But I do want to read some functions like conjunctions, and in Lisp, I am forced to call `and`, `or`, `<`, `/`, and pals the same way as log, print, etc. I just don't think I'll ever find:
(and (not (is-blocked door))
(< (height player) (height door))
(or (is-unlocked door)
(has-key player door)))
as readable as: not is_blocked(door)
and height(player) < height(door)
and (is_unlocked(door) or has_key(player, door))
Edit: to expand, I don't think it's a fundamental flaw of Lisp. There could easily be some syntax sugar that lets you specify precedence rules for functions and write them infix, just like Haskell lets you write either `(+) 1 2` or `1 + 2`. It would de-sugar to the same sexpr.I know this can be done as a macro, in fact I did it for elisp several years ago ( https://github.com/rspeele/infix.el ) but it is really just a toy for personal use. If an infix operator system came out of the box and its use was encouraged for certain common operators, I think that would be a net positive, but most Lispers disagree with me there (if I had to guess).
and --.-- not (is-blocked door)
:-- < (height player) (height door)
`-- or --.---(is-unlocked door)
`--(has-key player door)
The other one looks like a bit of a lorem ipsum paragraph to me.Naively I would guess that I would do best on infix exprs and you would do best on s-exprs.
But I could imagine other results, like s-exprs giving me a speed disadvantage but an accuracy advantage (either because I had to read them more carefully or because they eliminate reliance on precedence rules). Or there may be other quirks, like maybe S-exprs read better for larger, multiline conditions while infix reads better on short one-liners with <= 3 operations.
It reeks of effort so I'm not going to make such a site, but I do wonder what the results would be.
"No programming language is more or less natural than Lisp. It is merely a matter of familiarity and the way most programmers were taught."
One obvious problem is that familiarity does matter. Even ignoring all other programming languages, there is a barrier to climb for the vast numbers of beginner programmers who know English and common math notation like f(x) instead of (f x) and x < y instead of (< x y). I've also seen (- x y) be confusing as one incorrect way to read it as English in your head is "subtract x from y".
The other is that for some things, it really does seem like infix notation is inherently preferred by humans. Is there a natural language where conjunctions don't go between terms, i.e. one says "und x y z" instead of "x und y und z"?