I'd suggest 'Plagues and Peoples' over 'Guns, Germs and Steel'
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies
by james_s_tayler on Monday January 07, 2019 @02:15AM
(#18843388)
Thanks for the recommendation! Plagues have definitely had an important impact on the river of history.
Is there any particular reason to read Plagues and Peoples instead of Guns, Germs and Steel rather than in addition to?
GGS isn't super well respected by historians. Diamond ignores a bunch of conflicting data when presenting his grand theory. It also presupposes a lot about how cultures "win". It's not a bad book but if you aren't careful it is easy to take it to mean more than it does.
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies
by james_s_tayler on Monday January 07, 2019 @03:44PM
(#18849859)
Yeah, that's my impression of it too. I included it because it's very well known and given a lot of people have read it, if it's the only book of that nature that they have read I want to understand what their mental models or their intuitions are regarding how this stuff works.
This analysis is uni-dimensional. There is nothing special about Democracy, per se, or even about standard political issues. We are highly political creates and you'll notice the very same patterns of calling the other side stupid or assuming they have an agenda with regards to basically anything. Though credit where credit is due, I think the subtext is saying "wait, are we in trouble?". That's not an entirely silly notion IMHO. History has shown things can progress and then go back the other way.
We might have left the tribes but tribalism never left us. We have upgraded ourselves a little bit, but there is a long way to go. There are many underlying problems with our cognition that paint a pretty bleak picture with regards to "can't we all just get along?", but all is not lost. Just as The Enlightenment moved people away from relying on Mysticism as a philosophy, there is an ongoing dialectic around these issues that has the chance to birth a new philosophy that can help elevate our thinking further.
In general just being aware of all our cognitive pitfalls, I think, will go a long way and there is also language that goes along with new ideas to help us communicate using new tools.
I'll list some books I've read/I'm reading on the journey to help me figure this out. Most of this paints a picture that says "we need to actively adopt a philosophy where we emphasize digging into the opponents side more, also, yes they likely are coming to faulty conclusions, but still give them the benefit of the doubt as it will strengthen your own thinking."
History (last 14,000 years):
Psychology: Poltics: Communications: