Re:AMD Radeon VII: High-End 7nm Vega Video Card
by wmf on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @04:34PM
(#18869155)
Presumably hughes is just making a knee-jerk comment about how 99% of PoW systems are doing useless work. Personally I am very skeptical of any system that tries to do proof of useful work like transcoding; it seems vulnerable to cheating.
Re:AMD Radeon VII: High-End 7nm Vega Video Card
by ericxtang on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @05:44PM
(#18869776)
Hi wmf - I work on Livepeer, happy to clarify on some of the skepticism here.
Livepeer uses cryptographic signatures to prove authenticity of the video transcoding results, and that signature can be used as proof to punish cheaters (if you signed the result, you are responsible for the correctness - and since it's easy to validate whether the transcoding is done correctly, anyone can use that signature to punish you by taking away your stake). If no one cheats, no one gets punished. Since the cheater doesn't know how many people are monitoring the results, their best strategy is to be honest.
Re:AMD Radeon VII: High-End 7nm Vega Video Card
by jMyles on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @05:52PM
(#18869842)
Hey ericxtang. I've met your boy Phillip a few times (that's how I found out about LivePeer) - solid guy. Very good ambassador for your project and all that it can mean for the world.
Re:AMD Radeon VII: High-End 7nm Vega Video Card
by jMyles on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @04:52PM
(#18869321)
LivePeer uses the Truebit protocol for this.
I'm not familiar with the nitty-gritty, but video transcoding seems to me to be something that can be verified much, much more cheaply than performed.
FWIW, I think they're already launched, so do feel free to break it.
I mean, maybe you think their choice to deploy as an ERC20 was a bad choice; fine. But they're not adding any additional computation to the environment.
I don't understand how it's possible to think that LivePeer is bad for the environment without thinking the same thing about, for example, Elastic Transcoder. Your comment reads like a non-sequitur to me.