Re:Ask HN: Mac users who have switched to Linux, how do you ...
by wahern on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @07:27PM
(#18711929)
I use Beamer and I use macOS.
macOS has great PDF support. Preview.app understands ToCs and full-screen presentation mode. It's been awhile since I've used any Linux GUI apps, but IIRC the typical Linux PDF viewers had all the right features, too.
Your whole presentation is basically an HTML file - a <section> for each slide. CSS and JS can be used as like on a normal webpage to provide styling and effects.
It can be edited and run on any computer and operating system - just needs a text editor and browser.
It's responsive - no need to worry about aspect ratio.
Re:Ask HN: Mac users who have switched to Linux, how do you ...
by zapzupnz on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @07:08PM
(#18711821)
I think the comments you've had so far have been to do with the result of having a good-looking and functional presentation. But as a fellow Keynote user, I understand that it's not about the end result; it's about the joy of working in Keynote. Hell, that's the thing about being a Mac user — when It Just Works™, It Just Works™ to the point that when you try to do things the other ways, somehow It Doesn't Work Well Enough™ even if the result winds up identical.
I can manipulate and place objects in Keynote with a precision that nothing else affords me not because they're incapable of it, but rather because their workflows for doing so are, to me, hugely inefficient. The way Keynote handles layout, snapping, movement, Magic Move transitions and many other features just can't be replicated.
Except it can, on the web. Have you given iCloud.com's version of Keynote a try? Much less featureful, but if you go back to any given Mac and make yourself some nice templates and store them in your iCloud Drive, you can always use those to create presentations in _basically_ the same workflow as you're used to, just in a browser.
Fair warning, though: anecdotally, I've always found it's a bit heavier on the resource usage than Google Slides or Office 365.
Re:Ask HN: Mac users who have switched to Linux, how do you ...
by sqs on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @04:37PM
(#18710819)
What’s lacking in Google Slides? It works great for me and is the standard at most companies I know. In a way, you’d have the same problem if you just joined a company that uses Google Slides, so maybe that’s a better way to frame your question.
Guess this approach depends on whether you want to "code" your slides or not. As someone who's never gotten along with Powerpoint et al, this approach agrees with me very well.
Re:Ask HN: Mac users who have switched to Linux, how do you ...
by LarryMade2 on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @08:37PM
(#18712314)
Haven't done it yet but I have read there are s few great PDF slideshow programs that are really good. So you would make your presentation a PDF and then use one of these to page around your slideshow. Has fades, animated page changing, etc.
I kinda like this solution over a "presentation" program as you can use whatever you want and produce slides way nicer then being limited by Pages, Impress, PowerPoint, or whatever.
I usually use LaTeX, because it works on all the major OS and frees me from learning different software
macOS has great PDF support. Preview.app understands ToCs and full-screen presentation mode. It's been awhile since I've used any Linux GUI apps, but IIRC the typical Linux PDF viewers had all the right features, too.
Your whole presentation is basically an HTML file - a <section> for each slide. CSS and JS can be used as like on a normal webpage to provide styling and effects.
It can be edited and run on any computer and operating system - just needs a text editor and browser.
It's responsive - no need to worry about aspect ratio.
It has speaker notes too!
I can manipulate and place objects in Keynote with a precision that nothing else affords me not because they're incapable of it, but rather because their workflows for doing so are, to me, hugely inefficient. The way Keynote handles layout, snapping, movement, Magic Move transitions and many other features just can't be replicated.
Except it can, on the web. Have you given iCloud.com's version of Keynote a try? Much less featureful, but if you go back to any given Mac and make yourself some nice templates and store them in your iCloud Drive, you can always use those to create presentations in _basically_ the same workflow as you're used to, just in a browser.
Fair warning, though: anecdotally, I've always found it's a bit heavier on the resource usage than Google Slides or Office 365.
Guess this approach depends on whether you want to "code" your slides or not. As someone who's never gotten along with Powerpoint et al, this approach agrees with me very well.
I kinda like this solution over a "presentation" program as you can use whatever you want and produce slides way nicer then being limited by Pages, Impress, PowerPoint, or whatever.
but I think the willingness to move to linux pre-supposes you have also accepted the slide content is what matters, not what it looks like.
I think there is a very strong Tufte moment here: make slides in whatever you can, even as plain ASCII.
Disclaimer: I work there.