Until it's done correctly by any side, nobody is "right" and the way it seems or not is a PR thing. At the very least, one defending the traditional car manufacturers' approaches would at least concede the impetus might never had arisen, or not for a long time, with their closeted and often-unrealized research methods. Especially if it's counter to the traditional income funnel.
The reality is that Silicon Valley is very very good at moving fast and building very high tech solutions very quickly. The car industry isn't exactly known for being fast movers and they were very slow to get on this bandwagon.
I'm sure Silicon Valley has a few things to learn from the incumbent car industry too but let's face it - the car industry is mostly just desperate not to have their lunch eaten at this point.
From every source I've read that's publicly available, SV IS eating the major automakers' lunch. An anecdotal claim with zero evidence isn't enough to convince me otherwise, nor should it convince you.
What lunch are they eating?
In short: the likely explanation for those failures, regardless of bad coding practices, were most likely 100% human error
If I were in your shoes, I totally would have gone there.
Are you saying that Comcast, a company that has a monopoly on internet access, has zero incentive to work on increasing bandwidth speeds and lowering prices for end users?
You see how wrong and colossally stupid your argument is, saying that corporations with essentially a monopoly, without incentive, will just happily increase the quality of their product?
Your argument is so wrong and colossally stupid that I feel like Humanity as a whole, has taken a step back due to the ignorance that has happened here today.
Wait, are you serious? But I mean, I thought the whole point of driving a car in the first place was that you could "move fast and break things!" So, clearly Silicon Valley has the most appealing approach!
He pointed me to GeorgeHotz YouTube channel who developed in the open for CommaAI (now shut down), this company got 8m in funding (small cheese to a VC, but still showed there was interest in the project) and he was just googling answers and training his model on one single video he downloaded of the internet.
The 'play loose and fast' with the rules approach won't fly with self-driving and the car companies are looking to build something that works in the field with as close to imperceptible failures as can be realistically allowed.
The incumbents are building it right, but slow. And I would much prefer that approach if it leads to increased safety