Re:Half of Milgram’s subjects told him to take a hike
by srbloom on Monday November 08, 2010 @01:31AM
(#1881624)
I guess your satisfaction with this result depends on your prediction.
Also, judging by the comments section on that site, presenting the result this way ("50% refused" instead of "50% complied") has a significant impact on how people respond to the result.
Re:Half of Milgram’s subjects told him to take a hike
by wisty on Monday November 08, 2010 @02:30AM
(#1881741)
Brilliant observation. People respond very differently to the same fundamental numbers if you present them differently.
Re:Half of Milgram’s subjects told him to take a hike
by JoachimSchipper on Monday November 08, 2010 @04:19AM
(#1881906)
Scientists doing an experiment may well use very formal speech, and it stands to reason that (sufficiently well-educated) subjects adapt.
Re:Half of Milgram’s subjects told him to take a hike
by sliverstorm on Monday November 08, 2010 @01:28AM
(#1881614)
"the most insane of orders"? I'm sure there's more insane than painful or dangerous electric shock.
In regards to his lines, I'm pretty sure the abundance of "um"'s in speech is a recent phenomenon
Re:Half of Milgram’s subjects told him to take a hike
by stellar678 on Monday November 08, 2010 @01:49AM
(#1881673)
I dunno man, disfluencies like "um" are an integral part of language. I'd put my money on them being plenty common in everyday language 45 years ago.
Re:Half of Milgram’s subjects told him to take a hike
by sliverstorm on Monday November 08, 2010 @02:32AM
(#1881743)
No, I totally agree with you, but there was a very specific period a handful of years ago I noticed people seemed compelled to fill any dead air whatsoever between thoughts with literally strings of "um"'s... So much so they'd still be saying an "um" after they were ready to say the next word (you could tell by their face and speech)
Re:Half of Milgram’s subjects told him to take a hike
by nl on Monday November 08, 2010 @03:30AM
(#1881832)
People have always used fillers (aka filled pauses) in speech. There is no evidence to suggest they have become any more or any less common.
For example, http://separatedbyacommonlanguage.blogspot.com/2008/05/uh-er... cites a play by Agatha Christie (who dies in 1976) which is full of um's (using the British spelling of erm).
Also, does anyone else feel like the subject's (Man Two's) lines were scripted, or did people talk that way often back then?
Edit: replier is right, 'most insane' does not fit here.