She learned to sweep a floor, and I learned that often, when kids aren't meeting your expectations it because they honestly don't understand how to do it. I didn't have a child for a long time after this, but I think of this vignette often.
Even at work with junior colleagues, often they have no earthly idea what the expectations are or how to fulfill them. They need to be taught and just expressing your disapproval isn't going to help.
If we define positive discipline as addressing the behavior and trying to compliment them stopping it, or "encouragingly" and "nicely" enforcing some kind of positive or negative punishment, then it's just kind of making the child more self-conscious and stressing them out for something they can't control. This prolongs the tic.
It's really what it sounds like to me here. It's quite common and nothing to worry about, at least for the first few months. Although in some cases it can lead to more serious long term issues and require intervention, in most cases it's temporary and goes away all on its own. The best thing in most cases is to ignore it. Calling attention to it just stresses out the child and makes it worse.[1]
[1] https://www.healthline.com/health/transient-tic-disorder
But if you can create an understanding of why the action was bad then you can give the person a toolset to understand whether their future actions will be bad. And hopefully you can create a society of people whose behavior is determined by their understanding of right and wrong and not by whether or not they think they will be punished for something.
I think you're grossly oversimplifying the way people work if you don't see the difference here.
Out in the real world, when someone tells you to obey because they are stronger, you tell them to stuff it. It is widely agreed that in society, people need better reasons to be obeyed than that (even if the strong do tend to get their way more often...).
I think what you said about understanding future actions and disconnecting them from punishment is spot on.
Now even a lower mammal can learn instinctively through positive and negative reinforcement. I think the problem is significantly more complex in young humans because the capacity for complex reasoning is there but just not firing on all neurons properly. So your negative reinforcement is more likely at that age to just confound the situation than a simple Skinner box with a rat experiment suggests.
It’s certainly not the case that punishment (or we can say “negative consequences”) are never appropriate. A negative consequence should make sense in the context of the behavior.
Yesterday at the airport, a woman with a young child was waiting in a long line at the airport food court in front of me. She was scolding her child for wandering off. The child had a small backpack of toys which he was dropping on the ground and then was walking off (a few feet) and peering around things playing hide-and-seek. The mother would get angry and scold the child to pick up his bag, and stop wandering off. A few times she chased after the boy and he gleefully ran away from her.
The child was clearly not mentally capable of waiting in the line. The mother was agitated because the line was long, she was afraid of losing her place, and didn’t want to lose sight of her child in a crowded space. So she told the boy if he walked off again she was going to throw away his toys. When he did that, she changed tactics threatening that she would “spank him in front of all these people”. At that point I asked if I could hold her spot for her, and she was able to focus on her child until her turn came.
Now that’s a glaringly obvious example of a child being totally “outmatched” by the difficulty of standing in an airport line. I can barely handle it myself sometimes. But there’s a wide spectrum of misbehavior which ultimately boils down to just being beyond a child’s mental capability, which may be diminished because of lack of sleep, hunger, or something challenging that happened earlier in the day (which could be seemingly insignificant, like a friend wanting to play a different game at recess). Until you stop to ask, it’s just so much so simpler to assume they “just aren’t listening”. It can actually be exhausting sometimes to give the benefit of the doubt. More than once I’ve felt like an ass after jumping to a threat or knee-jerk punishment only to shake my head when my wife steps in and gets to the root cause. Luckily every once in a while the situation is reversed and I get a few of my own saves too.
It never ceases to amaze me how hard parenting is, and how unprepared we go into it. I like to say that kids take an infinite amount of effort to raise.
> children are straight up desperate for attention and affection of their parents
Does it mean that children have a motive but don't have the logical aptitude to get to the goal ?
We assume as adults that children who do things that are not what we want or against our instructions need “discipline” in order to learn they should have made a better choice.
This fails on the most basic point. Young children are, in most cases, not making a conscious choice at all in these cases. They are not thinking in their brains, the same way we adults imagine a conscious decision making process occurs, weighing the concequences and choosing a certain path. They are not deciding to be bad because it is easier/more fun/worth it at that age.
Positive discipline is not actually discipline at all. It is fundamentally a realization that children make “mistakes” because they weren’t actually capable of doing what was asked of them.
The essence of positive discipline is the search for the underlying reason a child is not capable of following your direction at that point in time / for the task at hand.
Barring an exceptional case, (younger in particular) children are straight up desperate for attention and affection of their parents.
Sometimes this is the hardest thing in the world, as a fully functioning adult, when your child is doing something [annoying/destructive/insulting/dangerous/disgusting] after the n-th time you’ve told them not to. Adults respond to punishment / negative reinforcement very differently than [young] children.
In particular keep in mind this is primarily a learning experience for a child to develop coping skills and the ability to regulate their emotions. The skills don’t develop very well from a basis of fear of reprisal in my opinion.
I’m not always able to practice positive discipline with my kids, but I can’t count the number of occasions where I’ve pulled out that tool in response to some stressful situation and watched the sheer relief/release on my kid’s face when they manage to actually communicate outloud to someone that will listen that thing that had them so upset or feeling sad/mad/lousy.