Maybe it's changed since I've been, though.
NYC was developed in its current form, with high-rises and all, well before cars were commonplace[1].
So no, they didn't take a place designed for cars, and yes, that's why it actually works when you take the cars out of the equation again.
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_buildings_in_N...
Ha, no it was not. Oh, it was originally developed sans cars, that's true. But that's not the same thing as its current form. Cities are continually being redeveloped after all. You think Amsterdam was always so bike-friendly? Try googling for what it was like in the early 70's, before the "Stop De Kindermoord" campaign.
Spoiler: that's one of the major reasons why city centers work. Transportation hubs are also commercial hubs.
In terms of shopping, the stores are all chains, so nothing is "unique" per se. However, getting to Times Square is super convenient because it's a transit hub.
Plus the fact that there are probably 150,000+ jobs within a three block radius.