Re:AT&T’s “5G E” network is not true 5G
by stevecalifornia on Monday January 07, 2019 @07:58PM
(#18851932)
Is it too much to expect that TechCrunch should prove in their article that the phone is still on 4G when it says it's on 5G? They are declaring a conspiracy, it's their job to provide evidence. I feel like not providing any evidence is wildly lazy journalism.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
It's all over the internet, so you should be complaining more about this being the next tier above blog spam rather than taking this as TechCrunch's journalism.
That being said, AT&T isn't currently shipping any 5G capable handsets, so a 5G logo popping up on any of their phones is arguably a lie. According to AT&T's stated intentions, they're rebranding LTE with most of the latest extensions as "5Ge" and real 5G will be branded "5G+". None of this is particularly hidden information.
Additionally, none of this is new, AT&T is known for faking this information, like displaying LTE when it might be able to see a tower that's LTE capable, but you're not able to connect to LTE.
ah yes, "e" and "+", the two speeds.
Just like High Speed, and Full Speed.
We're talking about phones that have no 5G radio and thus are obviously not 5G; there's nothing to prove.
Here's an article from 2 weeks ago, with a much larger discussion and the evidence you're asking for. Not sure how this current article is better than the older one. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18736378