A license to make and redistribute copies, with no restrictions on how many copies can be distributed, and no requirement to track how many copies are distributed or to whom, for a one-time lump sum payment is probably going to be rather expensive.
If she's very unlucky and it was downloaded 1.5 million times off of her computer (doubtful - Comcast would have shut down her computer for going way over her bandwidth quota, and the ratio of sharers to downloaders is quite a bit higher than 1:1000-1:1000000), then maybe it's justified.
This is even without factoring in the likelihood that those people would have bought that music otherwise, rather than downloading in bulk and listening to a small percentage, as is common.
Otherwise, there would be no point in ever buying a license. You'd always be better off just using the item without permission, and then paying the penalty if caught.