It's really hard to fault a company for not innovating when nobody else is innovating either. It's a mature product category which means all the low-hanging fruit is gone.
For Apple to really innovate their way back into massive growth they're going to need to find another new product category. I have a really hard time seeing what that may be, as do most observers, I would imagine.
CES 2019 starts in few days, and rumor is that we'll see foldable smartphones there, so there are still some companies innovating, Apple just isn't one of them.
I agree and it’s been true for some time. I was an early adopter of iPhone but went one upgrade cycle with a Windows Phone. It gave me several benefits that iPhone either didn’t have at the time (like wireless charging) or that they still don’t have (easy “child” mode that limits access to specific apps and disables ability to send or read messages).
Wait...
what?
You think making a smart phone fold is innovative?
I don't know man?
I think maybe I'm just crazy or something. I still use my iphone 5, it seems to work fine. I don't really understand why I need to upgrade to the latest and greatest thing every year. But for me, asking me to pay hundreds of dollars for a new phone, when my old phone works perfectly fine, seems a bit silly. And then to say, "But this one will FOLD!!!" just makes me think you're insulting my intelligence.
Even just straight up copying the folding tablets from Westworld, it would change how I interact with technology to have a device that spans pocket sized and tablet sized.
A tri-fold phone could be a really big deal for me.
To be clear, the screen itself folds.
I'd say that is a pretty nifty innovation (assuming the quality of the image is still comparable to non-foldable screens). Not sure it'll work as for the UX, but technically it is quite an advancement.
Hard time seeing what’s next indeed!
So, if they manage to make the watch a ‘necessity’ in the health market, it can become very, very big.
https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=apple%20watch%20growth
It is growing the smartwatch market exponentially. Not as fast as the iPhone for sure, but that’s to be expected.
More to the point, I get the impression that Apple expected more growth than occurred already by the initial effort and marketing they put into watch. All of the hoped for growth hasn’t come yet, though it could still come in the future.
I think what they are looking for is a wearable (Apple or otherwise) being seen as a must have device, which isn’t the case in 2019.
Also - why do you keep saying Apple ‘expected more’?
It’s a multi billion dollar business and a growing hit.
You talk about hopes for growth that hasn’t come, but is that just an impression?
The area displaying watches was at least twice the size of the previous version, and more central. They also had a much more deluxe area in accessory section displaying watch bands much more visibly.
I see all kinds of people with Apple watches around here. The entry level black sport band model seems to be the default men’s watch.
We can see this with for example laptops (and PCs though that's an older example). The laptops of this decade are all still useful unless you're a hardcore gamer. And even for gamers (a specific market and niche) the need to upgrade their gaming laptop is lowering if they're OK with not the latest of the latest settings.
We should also take price into the comparison. A phone costing between 1000 and 1500 EUR is a lot of money for people.
Finally, we should take into account Apple's biggest competitor: the second hand market of iOS devices. Everything older than 5S still works with the latest iOS.
People who had ultrabooks, often try Atom based notebooks and sufraces. The key deciding factor for such people, I think, is having a good screen and bearable ergonomics (no microscopic keyboards, or batteries.) The data I have access to tell that the "big screen, small CPU," is the category with the biggest year on year growth. Atom based 14 and 15 inchers are selling like hot cookies.
As a person working in the industry, I can say that's a very visible trend. People switch their devices more due to battery and physical wear than actual need for more features.
In that respect, things got very "Japanised" in respect that Japanese cellphone makers are often making new models every season with no real changes other than cosmetic.
Japan is also the only developed market where "dumbphones" ever saw few upwards trends in last 5 years.
Software too. The kids have stopped using MS Office. They do all of their schoolwork in the cloud.
I also wonder if the downgrade is influenced by optimism about technology being replaced by a dread of being manipulated and harmed by it.
The product segmentation is confusion here. Pentium Silver (N5000) actually has more performance than Core based ULV Pentium Gold.
People who buy "big screen, small CPU" are not your usual refurbished hardware buyers, I think they really are "socially antipodal" to them.
Some bling and, "freshness" is definitely a deciding factor for them, unlike to people who buy "refurbished ABS plastic slabs" office class hardware.
Asus has a 15 incher that they sold close to $600 just half a year ago that was Atom powered. It was a very basic machine, with a surprising pricetag.
No wonder, every OEM is already on the trend.
And that's exactly the issue. Watch movies and web browse, oh come on... put a high-quality distro on it and 4GB is plenty enough for a snappy, solid, general purpose machine. Put another 4GB in it and you've basically hit workstation class, while Windows 10 needs as much just to be barely usable! Like, this makes no sense to me actually. It's so far out of a sensible perspective.
Look at Electron apps. A chat app takes more resources than my entire computer used to have and doesn’t do significantly more.
The neural engine on the A12, for instance. Tiny power consumption and massive performance could be a game changer. But it isn't because there is nothing in the user space that needs it, yet.
And really Apple's game isn't to usurp last year's phone in some massive way -- it's to compel the year before to upgrade. e.g. an iPhone XR or XS for the iPhone 7 user. Even that is getting tough because the devices were already so good that outside of battery decay many users are 100% pleased.
It was an inevitable outcome that the market would mature, and there is very close to nothing that Apple could do but push to additional markets. They foolishly tried to make up the difference through extra premium pricing and that was just folly.
I don’t define innovation as improving things for the sake of it. I think of it as delivering meaningful improvements to the end user.
To me, Apple has been the master of this kind of innovation.
Your point about the A12 neural engine proves what I’m saying.
I’m not saying Apple is resting on it’s laurels - that’s something of a straw man. I think what Apple is achieving technically is outstanding.
I also don’t accept the inevitability of the ‘outcome’ that Apple has fully satisfied people’s needs or that the market would ‘mature’. Most of the ‘needs’ that the iPhone X serves didn’t even exist when the first iPhone came out.
The idea that the iPhone X represents the pinnacle of what a pocket computer can do for a human being seems almost absurd to me.
If you think about it as a bicycle for the mind, as Jobs famously did, almost every dimension of the system has room for more depth.
I’d like to assume Apple knows this, and that there is a lot more to come.
However I still think that in terms of the pipeline of delivering innovation to end users, it’s fair to say that the iPhone is in a patch of friction.
Didn't they? It takes pictures. It sends emails and messages. It watches media. It listens to music. It plays games. It's a web terminal. It's an alarm clock. All of these needs most certainly existed, and the iPhone has sold billions of units by fulfilling those needs beautifully in a more convenient, portable fashion.
Of course the market matures. Beyond some hand-wavy nebulous conjecture, there is a limit to what the device can do without getting into science fiction, especially when your basis of comparison is one year over the next. If the complaint is that Apple hasn't completely upset everything in a single year, that's a completely unreasonable, irrational expectation.
At one point, the iPhone itself was science fiction. The iPhone X was science fiction when the iPhone came out.
Even after the iPhone came out people continued to be dismissive of its potential.
By all means be like them and believe that pocket computers are now done.
My point is twofold - one is that I think there is a huge room for continued progress in this field.
And the other is that the path of progress of the iPhone has involved delivering significant capabilities that enabled people to interact with it in new ways, and this has driven demand.
The rate of delivering those new ways of interacting has slowed.
We both agree on that.
But you think that’s because there is no more progress to be made and that pocket computers will not gain meaningful new features.
I don’t believe that.
Which is of course absurd. But you are jumping between "not enough change over a year" and "over an infinite timeline imagine what is possible". Try to rationalize your thoughts.
“Beyond some hand-wavy nebulous conjecture, there is a limit to what the device can do.”
And you are the only person taking about infinite timelines.
I’m simply saying that year over year, Apple has typically had significant features to drive adoption, and that has slowed. But it doesn’t need to have, since there is much more to be done.
I don’t know why you’re talking about infinite timelines, but you are saying the market is matured and the job of the smartphone is done.
We just disagree about how much innovation is still possible in the space.
Their own "innovation" was raising the prices, and saying ", the only viable strategy it was left with was to raise prices to extract higher rents from its existing user base" is just ignoring elasticity and demand.
"Sure, just make your customers pay more, that will work out fine" yeah, right
Depends on your definition of “significantly better experience”. For example, you can adjust the depth effect on iPhone XS/XS Max while framing/shooting a photo, whereas on iPhone X this is possible only in post. And that’s just one of the differences.
People buy new iPhones when they offer something new and meaningful they they are going to appreciate.
The iPhone XS simply doesn’t offer a significantly better experience than the iPhone X.
It is better, for sure, but not in any way that the iPhone X doesn’t already excel.
In previous years, even S models had significant new features. And speed used to really matter to how the device felt.
Both of these seem like rectifiable conditions.