News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by gmaster1440 on Thursday December 20, 2018 @05:27PM (#18729759)
Newsflash: e2e encryption is used to send content that stands to gain most from using it.
Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by exolymph on Thursday December 20, 2018 @07:03PM (#18730387)
As someone who strongly believes that people should have the ability to communicate truly privately, I upvoted you because you're correct and people need to be honest about it.

The problem is that "content that stands to gain most from using [encryption]" also includes activists protesting authoritarian governments, or even government officials themselves who don't want to be spied on by their rivals, or victims of stalkers and domestic violence.

Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by izzydata on Thursday December 20, 2018 @05:31PM (#18729785)
Careful there. You don't want to cause people to pull an Australia.
Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by muthdra on Thursday December 20, 2018 @06:00PM (#18730019)
Australia has passed controversial laws designed to compel technology companies to grant police and security agencies access to encrypted messages. The government says the laws, a world first, are necessary to help combat terrorism and crime.

Source: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-australia-46463029

Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by tya99 on Thursday December 20, 2018 @10:08PM (#18731168)
Passing a law is easy, but putting it in practice is enough thing. We of course won't hear about that side of it because "secret".

I have no doubts that the big companies which this seems mostly for will be doing everything to decentralize and remove themselves from the problem citing "systemic weakness" and then doing nothing for the government.

Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by cyphar on Friday December 21, 2018 @02:04AM (#18731874)
> Passing a law is easy, but putting it in practice is enough thing. We of course won't hear about that side of it because "secret".

ASIO has to provide statistics on how many notices they issued in their yearly reports. In addition, recipients of reports are allowed to provide statistics about his many reports they've received. See s317ZF.

> I have no doubts that the big companies which this seems mostly for will be doing everything to decentralize and remove themselves from the problem citing "systemic weakness" and then doing nothing for the government.

Except that Apple (and other such companies) have explicitly designed their e2e systems in a way that they could be backdoored (users don't need to sign new identities with a key, so Apple can add a new one -- which is how the device adding feature works).

In addition, many such companies have the ability to provide a single backdoored binary to a single user. This, according to the legislation, would not be a systemic weakness. There is work you could do to make yourself resilient to company-wide sabotage but no company I'm aware of is doing it.

Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by krylon on Friday December 21, 2018 @08:31AM (#18733147)
With WhatsApp, end-to-end encryption is used by everybody, even though most people probably do not realize it.

EDIT: Okay, that came out more snarky than I wanted it to. On the one hand, you are right, of course: Provide a secure, encrypted, easy-to-use means of communication, and people with something to hide will use it. If I wanted to download or spread child pornography, I would not do it via an unencrypted channel, either.

On the other hand, your comment might be read by some to mean that you think encryption is the problem. And I think, by the time somebody posts a video of a child getting raped to a WhatsApp group, the problem has been around for while and is not going to magically disappear if WhatsApp were to remove end-to-end encryption from their service.

And child pornography, understandably, provokes strong emotions, which is why politicians and law enforcement officials eager to push more surveillance or censorship like to use it as a reason to push their agenda.

Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by feanaro on Friday December 21, 2018 @11:12AM (#18734200)
In fact, I would say that everyone has something to hide and that is perfectly normal and acceptable.
[dead]
Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by dijit on Thursday December 20, 2018 @05:37PM (#18729837)
Because it doesn't contribute to the discussion.
Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by bdamm on Thursday December 20, 2018 @05:43PM (#18729887)
Personally I think it does. The OP is highlighting an assumption that it appears to be the duty of the carrier to track and block content ("WhatsApp has ... problem"). Except that is exactly what carriers should not be doing, and what encryption protects against. Using carriers to track and block content is the definition of totalitarianism. I think child pornography is a hideous blight but stamping it out by shifting responsibility to the carrier is not the way forward.
Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by gmaster1440 on Thursday December 20, 2018 @05:40PM (#18729864)
Sure it does, maybe not as directly as people would like but I don't see how it warrants downvotes. If you feel it doesn't contribute, don't upvote it.

I for one think there's some element of surprise that accompanies these articles that undermines the mechanisms of the technology being discussed and places blame on platforms that administer it.

Re:WhatsApp has an encrypted child porn problem by ionised on Friday December 21, 2018 @06:25AM (#18732703)
A victim complex will get you even more downvotes.