News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by StavrosK on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:01PM (#18703974)
I feel compelled to write up a summary of the comments here and responses to each one:

> This is useless.

Who cares? It's super cool!

> This is not well-suited for use case X.

Did you read the page? It's so great that someone thought of this and did it.

> This has been done before.

SUPER. COOL.

> It's hard to read.

I don't know what you aren't getting about this.

> What if it implemented improvement X?

I don't know, I didn't write it. Maybe the author would appreciate the suggestion!

Re:Dotsies (2012) by xg15 on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @05:01AM (#18705535)
To be fair, you could use your exact post to argue in favor of Juicero, uBeam or Theranos.

More in-depth, yes, a lot of posts here are criticizing - but it seems to me, a lot of it is constructive criticism from someone who actually did find the idea interesting.

I personally would find a HN where each post is just a variant of "woah that's super cool!" a lot less interesting.

Re:Dotsies (2012) by burke on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @09:22AM (#18706527)
Notably differently, Dotsies is not heavily funded, nor does it want you to pay several digits for access. It’s just a fun experiment. It should not be held to the same standards of usefulness as a thousand-dollar juicer.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by trogdoro on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @03:40PM (#18710322)
I appreciate the support :)

Creator of Dotsies here. I've been using Dotsies to read books since 2012 (maybe around 100). At first on a Kindle and then on a Kobo after Amazon stopped letting you add your own fonts. I reached my normal reading speed a few years ago, and now reading it is fairly second nature. I now prefer it to normal fonts, and have the feeling that my eyes are racing unnecessarily from side to side when I use them. With normal fonts I'm also less likely to "seek" to different parts of the page, and thus feel a bit handicapped with them.

> the brain uses a hierarchy of constructs like circles, lines, corners, etc

It's a little counter intuitive if you haven't tried it, but the shape-seeking aspects of our visual systems do come into play with grids of dots. As others have said below, the words jump out at you as shapes. Sort of in the way that letters normally do. Just to approximate it, consider: :..'. But you may have to look at words a few thousand times before you get the full effect of this.

In general, the less visual noise and redundancy there is, the easier it is to recognize shapes. Consider looking at a pile of sand vs a pile of boulders, to get a sense of the extreme ends of this spectrum. Pile of sand: high complexity, harder to make out visual shapes. Pile of boulders: low complexity, easy to make out shapes. It is possible to map each letter to unique arrangements of 1000 disordered grains of sand, but clearly a few boulders per letter would be better. Consider that it takes about 20 pixels to represent each Latin letter. We scrapped reading fancy calligraphy because they would take more like 40px or so pixels to represent. And the extra flourishes really just added superfluity to the page. Only that was difficult for us to see, since we were so used to the calligraphy as the norm. I think it's naive to think the current state is the apex. Let's get rid of the remaining flourishes! Calligraphy is sand. Latin is marbles (or spaghetti might be apter). Binary grids are boulders. Just stare at the equivalent paragraphs under "How much better is it?" on dotsies.org for a while and you'll get a sense of this. (Especially if you can do so while imagining you're unfamiliar with Latin letters.)

I think I made a joke in 2012 about cave-men waving their spears at the stone-age version of hacker news claiming their bison heads and triangles couldn't possibly be improved on :).

Just wanted to give a quick summary. Will reply to other comments directly.

Btw I'm also the creator of Xiki, which has been discussed on HN as well, and has a stronger claim to originality/practicality. I did 2 kickstarters for it, which didn't get much hacker news attention, much to my disappointment. I'm doing a third soon and am hoping for more interest/abuse :). My new version will switch to using the markdown format, and will hopefully revolutionize the command line.

Re:Dotsies (2012) by xelxebar on Thursday December 20, 2018 @03:04PM (#18728603)
This is amazing! You inspired me to get Dotsies on my Kindle. I've been wanting to read Cixin's "The Three-Body Problem", so this is the perfect opportunity.

I'm also packaging the fonts up for Void Linux but was unable to find any licensing information. Do you have dotsies under Creative Commons? Did I just miss something?

Re:Dotsies (2012) by the_cat_kittles on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @03:58PM (#18710497)
you should really cite your own personal experience on the page. if i had seen that you have read 100 books in dotsies i would have taken it much more seriously. all this other stuff is kind of post hoc rationalization. if dotsies didn't end up being easier to read it would all be irrelevant. i really think you underestimate the complexity of reasons (or lack thereof) why dotsies works (or doesn't)
Re:Dotsies (2012) by burke on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @05:49PM (#18711342)
I took a run at learning to read dotsies earlier in the year but I think you've just inspired me to give it a more serious attempt. Sounds fun.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by StavrosK on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @06:29AM (#18705808)
Criticism is useful and welcome, but it doesn't have to be dismissive or in a negative tone.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by swsieber on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @09:26AM (#18706546)
No you couldn't - because those weren't done before :)
Re:Dotsies (2012) by Klover on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @01:03AM (#18704819)
The website states “was created thousands of years ago, and is optimized for writing, not reading. About time for an update, no? Dotsies is optimized for reading.”, and other claims on the website, and people are not instantly convinced just because it’s free.

Positivity is fine, but blind positivity is not helpful for anyone..

Re:Dotsies (2012) by sundarurfriend on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @04:19AM (#18705411)
> Positivity is fine, but blind positivity is not helpful for anyone..

I'm with you on that one, but at this point I'd even take blind positivity over the usual constant blind negativity to anything new on HN. Maybe that's the actual remedy to that, a bit of blind positivity in every thread to counteract the immediate all-around pessimism.

Re:Dotsies (2012) by Klover on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @04:34AM (#18705459)
That’s fair. I guess the karma system makes for more combative comments, or comments that more align with the status quo. Like https://forums.bunsenlabs.org/viewforum.php?id=13 seems to be welcoming a lot more discussion. I can only give that as an example because it was the last non karma forum I’ve visited in ages, and even that was a long time ago.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by jeremyw on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:40PM (#18704140)
I feel like HN should implement a "positive-only" or "constructive-only" flag for posts, whether set by posters or moderators. Perhaps all Show HN. Start to experiment, see what sticks.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by TomMckenny on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:53PM (#18704200)
It is a pity an intellectually curious person's work posted to a forum of presumably intellectually curious people gets a bit beat up.

George Bernard Shaw worked out a new alphabet too. Tolkien built a language for books about goblins and elves. I can't image how they would be greeted. But perhaps it's just a bad day or hour or something.

Re:Dotsies (2012) by umanwizard on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @01:34AM (#18704914)
Tolkien did not claim that his invented language was better than English and should replace it.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by coryrc on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:42PM (#18704366)
Had Tolkien not been "bit beat up" he would have written the whole thing in Qenya and no one would have ever heard of it.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by nothrabannosir on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @04:39AM (#18705480)
A problem with HN is that the rules essentially incentivise this behaviour: if you simply think something is good, you cannot say so until someone else said it was not. “This is great “ is not a good comment. So people upvote instead. But scores are hidden , so you can’t see that from the outside.

you can see this effect in action on your own posts : 10 upvotes, 1 critique. From the outside however, it just looks like “HN is at it again!”

Sure, people could say “this is good because X”, just as they should with critique , anyway. But that’s not how we think : it’s easier to motivate why you don’t like something than why you do.

I think HN is much more positive than it seems. We just need to find a way to stop hiding it.

Re:Dotsies (2012) by IgorPartola on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:54PM (#18704404)
I think generally we should strive for positive comments. But I have seen some pretty terrible Show HN’s. To be clear, they are the minority. But there are some that are basically “I will put drug dealing sex workers on the blockchain using Tor” or similar where I think it is warranted to point out that it’s a terrible idea or terrible execution or both.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by rhacker on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:49PM (#18704179)
It would be great to have a sliding scale

Mean comments allowable:

    0 --x--------- 100
        15
Re:Dotsies (2012) by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday December 17, 2018 @11:43PM (#18704572)
Isn't this almost exactly what slashdot has?
Re:Dotsies (2012) by duck on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:18PM (#18704291)
The only thing that would of made your summary better is if it was written in the Dotsies font.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by Koshkin on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @09:09AM (#18706456)
And the only thing that would have your comment better if it had the word 'worse' instead of 'better.' Oh, and that "of made" thing.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by code_duck on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @11:47AM (#18707995)
I don’t understand what your definition of super cool is.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by StavrosK on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @11:51AM (#18708044)
I have a set of things that define "super cool", and "inventing your own writing system" is definitely in there.
Re:Dotsies (2012) by code_duck on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @11:53AM (#18708070)
That still doesn’t explain very much. Your answer to “This has been done before.” is ‘SUPER. COOL.’, so what was invented? Could you provide some other things that are on your super cool list or some synonyms?