On the other hand there is no way to breed whales. There is some finite number of them in the wild and we cannot actively endeavor to create more.
Commercial farming of farm animals will not cause the extinction of farm animals; commercial farming of whales will cause the extinction of whales.
They still suffer greatly. Maybe a little extreme but by the same logic we could breed humans for slavery and say that it's OK because they got bred for it.
"commercial farming of whales will cause the extinction of whales. "
Not if done with proper quotas. It's not different from any other type of fishing.
Again, I don't even eat meat, but we should be a little more rational.
And there lies the rub! People ignoring quotas are the whole reason this kind of fishing needs strong cooperative regulation.
> It's not different from any other type of fishing.
Actually, it is categorically different. You'd be hard pressed to hunt salmon to extinction even if you tried because they spawn hundreds of eggs per female each year. The same cannot be said for any species of whale.
The day an animal can articulate that, I'll agree with you.
Until then such comparison bears no meaning.
They can if you keep your eyes open just a little.
I'm not sure this justification works. After all, if someone started breeding dogs or African Greys for human consumption in the U.S. in a way that was sustainable, people would still be outraged by it.
And then people like me and you respond with this same response: "Cows are not going extinct." They don't want to hear an answer, they want to shill veganism.
I've made the same reply a few times in this thread, and both times my comments were down-voted and flagged less than a minute after posting.
edit: Am I saying these people are coordinated? Yeah. Absolutely I am.
This is a rather obtuse outlook on your part. It should not be difficult to see that these positions on killing animals are not logically equivalent, or logically exclusive of each other.
Even forgetting about any concept of morality or ethics for a moment, from a purely utilitarian viewpoint raising animals for food isn't mutually exclusive with wanting to preserve the balance in an ecosystem in which whales play a part, and whose disruption could have far-reaching implications.
There was of course an extensive horse meat scandal in the UK as well, but I didn’t encounter anybody at that time describing the consumption of horse meat as “morally wrong”. Mislabelling of products, fraud, and food safety - those were the problems.
That would be persuasive to some vegans and vegetarians, but they represent a small subset of the population.
A much larger group will respond well to concerns about their extinction. I want my son, and someday my son's kids (if he has any) and their kids to be able to go whale watching. I don't want them to go to school and learn about extinct species that my generation wantonly destroyed.
Unfortunately, this common desire runs afoul of other cultural activities that a few small minorities want to maintain: they want to follow their parents, and allow their kids to follow them, in hunting and eating whale.
A question for you: the banana tree is at risk of extinction, many historical variants have been pushed out of existence by massive cultivation of sterile farmed varieties. Blight, disease, and other issues put this large population of identical plants at risk.
The difference between the whaling problem and the banana problem is that bananas don't have the ability to experience suffering[citation needed]. Do you think it would be meritorious to advocate for the preservation, cultivation, and careful stewardship of bananas?
It would be less meritorious than reducing the suffering of animals.
"I don't want them to go to school and learn about extinct species that my generation wantonly destroyed."
They will learn about that anyway, whales or not. We are destroying habitat of a lot of animals.
It doesn't have to be about suffering or intelligence specifically to still be objectionable to hunt whales.
I never knew this before reading this article(1), but a pig was put on trial. It ate off a kid's face. Was tried and hanged.
They lived among humans, eating our garbage and feces, and the occasional human or corpse, earning them a bad reputation.
Still is no comparison to what humans have done to them, and continue to.
I personally try not to eat them, in paeticular.
1-https://www.wired.com/2015/05/pigs-may-eat-crap-shouldnt-tre...
The only difference I see is that whales are more in the open while the suffering of farm animals is neatly hidden away from most of us.
We should strive to treat animals much, much better but that should apply to all and not just to a few favored ones like whales while forgetting others.