Re:An Eve Online corporation has been hit with a GDPR reques...
by zorga on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:14PM
(#18876341)
The US will generally not cooperate unless said thing is also illegal in the US. The EU can ask, they cannot enforce, and the US doesn't make a habit of enforcing laws of foreign nations on citizens when said thing is perfectly legal in the US. If what I'm doing is legal under US law, the EU request will be denied. Only when the thing is illegal in both countries are such requests generally conceded to.
> It's not an EU citizen coming to your US website - it's your US website choosing, willingly, to serve EU citizens.
Wrong, they're coming to my site; I have no way to know they're EU citizens or not, there's a thousand reasons I wouldn't know, it's not like IP is a reliable means. People use vpn's, or EU citizens travel. The burden is not and cannot logically be on me to know where my customers come from. It's impossible to know the citizenship of your customers.
Perfect example, according to the GDPR, an EU citizen travelling in the US who uses my site from the US is still protected by the GDPR; that's horseshit and a technical impossibility; I can't know they're an EU citizen. This law was written by technically illiterate morons.
You have it backwards. It's not an EU citizen coming to your US website - it's your US website choosing, willingly, to serve EU citizens. You can also choose to not serve them - that's fine. And yes, EU cannot fine you in any way, there's no legal possibility to do that. However, if your operation was detrimental to EU citizens in any way, EU could ask US to cooperate in asking you to stop. Obviously US has the jurisdiction to do something about it, there's no question about that.
To maybe give a different example - if you were selling something that is legal in US but not legal in EU, advertising it, selling it and shipping it to EU customers could still get you in trouble, because at a certain point EU will ask US authorities to stop you from sending illegal products to their territory. You are not breaking US law, but countries do cooperate in this manner. Same would happen in the other direction - if someone was sending drugs that are completely legal in EU over to US, they wouldn't be braking EU law - but US definitely and absolutely would ask local authorities to find you and politely ask you to stop. Does that mean US suddenly has jurisdiction in the EU? No - but EU would most likely comply with such a request as a matter of international cooperation.
And yes, the same request sent from North Korea or from China would likely be ignored - that boils down to what I said earlier about negotiating power and international respect. EU countries are very likely to comply with requests like these coming from US, and EU can and does request things from US. It has nothing to do with the issue of jurisdiction that you are so very keen on.
>> I don't have to give a damn about EU law while operating my US business in the US.
Again, if your US business does serve EU customers, then you kind of have to give a damn. Just like an EU business has to give a damn about US laws when doing business with US customers. It's really not a difficult concept to grasp.