human societies for thousands of years, so you need stronger evidence for such a statement.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by mirimir on Sunday January 13, 2019 @02:44AM (#18895617)
Crime and war have also "been a part of human societies for thousands of years".

> deMause, L. (2002). The emotional life of nations. London, England: Karnac Books.

> Abstract

> Describes a psychogenic theory of history, arguing that childrearing and the interpersonal expression of love impact upon the national and international arenas with greater force than any bomb. The author discusses the role of mothers in political progress, our psychological dependency on our enemies, and the concept of the "social alter"--that part of the mind that infinitely restages social trauma. Furthermore, he delineates the ways in which inadequate parenting and overabundant technology interact to produce the crises of our age. Part I of this book describes how shared early personal experiences determine political behavior. The three chapters describe historically recent political events to demonstrate how shared emotions can cause political violence. Part II details a psychohistorical theory of history, first as it applies to politics and second as it explains the causes of war. Part III is a history of how child rearing has evolved and how more loving, trustful parenting has produced new kinds of human psyches, which in turn have resulted in new social and political institutions. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)

http://psycnet.apa.org/record/2002-17655-000

Also: https://scholar.google.de/scholar?hl=de&as_sdt=0%2C5&as_ylo=...

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by padolsey on Sunday January 13, 2019 @07:58AM (#18896492)
What's funny is that your comment alluding to the generational persistence of punishment indicates the very cyclic nature that you are seeking proof of. Its persistence does not prove its worthiness ('appeal to nature'), only its ability to survive as a trait. What we have to decide is, whatever the mechanism of its survival, what is its efficacy and moral value in today's society.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by kabouseng on Sunday January 13, 2019 @08:56AM (#18896686)
I didn't make a statement as the parent as to the effects of punishment. Making statements requires proof, making extraordinary statements requires exteaordi ary proof.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by educationdata on Sunday January 13, 2019 @11:38AM (#18897319)
"In a review of research on emotions and moral development, the psychologist Nancy Eisenberg suggests that shame emerges when parents express anger, withdraw their love, or try to assert their power through threats of punishment: Children may begin to believe that they are bad people. Fearing this effect, some parents fail to exercise discipline at all, which can hinder the development of strong moral standards."

Here is a very good read: Raising a Moral Child. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/12/opinion/sunday/raising-a-...

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by mirimir on Sunday January 13, 2019 @08:32PM (#18899928)
Yes, "no punishment" <> "no training re moral principals and values". And when you do that with love, without punishment, you get people who actually have moral principals and values, rather than just pretending, in order to avoid loss of love or punishment.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by nearbuy on Sunday January 13, 2019 @02:42AM (#18895609)
This seems like a pretty extreme viewpoint.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by geomark on Sunday January 13, 2019 @06:35AM (#18896248)
There is actually another more important lesson, which is that there is always someone bigger and more powerful than you.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by mirimir on Sunday January 13, 2019 @08:33PM (#18899932)
Well, yes. And so you need better weapons than they have.

Funny story. So I'm a little wiry guy. And back in the day, I used to carry a buck knife in my back pocket. As Logen says, you can never have enough knives ;) But anyway, a bunch of us were sitting around a fire, BSing, and I start cleaning my fingernails with the knife. And this big jolly dude says "It's always you little guys who pull a knife, when we're just having a friendly brawl!"

Funny, no?

Edit: But global nuclear war? Not so funny :(

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by hopler on Sunday January 13, 2019 @08:26AM (#18896587)
The weak clearly can't punish the powerful. If the powerful can't punish the weak, there is no check against criminal activity.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by mirimir on Monday January 14, 2019 @01:38AM (#18901130)
Criminal activity by the powerful is a far greater problem than criminal activity by the weak.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by cortesoft on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:47PM (#18895138)
Corporal punishment is insane.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by sethammons on Sunday January 13, 2019 @09:51AM (#18896862)
Corporal != Abuse. I was a teacher. Kids were not turning in homework. I gave out about 15 minutes worth of it because independant practice is important. Most kids would just not do it. So I instituted a 5 push up policy. You did 5 push ups for every day in a row you did not turn it homework. So your third day would have been 15 push ups. It worked great. Only three or so kids per class would skip homework, and few kept up the trend. This lasted a very short time. When administration heard, they shut that shit down fast as it was considered corporal punishment. Students stopped turning in homework for the most part after that.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by adn on Sunday January 13, 2019 @10:15AM (#18896952)
Hmm, I'm not sure this is as good of an example as you think it is. If the only way to get kids to do their homework was to essentially threaten them with physical "labor" (obviously 5 push-ups isn't much) it definitely feels like there may be larger issues at play.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by sethammons on Sunday January 13, 2019 @10:50AM (#18897096)
Oh, for sure. The larger issues are all the issues that come with being in a poor, inner-city school where there are no real examples of how doing well in school could actually help one's life. Where gangs, violence, and going to prison or jail is assumed to be normal. I had students confused by the idea I've never been arrested and where all the adults in their family (including grandparents) are members of gangs. At this particular school, 4% would go onto any post secondary education. Less than 1% would attain a four year degree. The (majority of) students and their families had zero buy in for school meaning much of anything.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by gizmo686 on Saturday January 12, 2019 @10:58PM (#18894971)
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by educationdata on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:33PM (#18895089)
It is strange that the study does not report raw numbers of instance. How many happened after post card release vs. not after post card release? I can't find the raw numbers of such. Only raw number of breaking down by race.

Also, "Of the 167906 calls to the child abuse hotline for children aged 5 to 11 years, 2017 (6.7%) were verified as physical abuse cases". Only 6.7% verified???

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by gizmo686 on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:39PM (#18895102)
>Only 6.7% verified???

I have complaints about the quality of the study, but this is not one of them. Keep in mind that anyone in Florida who suspects abuse is required to report it to the hotline. Probably more significant is the more traditional mandated reporters, who are trained to report any suspicion of abuse, out of both an abundance of caution and to protect themselves from liability. By design, such hotlines have a high false positive rate.

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by educationdata on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:49PM (#18895142)
I am not blaming the high false positive rate (although itself is problem). The problem is that this kind of high false positive rate has a huge impact on the quality of the study. Be aware the followed analysis does not account for the error in reporting and verification. There are simple too many noise.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by fyfy18 on Sunday January 13, 2019 @02:42AM (#18895611)
I wonder if it could just be that the child abuse workers can more easily verify cases over the weekends. Maybe they need to talk to parents (who are likely working other days) before they can mark it as verified?
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by hopler on Sunday January 13, 2019 @08:27AM (#18896589)
This is such an obvious explanation that it makes me doubt the whole study.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by ebg13 on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:43PM (#18895124)
> Only 6.7% verified???

Verified "as physical abuse cases", meaning that the rest were deemed to not be.

Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by educationdata on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:53PM (#18895156)
Could be. Then the study should report how many were verified as abuse, how many were physical abuse.
Re:To protect kids, don’t send report cards home on Fridays by knappa on Saturday January 12, 2019 @11:12PM (#18895012)
That's a lot of overlap of those confidence intervals in Table 3.