News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by c54 on Sunday December 30, 2018 @11:02PM (#18792919)
I appreciate your example especially since it’s something you couldn’t really have looked up beforehand. Imagine searching “raves til 5am in my area”

But flight paths are a known known. Maps exist. Noise level maps exist. Airport locations, runway directions, departing and arriving flight paths (and altitudes!) all exist.

Caveat emptor, you got a “good deal” on a house because it’s in a loud area. If you cared about the noise then you should’ve done your homework.

Or.. move somewhere else?

Again— all this only applies to people walking in to buying homes under takeoff paths. If the airport did this to existing homeowners that’s a prolem, and I think complaints are justified. (This case also runs into NIMBYism, which is also a problem, and so on)

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by cyberferret on Monday December 31, 2018 @01:23AM (#18793367)
Once again - anecdotal evidence from my own experience - when we bought our house, which was the biggest purchase of our lives, we made sure that during the cooling off period before final settlement, we spent a lot of time parking our car on the street where our house was and walking around.

Day time, night time, weekends, working hours, we spent at least 30 to 60 minutes in the neighbourhood on multiple occasions to see what the noise and traffic levels were like amongst many other factors. I cannot believe that most people don't do this more often when looking to settle in a family home that you are going to live in (and possibly raise children) for a large chunk of your lives.

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by GFischer on Monday December 31, 2018 @10:05AM (#18794748)
There are some markets where the real estate business is insane, you don't get to make those studies.

I once had 30 minutes to make an offer on a flat, I actually matched the asking price... and was outbid an hour later.

Current price for that flat is 50% higher now. I'm still renting :( .

And it was a sketchy part of town with known crime (mostly theft, not violence).

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by binarycrusader on Sunday December 30, 2018 @11:22PM (#18792993)
Flight paths change sometimes. Airports expand, etc.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by cyberferret on Monday December 31, 2018 @01:20AM (#18793357)
Airport expansion, or addition of new runways etc. are usually a tediously long process, and usually with a lot of community feedback and approval etc. (at least, here in Australia it is). Not something that can happen overnight without anyone knowing.

Flight path changes are more common. But then again, those are usually departure pathways. The worst noise issues are on final approach or on the takeoff run on runway heading, which rarely change. Most turning points are above 1000ft AGL where the noise levels are a lot less.

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by pongogogo on Monday December 31, 2018 @03:36AM (#18793674)
You would probably use the buttons as part of a campaign to prevent the expansion of an airport further, to prove that aircraft noise is already louder than the authorities say it is. I doubt the current measurement of aircraft noise at ground level over wide areas and long periods is that great, and airport operators have a heavy incentive to understate the levels of noise pollution.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by masonic on Monday December 31, 2018 @03:07AM (#18793604)

  usually with a lot of community feedback and approval
Has "community approval" ever been a prerequisite for commercial jet airports in the US?
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by happertiger on Sunday December 30, 2018 @11:27PM (#18793011)
This is true. If you live near an airport the disclosure is required by law if you buy a house in the are.

However, it doesn’t preclude expansion and changes. If for example your airport moves from 12 hour a day to round-the-clock flights... nothing you can do.

It’s a sticky wicket.

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by Carpetsmoker on Monday December 31, 2018 @12:26AM (#18793186)
Not all noise complains are from people who actually live near airports. I already linked this in my other reply, but: https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/01/former-astronaut-fil...

> located five miles from Reagan National Airport.

That's not really close. The reason there are planes there is due to the flight paths:

> To reach Reagan National through the congested and closely monitored DC airspace, flights must basically follow the Potomac River. The problem for Vittori's neighborhood is compounded by the fact that the airport recently adopted a new flight navigation system known as NextGen to help cut carbon emissions and reduce fuel consumption. This brought planes directly over his Georgetown neighborhood.

Also see the other commenter whose living 12 miles from the airport!

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by chii on Monday December 31, 2018 @12:34AM (#18793220)
Cities should of course be building airports outside of the city!
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by gambiting on Monday December 31, 2018 @05:59AM (#18794027)
And they do, but of course cities expand. What might have been an airport in the middle of nowhere 30 years ago, might be a city airport nowadays.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by accnumnplus1 on Monday December 31, 2018 @11:29AM (#18795271)
Exactly. Heathrow was setup as an airport in the middle of the last century, and continues to be used as if London hasn't grown in that time, and won't grow in the future. With plans to extend. I regularly get woken at 4:30am. Undoubtedly, at some point during the day I'll see headlines or commentary about mental health or strain on the NHS. I wonder how many would be feeling considerably better if they simply weren't subjected to sleep deprivation and a plane flying overhead every 120 seconds.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by sargun on Monday December 31, 2018 @12:52AM (#18793265)
Doesn’t this somewhat defeat the purpose of the airport?
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by chii on Monday December 31, 2018 @01:05AM (#18793316)
Not if they could put in good mass transit to and from the airport.

Airports, like heavy industries, should be outside the city limits, away from populations.

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by gambiting on Monday December 31, 2018 @06:01AM (#18794028)
By that logic, London should build their airport about 2 hours by train away from the city, because anything within <2h radius is still within highly populated zones.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by Retric on Monday December 31, 2018 @08:50AM (#18794460)
2 hours by HSR is a very long way ~300 miles from London. In reality, 50 miles north east of London is farm land.

The core problem is when you build an airport you decrease the value of all nearby property. If people building airports directly compensated people say 50,000$ each property they would build airports in the middle of nowhere and opposition would likely be minimal. Instead people suddenly hate where their living but can’t afford to move.

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by gambiting on Monday December 31, 2018 @09:05AM (#18794504)
Not everything is connected by HSR. Getting from Heathrow to city centre can take ~1.5h on public transport, and that's like ~15 miles in straight line.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by Retric on Monday December 31, 2018 @09:15AM (#18794550)
If you're building an airport you can presumably also build other infrastructure. I am not saying it needs to be reach it in 20 minutes via HSR, just that distance is not the problem infrastructure is.

Dulles airport was built 30 miles from DC in what was the middle of nowhere at the time even though DC already had an airport. "In 1965 Dulles averaged 89 airline operations a day while National Airport (now Reagan) averaged 600 despite not allowing jets." Dulles still does not have a subway link to DC, and it's not the closest airport yet it still sees 21 million passengers a year.

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by bobthepanda on Monday December 31, 2018 @05:25PM (#18797430)
Dulles is only really successful because National has capacity restrictions and a limit on how far flights can go.

As a counterexample, Narita, is too far compared to Haneda.

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by Retric on Monday December 31, 2018 @07:27PM (#18798087)
London like most major cities already has an airport. However, expanding airports means addicting a runway ~1.2km from existing runways which causes more noise issues as people are now effectively 1.2 km closer to the airport.

So, sure expanding existing airports is an option to consider, but doing so has a real and measurable negative impact on property values.

PS: I am not trying to promote a new airport further from London just saying such a thing is an option for London and most other major cities.

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by bobthepanda on Monday December 31, 2018 @02:48AM (#18793560)
The problem is that access to the airport becomes a location amenity for some businesses, which in turn will draw housing for workers, and eventually the city will envelop the airport.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by Symbiote on Monday December 31, 2018 @04:24AM (#18793786)
It's easy to forbid residential (or all) development under the flight paths.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by picklebutt on Monday December 31, 2018 @01:12AM (#18793342)
Not really, runways are really expensive, long, wide roads, they may get lengthened slightly or have safety devices installed on the ends but their location is so fixed that few have changed since they were built, and most were built during the war years.
Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by Carpetsmoker on Monday December 31, 2018 @12:24AM (#18793179)
> flight paths are a known known. Maps exist. Noise level maps exist. Airport locations, runway directions, departing and arriving flight paths (and altitudes!) all exist.

I think it's not so unusual for people to just ... forget about this. Especially if they've never experienced it, or if the house isn't close to an airport at all. Moving can be a stressful experience; not infrequently moving has some sort of time constraint (family expansion, new job, etc.) or is due to a bad experience (divorce/breakup being a common example). There are loads of variables, and can't possibly check up on every one of them.

I once lived in an apartment where I couldn't properly open the windows. Of course I had a viewing before I agreed to rent the place, but it never occurred to me to check if I can open the windows. Not being open the windows is annoying on hot summer days. Not being able to sleep at night had a massive impact on the quality of your life. There have been a number of studies about the effects of noise pollution, and it's a lot more harmful than people think. Housing and a good night's sleep are basic human needs; even more so than health care. As I said before, we can't always need to accommodate everyone, but I don't think that concerns about them should be dismissed lightly.

Ideally, the landlord/agency should have an obligation to find out and tell people these sort of things. Maybe that's already the case in some jurisdictions? IMHO selling people a house above a plane route without informing them is like selling people a house where you know the roof is leaking but aren't telling people. Do you check if the roof is leaking? Do you ask? Probably not. And the roof is just one example, there are many more things to check. To have a free market you must have good access to information, so you can make an informed decision.

Also remember that situations change; here is actually an example from the D.C. area (not sure how related that is to this one, perhaps it is?): https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/01/former-astronaut-fil...

> The problem for Vittori's neighborhood is compounded by the fact that the airport recently adopted a new flight navigation system known as NextGen to help cut carbon emissions and reduce fuel consumption. This brought planes directly over his Georgetown neighborhood.

Other airports have massively expanded, and/or are misleading about the information they give out. A good example of this is Amsterdam airport (Schiphol), which had expanded a lot in the last 40 years, and has been misleading people about how much noise the planes make.

Honestly, I think blaming the tenants for "not doing their homework" is just not very constructive. As I mentioned before, someone will live there, and someone will have the draw the shortest straw. I don't have a good solution for airplane noise, but I don't think that "just don't live there" – which is basically your proposed solution – is really a solution at all. It's just waiting for the sucker who will forget to check the airplane paths, or the person who just can't afford anything else.

> Or.. move somewhere else?

Not always so easy depending on the area and requirements (e.g. closeness to job etc.), and not everyone has the money to just move whenever.

In my case, the housing market is crazy in the city I was living in (Bristol, UK); I tried finding something else but there wasn't too much on the market that fit my requirements, and it was a lot of effort.

Re:Button offers instant gratification for those plagued by ... by sokoloff on Monday December 31, 2018 @06:22AM (#18794072)
I absolutely inspected both houses I’ve bought for a leaking roof prior to the inspection period closing and can’t imagine buying a house without doing so.