News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by mike00632 on Friday January 11, 2019 @02:55PM (#18886343)
It's not like money paid as taxes just evaporates. It's spent, i.e. put right back into the economy.
Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by dunpeal on Friday January 11, 2019 @03:03PM (#18886421)
Except much of it is spent hiring more bureaucrats whose function is often to hinder economic activity and growth by numerous rules and regulations.

These very same people would be contributing to growth if they worked in the private sector and produced goods and service. Instead, they create either zero or negative growth.

Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by jonhinson on Friday January 11, 2019 @03:23PM (#18886594)
What do those bureaucrats do with the money that is paid with taxes? Spend it on economic activity.
Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by dunpeal on Friday January 11, 2019 @03:28PM (#18886646)
You take a person that could be producing goods and services in the private sector, and pay him to work in the public sector, where he produces no such goods or services, and often is tasked with creating and enforcing regulations that limit economic freedom.

Clearly you're going to end up with lower economic growth.

The fact he would spend his salary on purchases is small comfort, especially when he'd likely earn a larger salary to spend in the private sector.

Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by jonhinson on Friday January 11, 2019 @05:22PM (#18887768)
It's a false premise that taxation does not produce a good or service. E.g. USPS, defense contracts, farm subsidies, etc.

It's not clear that you're going to end up with lower economic growth. For example, taxing some level of income that would otherwise not be spent on economic activity (e.g. savings or equity investments) and spending it on things that do result in economic active results in higher economic growth.

Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by xupybd on Friday January 11, 2019 @03:33PM (#18886689)
Not always, sometimes they try to engineer the economy and kill growth.
Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by chrisco255 on Friday January 11, 2019 @03:05PM (#18886434)
The government is generally bad at spending money efficiently, since they are a local monopoly and have few incentives to do so...which is why markets work better at this.
Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by nitwit005 on Friday January 11, 2019 @08:29PM (#18888867)
That depends on what you mean by efficient.

Let's say you want to build a road that connects 12 houses. You can do that without the government. You just need everyone to agree on who contributes what, who you hire to do the work, what happens if something goes wrong, who else is allowed to drive on the road, how maintenance happens, who polices the rules, and so on, and so forth.

This does occasionally work out in real life, but mostly people bitterly argue over the whole thing and it never happens. Having a government set some sort of policy and doing the planning is usually far more effective, even if it pays more than is necessary for the actual work that gets done. The government may pay more per mile of road, but the road has a higher odds of getting built.

Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by mywittyname on Friday January 11, 2019 @03:51PM (#18886847)
This is a BS statement that doesn't actually say anything beyond expressing this trite idea that government is always bad.

"The government" is not a singular entity, it's a collection of tens of thousands of smaller entities, all of which operate mostly independent of one another and whose relative "efficiency" is based almost entirely on the people working there. One town may have a school or fire department which operates extremely well under a very tight budget, while the town over might poor money into a corrupt and expensive institution which fails to provide more than basic services.

In this respect, it's no different than any other business. Some Walmarts are clean, tidy, and well run, others are a mess. But you wouldn't go around claiming that "The retail" is inefficient because of this fact.

Also, not every government department should be efficient. The military is often held up as the hallmark of an inefficient bureaucracy, but the fact is, we don't want a military that's cost-effective, we want a military that's combat-effective, no matter the cost. But we also have a post office that can mail a letter to the middle of Alaska for less than a dollar.

Your comment about the market working better at "this" (whatever this is, anyway) is equally as lazy.

Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by chrisco255 on Friday January 11, 2019 @05:17PM (#18887727)
The difference (and it makes all the difference in the world) is that as a consumer of Walmart, you can simply choose to shop elsewhere (Amazon, Target, CVS, mom and pop, etc). Wal-Mart cannot survive if it performs under consumer expectations for too long (see Sears, KMart, etc).

Governments are monopolies. The only incentive they have to be efficient is the leadership changes that possibly occur with each election cycle. Given the wide range of services and issues that governments must tackle, it's likely that voters have only a few key issues in mind when they go to the ballot box. With each change in leadership, a different set of priorities takes precedence. Sometimes long standing, mediocre services, continue unabated and unimproved for decades at a time with little to no innovation.

Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by repolfx on Saturday January 12, 2019 @08:59AM (#18891169)
You're right but also wrong - people generalise about "the government" even though it's a large collection of entities because on average their performance is characterisable as worse than "the market" would be. Whilst you can have incredibly efficient and well run government departments, there's no particular incentive for people to run their departments well, doing so is difficult and so the noticeable trend is that they aren't.

The evidence that this stereotype is true is overwhelmingly strong, so, it's perfectly legitimate to set policy around it.

Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by realusername on Friday January 11, 2019 @10:11PM (#18889348)
Depends for what, the private sector is very inefficient to build large scale infrastructure for example.
Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by pessimizer on Friday January 11, 2019 @03:09PM (#18886466)
> It's not like money paid as taxes just evaporates. It's spent, i.e. put right back into the economy.

That's not how taxes work. It actually does evaporate. Money is an IOU from the government that it guarantees it will accept as payment. The government doesn't actually need to give itself an IOU (it doesn't make sense except as a way to keep track of internal accounting obligations); it burns the IOUs it gets back in order to preserve the value of its still circulating IOUs.

It's always important to remember that governments print money, they don't discover it. The government doesn't need it from you, it needs you not to have it in order to keep it somewhat scarce.

Re:South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far,... by mywittyname on Friday January 11, 2019 @04:01PM (#18886947)
Ultimately the purpose of taxes is to force citizens to use the currency the government produces, which in turn, makes their currency valuable to citizens.