Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s...
by tzs on Friday November 05, 2010 @05:50PM
(#1875076)
So when three of the four major labels were refusing to give Apple permission to distribute DRM-free music on iTunes, but were allowing Amazon to distribute their music DRM free, would you argue that Apple could have just gone ahead and distributed the music without permission, as long as it went ahead and paid the labels the same that Amazon pays them?
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s...
by cma on Friday November 05, 2010 @06:14PM
(#1875137)
So when I start throwing rocks and break one window a day of your 5000-window house and announce this intention, when you take me to court and stop me with an injunction after 5 windows, you can go ahead and sue for the repair costs of 5000 windows?
If she's very unlucky and it was downloaded 1.5 million times off of her computer (doubtful - Comcast would have shut down her computer for going way over her bandwidth quota, and the ratio of sharers to downloaders is quite a bit higher than 1:1000-1:1000000), then maybe it's justified.
This is even without factoring in the likelihood that those people would have bought that music otherwise, rather than downloading in bulk and listening to a small percentage, as is common.