A quick look at http://weboob.org/applications/: handjoob wetboob boobsize
Look, I enjoy a good dick and boob joke, but some people (people, not just women) get understandably uncomfortable with people start sniggering about body parts. Hence I don't do it in public. It's called basic manners.
None of your other examples set out to be interpreted that way, and most of them are a hell of a stretch. Weboobs very clearly set out to make as many immature jokes as it could.
All right. But is this an issue for an “Anti-Harassment Team”? I mean, there might be basic standard of decency which Debian should uphold, and this package might fail that standard and ought therefore be removed, but in that case, the Anti-Harassment Team should have nothing to do with this – this would be an issue for the whole of the Debian project to decide on what limits on basic decency to have.
Or, the over-sexualization present in the package is actually harassing some specific group, in which case the AHT would be perfectly correct to take issue with the package. But the argument here is rarely made explicit.
Also, "immature jokes" has been the backbones of technology and the hacking community. It's called having a sense of humor.
If people are so offended, then why not go create your own distribution with only "non-offensive" software instead of poisoning software that exists. That's what made tech and the open source and hacking community so wonderful. Not everyone has to be boring cookie cutter puritans. Rather than doing that, the puritans are trying to enforce their authoritarian vision on everything.
Most of the debian and open source and tech community doesn't care about weboob or the hypersensitive agenda. Why should the community be affected by a tiny handful of puritans?
That's a lazy argument, and you know it.
"If your offended by me watching porn in my office, that's your problem not mine, feel free not to come in."
Or just consider if that package was called the n-word. Would you be upset with Debian for not choosing to distribute that?
> Also, "immature jokes" has been the backbones of technology and the hacking community. It's called having a sense of humor.
Slavery was the backbone of the American cotton industry. We seem to be under the impression that was a bad thing.
Look, we all know that a line exists. You can argue about where is should be, but trying to argue there isn't one is just lazy, and refusing the actually engage in thought.
This boils down to one simple thing: Debian chose not to distribute some guys boob joke. Seriously, that's what your mad about? Flip it around, and show me someone coming into the project demanding the name be changed, and I'm on your side. But just because you told a fart joke doesn't mean I have to repeat it.
>If people are so offended, then why not go create your own distribution with only "non-offensive" software instead of poisoning software that exists.
Feel free to create your own distribution that does. We already have a distribution that cares about this kind of thing. It's called Debian.
> Most of the debian and open source and tech community doesn't care about weboob or the hypersensitive agenda.
Citation needed.
--- Day changed Sat Feb 13 2010
...
13:02 > bon donc il nous faut un nouveau nom
13:02 > enfin, un nom
13:09 pankkake> grob
13:09 pankkake> Get Rid of Browsers
13:10 pankkake> bad (Browsers are Doomed)
13:11 > grob, ça me plait
13:12 pankkake> et en tout cas y a pas de paquet nommé « grob » sous gentoo
13:12 > idem debian
13:13 > ou woob (Web Out Of the Browser)
13:13 > (variante de ton wootb, en mieux)
13:14 > http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=woob
13:14 pingouine> [Link Info] title: Urban Dictionary: woob
13:14 pankkake> sauf que éliminer of et pas the, c’est pas logique
13:14 pankkake> bon on peut dire que « out of » c’est un vrai mot
13:14 > Web Out Of Browsers, ça se dit pas ?
13:14 pankkake> si
13:14 > bah voilà
13:15 > et woob ça te plait comme mot ?
13:15 pankkake> ouais, c’est rigolo
13:15 > ça va être dur par contre de grimper dans google
13:16 > bon moi woob ça me plait, on part là dessus ?
13:16 > à moins que tu aies d'autres suggestions
13:16 pankkake> non, j’en ai pas
13:17 > ça fait juste chier que le mot existe, en fait :)
...
17:25 > warning
17:26 > il y a déjà un projet nommé woob
17:26 > (plus ou moins)
17:26 > https://www.ohloh.net/p/wooboard
17:26 pingouine> [Link Info] title: wooB
17:27 > bon on va dire que c'est pas grav
17:27 > e
17:29 > hmm, ça peut être weboob (WEB Out Of Browsers)
17:29 > pankkake: t'en penses uqoi ?
17:31 > ook: pareil
17:31 > (même si tu t'en cognes)
17:39 pankkake> pas mal, y a boob dedans :)
https://linuxfr.org/nodes/100988/comments/1514849> pankkake> not bad, there is boob in :)
So... yeah. Started with a boob joke that they double and tripled down on later. Got it.
There is also a license which use the word Bugger off (Etymology source this down to heretics who were thought to have come from Bulgaria), calls lawyers for jackals, and has the word twit in it which all sounds quite nasty for a single license.
Frankly, I'm fine either way. People seem to have assumed from my reply I'm strongly against this Weboob being in Debian. I'm not. I don't really care, but I recognize why an organization might want to distance itself from that kind of humor.
I just really, really, hate bullshit arguments. And claiming that the "boob" association is accidental like the parent is 100% that.
But you are right that it is not accidental association. I attribute the humor to be intentional and very similar to that of the WTFPL authors.
Something that might be a accidental association is a pattern I noticed in the debian mailing list. For some peculiar reason, the vast majority of those in favor of removing the package are from the UK and US, while those against it are from east Europe and France. I guess diversity of culture is not high on the agenda of the diversity team.
And what's with the "our values" nonsense that so much of the tech leadership and business leadership have been using to justify censorship and their authoritarian behavior?
If they are going to remove weboob, then they should also remove man/pages, mongodb, git, gimp, strip, tail, head, gnome, etc. You can view anything as being offensive if you choose to.
So if debian somehow becomes a naughty word in our culture, will debian just shut down or change their name?
Also, does debian's "values" apply only to english? What if the names is innocuous in english but highly offensive in other languages? Will they remove it from the package list or demand the name be changed?
What is going on here? It's like someone released poison and the few people running things have turned into hypersensitive clowns.