The rationale is that chores are part of living in the household, and are not negotiable. My kid gets a paid allowance which is in principle tied to her “job” which is going to school.
It seemed inconsistent to say, “you are paid $x for this list of chores, which are in fact compulsory.” Because I didn’t want to allow her to opt out of, say, emptying the dishwasher because it wasn’t a good enough deal.
Fundamentally, I didn’t want to broker a market in chores.
Sure they are "negotiable". Your kid could just refuse to do them. What are parents going to do, kick him/her out?
Kids should always get basic necessities like a bed and food, but if they refuse to help the family in any way, there is no reason to not limit their access to luxury stuff, like electronic entertainment devices or sweets or whatever. Being able to do that is an enormous leverage in the hands of parents, and I really wonder why so many parents seem to hesitate to use it.
They might still have the machine then, but since today's kids have never gotten into "downloading digital stuff locally" but use streaming and online-only services for practically anything, the machine without internet access is nearly useless for entertainment purposes.
And how do you propose to do that? I have PiHole and OPNSense set up already. It's impossible to block everything.
If your kid isn't enough of a hacker already that she/he uses MAC address modification to get around your limitation (most aren't, which is what I'll assume for now), this should do it - and you won't have to deal with the manual work of blocking and unblocking for too long, because I can guarantee you that they will bend to your will rather sooner than later. After all it's just some easy-to-do and quickly done household chores, it's not like you want to enslave them. And once you've followed through on your "no-internet-for-lazy-kids" policy once or twice and shown them that you are indeed able to take their toy from them, the threat of doing it alone will do wonders when the next chore comes up and they start inventing reasons again why they just can't do that nasty work right now.
Edit: I can expound some. That's what would have been said to me if I responded in that way. Anyone living at home and not doing chores would pay rent. Mom and Dad did, so can anyone else bringing in money.
Growing up, chores were not tied to allowance. We got $5 a week for spending cash, any extra we earned was our own, but chores were just chores. It's how you helped out at home. If you didn't want to do chores, the response was "Here's the classifieds, find an apartment." Now, my parents wouldn't have kicked a 12 year old out for announcing they wouldn't do chores, but A) the realization of how much money one would need to survive on their own is a hell of a shocker, and B) there are much better ways to apply pressure to get someone back on board with being helpful.
Chores should be part of being in the family. Money should be tied to something else I think.