>Of course this assumes that less violence, barbarism, and/or government opression represents the will of the populace...
Not at all. However, what you seem to be assuming is that government size is independent of measures of tyrrany and opression. I contend that the the size of government is directly proportional to tyranny and opression.
We should take a moment to define terms here: by size in this context I refer to scope of operations and, by necessity, authority. In which case a larger government is by definition more opressive, in that authoritarianism past some point is itself opression, as it requires involuntary imposition of rules and restriction of freedoms.
Small government is a hedge against authoritarianism and the tyranny that naturally follows when your life is increasingly micromanaged.
Some examples Finland 56% of GPD
Afghanistan 12%
I don't buy your contention that size of government is directly proportional to tyranny and opression.
How's this for a thought: How 'big' do we want our government to become? Personally I would have liked to stop before Bush signed the Patriot Act, or before we bum-rushed the middle-east with no intention of leaving, or before the NSA created their god machine, or before Obama resigned the Patriot Act several times. Don't get me wrong, I'm not in favor of immediately stripping regulations and defending redundant agencies, but I am interested in immediately cutting off the hand that's reaching up Lady-Liberty's skirt.
Well sure, if you define size of government as such. What about instead number of regulating agencies and their relative budgets? What about legislation and imprisonment?
I would argue that, at least by the classical conservative definition, small government is less about GDP and more about restriction of freedoms and invasion of privacy.
Not to imply that some degree of both may be necessary for a functioning society.
Of course this assumes that less violence, barbarism, and/or government opression represents the will of the populace...