News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Porsche 911 Reaches Top Speed in 6th Gear; Not 7th or... by hinkley on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:47PM (#18717591)
I’m not quite sure I follow this explanation. Well more of a statement as it doesn’t explain anything.

Speed is limited by a square power law. Internal combustion engines have an rpm sweet spot for power to fuel ratio and a peak power that’s at a higher rpm.

So are they saying that the power curve for the 911 engine peaks at much, much higher rpms? So high that you can fit two gear ratios between peak power and typical cruising rpms?

It’s been a while since I owned a manual but it used to be common to shift down one gear to pass, for more torque and more power. Sounds like on this car you might have to go for two.

Re:New Porsche 911 Reaches Top Speed in 6th Gear; Not 7th or... by theluketaylor on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:05PM (#18718319)
Peak power is at high rpm in piston engines, but peak efficient power is at low rpm (generally between 1000 and 2000 rpm).

The reason car makers are stuffing so many gears into transmissions now is to keep the engine at peak efficiency far more often (to meet emissions and fuel economy targets).

Trying to hit top speed needs power (mostly due to wind resistance going up by its own square law) not efficiency. So the transmission will use the tallest non-overdrive gear (6th) for top speed and the overdrive gears (in this case 7th and 8th) for efficient cruising.

Re:New Porsche 911 Reaches Top Speed in 6th Gear; Not 7th or... by hinkley on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @07:34PM (#18721446)
So I'm partly stuck in 5 gear thinking. The gears are a lot closer together.

That said, Porsche's data sheet for the current 911 says peak power is at 6400 rpm, so the ratio in rpms between 'go fast' and 'cruise' is in fact a lot wider than on an older, cheaper vehicle, where cruise might be 1800 while you pass at something around 4400-5000 rpms.

Re:New Porsche 911 Reaches Top Speed in 6th Gear; Not 7th or... by vish4 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:30PM (#18717995)
> So are they saying that the power curve for the 911 engine peaks at much, much higher rpms? So high that you can fit two gear ratios between peak power and typical cruising rpms?

That isn't how gearing works. Gearing allows car designers to tradeoff speed vs torque. You can design a gear so that when a car is running at 100 mph, the engine is at 800 rpm.

I suspect Porsche has designed the 7th gear is for normal cruising (65 mph at 1000rpm), and the 8th is for autobahn cruising (165 mph at 1400-2000 rpm).

Re:New Porsche 911 Reaches Top Speed in 6th Gear; Not 7th or... by rubyn00bie on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:21PM (#18717907)
I came to the opposite conclusion: you could probably start the car in 3rd and still pull an oak tree outta the ground. /shrug