Re:Give Us Our Data, Facebook
by patrickaljord on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @01:04AM
(#1889378)
> I'm glad facebook doesn't give out the email addresses of friends to third parties without permission
The problem is that they actually do with yahoo mail and hotmail http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1889234
When I sign up to Facebook and use their contact list importer, they are using the private email addresses of my friends to link me into their network. When I export my social graph, Facebook will not return to me the email addresses I gave it when I signed up.
Either way, all this bluster is a red herring. The article has it right: Facebook is outright lying when they claim this is about protecting its users--people who have explicitly agreed to include themselves in my social graph in the first place. It's about owning the social graph.
Mh why is it ok for yahoo and microsoft to access my friends email over an api but not for myself or a third party vendor (like google).
http://searchengineland.com/facebook-you-have-no-right-to-ex...
If i want to export all of my data out of facebook why cant i get these kind of informations?
The public seems to not have a consistent sense of privacy. They slam Facebook for being too open by not having a privacy setting enforced as the default, and then slam Facebook again when Facebook isn't advertising emails.
Personally not a fan of all this hot air.