Re:Federal judge finds state law governing who is an enginee...
by darpa_escapee on Monday December 31, 2018 @09:04PM
(#18798449)
> Howver, I don't see how you can come to the conclusion that ordinary people should not be able to tell their children, friends, parents, or anyone, medical advice.
Please do not strawman my position. The discussion was about people purposely portraying themselves as doctors and then dispensing medical advice.
I have no problem with someone giving medical advice. I do have a problem with someone pretending to be a doctor while giving medical advice.
Re:Federal judge finds state law governing who is an enginee...
by kd5bjo on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @07:44AM
(#18799973)
I get mistaken for somebody with authority all the time. What happens when a lay member of the public offers medical advice, and the recipient mistakes them for a doctor despite having made no claims to that title?
Re:Federal judge finds state law governing who is an enginee...
by darpa_escapee on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @09:23PM
(#18803774)
Given that we are talking about people who purposely portray themselves as doctors, I'm not sure how this is relevant.
Howver, I don't see how you can come to the conclusion that ordinary people should not be able to tell their children, friends, parents, or anyone, medical advice. If so, where does it end? Can you tell your child to take medication? Which medications? Can you help victims of accidents? Give CPR? Can you tell your Father not to get that particular medical treatment? Can you tell someone to not trust a particular doctor? What you're suggesting sounds like a litigious nightmare of egg shells through life.
On principle, should we not err towards advocating for granting power to the people instead of centralized, corporate and government authority structures? Or do you just not believe in that?