News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diet hacker data point by ceejayoz on Monday November 08, 2010 @02:04PM (#1883520)
I think you're getting downvoted because it doesn't matter what he cut out - it matters that he was eating a caloric number conducive to weight loss.

He could've eaten 1800 calories of steak, grains, and fruits each day and lost weight, too. It's just a lot easier to count calories for junk food, as the amounts are right there on the package.

This diet was by no means healthy. It was simply a weight losing diet. Long-term, it'd be hell on your body, but it's an interesting approach to quickly bringing weight down (after which one'd hope he'd switch to a nice healthy diet).

Re:Diet hacker data point by mrj on Monday November 08, 2010 @02:15PM (#1883570)
Well, that's why I called it confounding, if he maintained the same diet and cut calories, that would be a much better experiment.

Instead, he both cut calories and massively altered his diet, so there's no telling why he lost weight. I mentioned cutting meat as confounding his results, but the other alterations count just as much, too.

Both the article and the diet are sloppy. Yes, he lost weight but even the nutritionist can't explain why, or even if it's a good idea to eat Twinkies for meals.

Re:Diet hacker data point by tbrownaw on Monday November 08, 2010 @03:34PM (#1883872)
> there's no telling why he lost weight

Fat has about 3500 kCal/lb. If you consume fewer calories than you use, you will lose weight based on that ratio and your calorie deficit. Doing it wrong just means that your body tries to work against you (makes you hungry, makes you tired, makes you want to put on a sweater, etc) and you feel like shit, but for as long as you manage to stick to it you will lose weight.

Re:Diet hacker data point by techiferous on Monday November 08, 2010 @02:12PM (#1883558)
"I think you're getting downvoted because it doesn't matter what he cut out..."

I agree that this is probably why mrj got downvoted. However, mrj's comments are valuable and further the discussion, so I really wish people didn't downvote.

Furthermore, mrj could be right and the article's point--that cutting calories is all you need to focus on--could be wrong. That's the point of science: to form a hypothesis and then test it with multiple trials and multiple studies. If he got back up to 201 lbs and then did the same diet again but with fruits and vegetables instead of junk food, maybe he would've lost weight faster? Who knows until you do it?