4 Techniques for Combining Fonts http://www.typography.com/email/2010_03/index.htm
I quote directly from the article:
"Here, three fonts with distinctive silhouettes have been chosen for their contrasting dispositions: the unabashed toughness of Tungsten is a foil for both Archer's sweetness, and the cheekiness of Gotham Rounded."
Really, there is no other way to talk about wines, or typefaces. It is subjective.
If you delve into the otherwise boring individual minutia of glyph characteristics and try to write an analysis comparing descenders of the lowercase "j" from 2 or 3 typefaces, you'd lose every reader before you got out of the starting gate.
That said, if you read the feedback, a lot of people said they learned something. My goal was to teach something and have the reader come away with a bit of knowledge, however incremental.
It's like art or fashion- it is entirely subjective, yet experts can make 'definitive' statements about style and generally agree.
I think each font carries history and connotation that is obvious to the 'experts' but not to everyone else.
In the same way, when looking at someones face, you are struck with an overall impression first. Then you single out features. I have never met anyone who said, at first glance, so and so has wonderful eyebrows.
I'm just wondering if there are some people who don't see personalities in these things (e.g., a font being "fun" or "stern") and whether they should, where budget permits, leave design to those who do?
Then again, I don't bat an eyelid at wine descriptors like "barn", "forest floor", "skinsy", etc while some people really dislike it.
What? It looks like fun is in the eye of the beholder. The lack of proper specification really bugs me. It's sort of similar to how wine connoisseurs use words like "round" which don't really mean anything, or at least not until you've had enough "round" wines to recognise the distinct flavour property that is being described. I vote for ditching this stupid scheme in favour of being more specific and / or defining terms clearly.