Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies
by UncleMeat on Monday January 07, 2019 @03:35PM
(#18849741)
GGS isn't super well respected by historians. Diamond ignores a bunch of conflicting data when presenting his grand theory. It also presupposes a lot about how cultures "win". It's not a bad book but if you aren't careful it is easy to take it to mean more than it does.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies
by james_s_tayler on Monday January 07, 2019 @03:44PM
(#18849859)
Yeah, that's my impression of it too. I included it because it's very well known and given a lot of people have read it, if it's the only book of that nature that they have read I want to understand what their mental models or their intuitions are regarding how this stuff works.