Re:OpenSCAD: Software for creating solid 3D CAD objects
by tcas on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @01:22PM
(#18808556)
In regards to number 2. You can have variables and parameters in Fusion360 -- I use it all the time for adding a tolerance variable and stuff like wall thickness, length, width etc...
Are configurations significantly different?
Re:OpenSCAD: Software for creating solid 3D CAD objects
by saidajigumi on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @04:56PM
(#18810643)
Yes, let me clarify. Variables and parameters in a model, which are then driven by a data set are what configurations give you. E.g. some CAD suites allow a CSV/spreadsheet to drive the configurable parameters. OnShape allows for a table-per-variable, avoiding the need to manage combinatorial explosion in the rows of your config table. Alibre Design simply adds configurations as named entities within a model file. While not driven by external data, it allows complete integration into the editor environment which has upsides for my work. (I don't work with big configuration tables, so this works great for me.)
Some suites also allow configurations to enable/disable parametric features. At the simplest, this lets you add boolean changes to the configuration table, like "has mounting holes?" or "is/isn't a full-thread screw" and so forth.
[1] not yet money-making, so still akin to "hobbyist" in needing to keep a constrained budget. I absolutely agree with the parent that the per-seat costs seem high, until you factor the costs of your skilled staff in a real work environment.
[2] Imagine you want to model a cap screw, but have just one master model for all of the diameter/length/{fully-threaded, partially threaded} variations. Updates to the model are then sanely propagated to every variant. You don't have to go very far down this path before manually keeping separate models in sync will drive you nuts. That's the problem that configurations in CAD s/w were created to solve.