News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whatever happened to chatbots? by AznHisoka on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:31AM (#18806340)
This article does a good job explaining why they were overhyped: https://blog.growthbot.org/chatbots-were-the-next-big-thing-...

Basically, people were too occupied with the fancy technology, and forgot about actually solving problems. People want to get things done, and clicking and choosing options in a GUI is already an very efficient way of doing so.

When they want to do more complex things, we don't want to talk to a chatbot, only to eventually get an useless response like "Sorry, we can't do that request online. Please call us" (if I wanted to call someone, I wouldn't be using you!)

Re:Whatever happened to chatbots? by fatnoah on Thursday January 03, 2019 @05:17PM (#18819896)
I have a fair amount of experience in a related field, which is messaging-based service and came to the article is spot-on. Some companies simply wanted to map their phone support flows to messaging (yuck!) and others wanted to do more pre-chat type of activities, such as getting basic information from the customer. For these latter use cases, some level of "AI" was useful to let a customer communicate with more natural language rather than having to enter a specific number or keyword, but you still essentially ended up with an analogue of a phone system.

In my case, a goal was better agent efficiency (i.e. fewer agents handle more customers) AND happier customers. A sweet spot for these chatbots was for them to handle specific interactions but not the whole conversation. For example, handling some basic pre-chat information gathering, or in the case of an interaction around rebooking a hotel stay, handling the date and room selection when using a medium that supports rich messaging, such as FB Messenger or iMessage.

Until we have fully conversational chatbots, it's going to be really hard to have a solution that a) eliminates agents from the equation AND b) results in higher customer satisfaction.

Re:Whatever happened to chatbots? by sethammons on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @06:19PM (#18811309)
I recently attempted CenturyLink's chatbot for support (it is a hurdle to attempt to alleviate support chats). It got to a prompt, something like:

    You can give me your membership number or phone number. Which would you prefer?
    1) membership number
    2) phone number
If you type "phone" or "phone number," it would not understand you and take you back a couple of levels in its internal hierarchy. Apparently it wanted you to type "1" or "2." Grrrr. It is a terrible interface. Automated tellers, chatbots, all of it, it shows utter disrespect for the customer. Give me a live person or a great web experience (preferably both).
Re:Whatever happened to chatbots? by quickthrower2 on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @11:48PM (#18804249)
Well hello there Animats, how are you today? What can I help you with?
Re:Whatever happened to chatbots? by taprun on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @06:39PM (#18803133)
Well, there are tons of chatbot popups when I visit websites.
Re:Whatever happened to chatbots? by rajacombinator on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @07:13PM (#18803269)
They got btfo pretty hard by sites like this https://chatbot.fail and others. But they’re still around, easy to sell this concept to low IQ types.
Re:Whatever happened to chatbots? by Animats on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:21AM (#18804916)
Um. Yes. I've been visiting various sites selling chatbots. None of them use a chatbot to sell their own services. Only one, IBM, even had a demo chatbot, and despite using "Watson", it was dumber than some phone trees.

On the other hand, Alexa seems to be far better than most chatbots.