News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

dbonneville

Re:Best Practices of Combining Typefaces on Monday November 08, 2010 @10:53AM (#1882798)
Mission accomplished :). As a non-designer, you aren't the target audience, so I'm not surprised, since I wrote the article for those who self-identify as designers, and who have some command of rudimentary typographic terminology. Read the comments on the article to determine who the audience is and whether or not the article reached its intended audience.
Re:Best Practices of Combining Typefaces on Monday November 08, 2010 @10:48AM (#1882778)
"...neophytes and experts"

I think if you read the comments, your assessment is incorrect. There is a near unanimous thanks for some simple, clear examples. If you are reading about combining typefaces, you obviously know the basics already. If you don't know what a slab serif is, you wouldn't be worrying about combining them with something else. In fact, you'd probably be doing something else entirely :).

Re:Best Practices of Combining Typefaces on Friday November 05, 2010 @11:09AM (#1873430)
"Nobody learns to be a rock star developer by merely cutting and pasting code that comes up in a Google search..."

That's not exactly true. In fact,that's how many developers get going - merely copying and pasting code, but then later analyzing and tweaking it, and making it part of their vocabulary. Copy first, understand later.

Look at the model for classical painting atelliers: year 1: clean brushes. year 2 - 6: draw copies of the master's work. year 7: assist with minor painting duties

I once did a study on the top guitar players from several genre's from jazz to fusion. Without exception, every single one of them learned to play by copying (transcribing) solos from their favorite musicians. Later, they learned theory.

Thellonius Monk said "writing about music is like dancing about architecture". There is only so much you can say, even if you can say something useful. Sometimes a picture is really worth 1000 words.

Re:Best Practices of Combining Typefaces on Friday November 05, 2010 @10:52AM (#1873378)
Oftentimes, in art and design, you can't specify, in a binary way, why something clashes. To your eye, if it clashes, it clashes. You can't really break down an impression into a series of isolated minutia while retaining a sense of the overall.

It's also much easier to define "clash" by simply showing "harmony", which is the simpler, more intuitive approach to take in a simplified blog format.

Sometimes you don't need to know why something is good or bad, you just need to trust your eyes. And if you train your eyes on enough good stuff, the bad becomes blindingly obvious.

Re:Best Practices of Combining Typefaces on Friday November 05, 2010 @10:44AM (#1873350)
Good question. I look at fonts and see overall personalities first and tints and shapes later. The tints and shapes are incidentals in the overall personality, and carry little weight when isolated from one another.

In the same way, when looking at someones face, you are struck with an overall impression first. Then you single out features. I have never met anyone who said, at first glance, so and so has wonderful eyebrows.

Re:Best Practices of Combining Typefaces on Friday November 05, 2010 @10:42AM (#1873338)
Hi - I'm the author of this article over at Smashing. Actually, this kind of scheme of describing typefaces is quite common, especially among the best designers on the planet. If you follow the references at the bottom of the article, you'd find a link to this article at H&FJ:

4 Techniques for Combining Fonts http://www.typography.com/email/2010_03/index.htm

I quote directly from the article:

"Here, three fonts with distinctive silhouettes have been chosen for their contrasting dispositions: the unabashed toughness of Tungsten is a foil for both Archer's sweetness, and the cheekiness of Gotham Rounded."

Really, there is no other way to talk about wines, or typefaces. It is subjective.

If you delve into the otherwise boring individual minutia of glyph characteristics and try to write an analysis comparing descenders of the lowercase "j" from 2 or 3 typefaces, you'd lose every reader before you got out of the starting gate.

That said, if you read the feedback, a lot of people said they learned something. My goal was to teach something and have the reader come away with a bit of knowledge, however incremental.