News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by hirundo on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:33AM (#18823540)
I tried eating a meat-only diet for a few months, and have mostly continued with some veg added. What I've found is that this is the most satiating diet I've ever tried after five decades of trying. I've also done a lot of high fat paleo, so I'm sure that for me the satiating element is the protein. I've also been a raw vegan and about everything else in between.

Protein fills me up and makes me stop eating far faster than the other macro nutrients. So I'm not worried about getting too much. Unlike with say low quality carbs, high quality proteins are self limiting. My body just tells me no more! If I want to know if I'm genuinely hungry I just ask myself if I want some meat. If not, I'm not.

IMHO, after a lifetime of mostly failed experimentation, (for those of us who can afford it) putting high quality high protein foods at the center of your diet is the most effective way to control and reverse obesity.

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by JofArnold on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:16AM (#18823735)
Meanwhile I eat pure vegetarian (almost vegan) diet that’s low in protein (comparatively), am always sated, have a lot of energy, am strong and slim and rarely sleepy during the day.

So one piece of anecdata seems to refute your piece of anecdata. Not to mention I’m willing to bet I’m far less likely to get cancer and kidney problems than you (assuming everything else equal)

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by gnulinux on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:42AM (#18823927)
If we're going to speak in the language of anecdata, I must say that I tried every diet out there tried for months (all vegan, vegetarian (vegan+eggs+cheese+milk), pescetarian (vegan+salmon), rice and bean based, all meat, all meat + avacado....) And vegan diet was by far the worst (makes me feel bad, did consistently ~40% of my performance working out.) I can go on hours to advocate my own favorite diet, but this is essentially horseshit.

Also there is no conclusive evidence meat correlates with cancer. Unprocessed meat anyway.

Your comment comes of very condescending. I'm sorry, this is not intended directly to you, but this is a problem widely present with vegans. We have 5 people talking about diets, and if one them is vegan, they'll be dominating the whole thing and claim everyone else is unhealthy and clueless. This is not fact based and does not support good discussions.

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by JofArnold on Sunday January 06, 2019 @11:07AM (#18838968)
Regarding not feeling well on a vegan diet, have you considered whether it was due to your gut bacteria not having adjusted yet? I was very much a carnivore for the first 32 years of my life (I was a hunter and came from a hunting family) so it took me a couple of months to adapt to a vegetarian diet due to the greatly increased fibre.

I didn’t mean to come off condescending but I did mean to attack. Recommending a high meat diet in this world is like recommending people drive gas guzzlers. It is irresponsible and selfish. The time for that behaviour has gone and we all need to be willing to give up a few things for the future of the planet.

Regarding vegans being very pushy (I am not one and don’t intend to be) I think that’s reasonable. It is unquestionable scientifically that the world will be better off if people didn’t eat meat. Given that, why would you not want to push hard for change?

On a more individual vegan diets absolutely are more healthy. The longest lived people in the world (subtracting genetics) are vegetarian or vegan. I cannot fathom how you could think otherwise; I mean just look at stomach and colorectal cancers. Figures are very clear.

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by gnulinux on Sunday January 06, 2019 @02:55PM (#18840208)
> I didn’t mean to come off condescending but I did mean to attack. Recommending a high meat diet in this world is like recommending people drive gas guzzlers. It is irresponsible and selfish. The time for that behaviour has gone and we all need to be willing to give up a few things for the future of the planet.

This sort of rhetoric does nothing except taking the guilt from producer and regulator to the consumer. If we think there is a problem with meat production, there certainly is, then we need to regulate meat industry instead of harshly judging meat-eaters with hope of making them feel enough guilt to turn vegan. This is childish. The reality is we don't have enough power to regulate meat industry so we just turn into shaming our peers, something we do have power to. But this is an ineffective method.

> On a more individual vegan diets absolutely are more healthy. The longest lived people in the world (subtracting genetics) are vegetarian or vegan. I cannot fathom how you could think otherwise; I mean just look at stomach and colorectal cancers. Figures are very clear.

No they are not clear, vegan diet is absolutely not the healthiest period. The research on this matter is very vague and pretty much no one knows, pretending otherwise is intellectual dishonesty. Up to last 20 years we thought fats are evil and cause heart disease, which is wrong and now we know fats and cholesterol do not correlate with heart disease. We thought fibers are important to prevent constipation, which recent research shows otherwise. We learn more and more every day how important Omega 3 is.

The only countries in the world with a significant vegan and vegetarian population are India and Mexico [1] and the rest only has vegans as a single digit percent minority. Also, pretending "Mediterranean diet" is meatless is horseshit. I was grown up with Mediterranean diet, and people do eat fish or meat quite regularly, except proportionally much much less. Pretty much everyone I know from my childhood ate Mediterranean diet, and I know absolutely no vegans except the ones I met in US. I do not necessarily advocate eating meat every day, but there is simply no evidence suggesting taking it completely out of your diet is a good idea. Hell, there is substantial evidence suggesting taking fatty fish out of diet is a bad idea.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vegetarianism_by_country

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by vinceguidry on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:19AM (#18823751)
There's no need to get defensive. Merely sharing one's experience need not be an attack on yours. You didn't have to refute his anecdata.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by JofArnold on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:27AM (#18823810)
One has a duty to refute poor advice - especially when OP is making general recommendations based one a single data point and where said recommendations are demonstrably bad for the environment, animals and his own health.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by saurik on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:25AM (#18823797)
I did not read that comment as "defensive": it is merely "powerful" (which is good).
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by vinceguidry on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:08PM (#18827213)
Perhaps because you agreed with his sentiment.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by m_eiman on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:57AM (#18823636)
Have you tried a high-protein vegetable based variant of the diet? Curious if it’s protein in general that works, or specifically meat.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by maliker on Friday January 04, 2019 @04:55PM (#18828042)
There's some good evidence that protein is more filling on a per-calorie basis than other foods [1].

But there's also a lot of other foods that are primarily carbohydrates and more filling than meat. Boiled potatoes, oatmeal, apples, and oranges all beat beef, eggs, and lentils in the above study.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7498104 and full text https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Peter_Petocz/publicatio...

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by moltar on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:57AM (#18823638)
Exactly same experience. Tried vegetarian, vegan, paleo, strict paleo, carnivore.

My actual best was eating beef only. I lost 6kg in a month without trying to lose weight. I had almost no hunger. I ate at 6pm my first meal on a couple of occasions, and normally wouldn’t feel any hunger until 1-2 pm.

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by icebraining on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:07AM (#18823691)
Losing 6kg in a month seems good if one if overweight, but not a sustainable diet; did you change it after hitting a good weight?
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by moltar on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:43PM (#18829100)
I was skinny-fat. It did plateau when I lost the excess.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by TheBeardKing on Friday January 04, 2019 @09:44AM (#18824323)
Have you tried like, you know, a regular healthy, balanced diet? Real foods, mostly plants, not too much? Just funny you didn't include that. As a side note, the Mediterranean diet has been ranked the top diet by nutritionists several years running.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by QuantumAphid on Friday January 04, 2019 @09:57AM (#18824410)
Is there an official specific Mediterranean diet? Is it the Mediterranean of Spain, Italy, Greece, Turkey, Lebanon, or Egypt, etc.? And from what era/period, because my understanding is that those places are seeing significant increases in chronic metabolic disease as well.

From what I've read, Mediterranean means something sorta along the lines of "natural whole foods, not much meat, lots of olive oil nuts and salads" -- and this is vague nutrition advice which can apply to almost any non-exclusionary diet.

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by TheBeardKing on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:07PM (#18826182)
I really don't know, as I don't really research diets and just see that headline year after year. My point was just that, as you said, the most recommended diet isn't going to be one with some sort of gimmick - limit your cals to this number, your carbs, to this number, only eat during these times, don't eat this one entire food group, etc. The general guidelines of Mediterranean diets seem pretty good to me, and I'm totally on board with a little red wine every day.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by QuantumAphid on Friday January 04, 2019 @05:08PM (#18828144)
I agree that this sounds like a pleasant and sustainable diet. However, like many diets, it all depends on your starting point. I'm skeptical that this is an effective weight-loss diet in the sense that an obese person or someone with a chronic metabolic illness (CVD, T2D, high blood pressure) will lose weight on. Anecdotally 5 years ago I followed this diet about and I put on weight.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by moltar on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:45PM (#18829105)
I’ve tried many diets. Including, ofc, just what some people would call a “balanced diet” whatever that even means. I’ve been experimenting with diets for fun for about 12y now.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by adriand on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:02AM (#18823660)
No judgment here (do what you need to do) but this is both bad for the environment and bad for your health (cancer, heart disease, etc.)
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by justtopost on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:19AM (#18823752)
That is judgy as hell, and untrue. Come back with facts or stop pushing your agenda.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by dang on Friday January 04, 2019 @09:08PM (#18829444)
Flamewar comments like this will get you banned here. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and don't post like this to HN.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by adriand on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:30AM (#18823831)
The scientific basis for links between red meat production and environmental harm due to greenhouse gases, and between red meat consumption and harm to individual health, is well established.

I’m not here to criticize the choices of one individual - I genuinely don’t care - but civilizationally a reliance on beef for the majority of our protein requirements would be a singularly poor strategy.

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by graeme on Friday January 04, 2019 @10:16AM (#18824538)
There's one thing I've wondered about beef and greenhouse gases. People say that cows produce co2. They also say that an increase in the human population does not produce co2.

It seems that either one claim is wrong, OR cows are somehow different from humans in their effect on the carbon cycle.

One notable difference is that cows produce more methane than we do. This has the effect of increasing short term warming as methane has a much more powerful warming effect over 100 years.

But other than that, when cow emissions are cited, are people simply adding up the co2 cows breathe? If so, why is this invalid for humans? Or if it is valid for humans, then how are cow emissions determined?

I could see land use change being one reason, but that would seem to apply to humans too. Can anyone clarify this? It would seem that either both humans and cows are net co2 contributors, or neither are. (Apart from methane)

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by lookACamel on Friday January 04, 2019 @11:09AM (#18825017)
They're talking about the methane, and also about using land to grow grain for feeding the cows.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by graeme on Friday January 04, 2019 @12:17PM (#18825708)
So in the latter case, more humans do cause co2 to the extent we each need food and land uses changes to provide that food.

In the case of cows, it's the same calculus: land use change to feed us. Just, more land use change in the case of cows.

So, therefore, a cow raised on pasture that isn't suited for other farming wouldn't be especially co2 producing by that measure, correct? Apart from methane.

So, we could reduce cows contributions to:

* Eliminating their methane (seaweed experiments, etc)

* restricting cattle to land suitable for pasture but not so suitable for crops

If cattle were only raised in those cases, that would effectively negate their warming impact?

This would still mean a massive reduction in beef and much higher prices of course.

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by moltar on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:49PM (#18829118)
That is an example of excellent critical thinking skills.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by graeme on Saturday January 05, 2019 @09:17AM (#18831727)
Thanks! The cow emissions thing has had me confused for a while.

I looked into it a bit further, and it seems cows produce more methane on grass, which is not good. I don't know if those seaweed proposals work on a grass based diet, or if they're only for cows largely fed grain.

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by eaenki on Friday January 04, 2019 @09:54AM (#18824384)
What about Googling "meat cancer" and then filtering by .edu and .gov domains? Or just go to Google Scholar. Then repeat for "greenhouse emissions meat".

If you're not helpless, out of thousands of papers you'll find some sources you deem "true and hella reputable".

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by alguem on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:54AM (#18824026)
Humans as primates falls under family that is mostly frugivores (meaning eats more fruits than anything else) and also there is a fact that no other animal on earth needs to cook stuff to make them edible: https://www.precisionnutrition.com/all-about-cooking-carcino...
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by QuantumAphid on Friday January 04, 2019 @10:13AM (#18824518)
Hmm. Why is it that humans spread across the planet to geographically diverse places and climates, many of which are sorely lacking (if not completely devoid) with regard to availability of fruit?
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by moltar on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:52PM (#18829128)
That is nonsense. Lots of population lives in places with zero fruits in the winter.

Inuits live in the north of Canada. Their ONLY food source is seals all year round. They are fine in terms of health. Their health declined with introduction of modern foods brought in by researchers and other visitors.

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by virtuallynathan on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:21AM (#18823762)
I can definitely confirm this, meat only I can go 23h+ without eating and not be hungry, consuming ~2000kcal at a meal.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by stef25 on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:40AM (#18823565)
I think the satiating element is the fat rather than the protein, no?
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by graeme on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:50AM (#18823605)
Protein is considered to be the most satiating. This review article calls it "fairly well established"

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092422441...

Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:23AM (#18823780)
However, like carbohydrates, protein does trigger ghrelin response whereas fats do not. At least in my case, a high-protein diet did nothing for my cravings.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by hirundo on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:49AM (#18823599)
I've performed that experiment repeatedly ad nauseum. For me the protein makes me push the plate away faster than the fat and leaves me not hungry for longer.
[dead]
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday January 04, 2019 @08:07AM (#18823692)
"Satiating" has a very specific definition when it comes to appetite, and it's used correctly here. I don't see the problem.
Re:Protein mania: the rich world’s new diet obsession by hirundo on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:47AM (#18823587)
I think it's different. I can be highly satisfied with a bannana split ice cream, but hungry again far sooner than after eating steak.