News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by lkrubner on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:03PM (#18703080)
But it is worth asking why people want to believe that a narrative can be extended to space? Humans structure their experience using narratives, and this works okay on Earth. Though even on Earth, there are many known problems with the way humans use narratives:

1.) police will tell you that eye witnesses are highly inaccurate

2.) psychologists can tell you all about the way people hurt themselves with inaccurate narratives about themselves

3.) human rights activists work constantly against narratives that take a racial category as a first class character, with real and knowable attributes

And those problems arise on Earth. At least since Einstein's Theory Of Relativity we've known that normal human narrative will not extend to space. And yet people want to this to be true. There is a kind of nostalgia that infects most writing about space, a belief that our exploration of space can be like the discovery of the frontier in centuries past. Even intelligent people sometimes talk this way, even though they know it is an inaccurate way to think about the universe.

I suppose this is sort of in the category of "Why do 99% of sci-fi movies act as if there is a gravity on spaceships, or assume a technology that can easily assume that a 1 G warp of the space time continuum does not itself warp the ship into a ball?"

Basically, people don't want their sci-fi stories to be too accurate. And I guess that's fine. Maybe it's all just entertainment. But then we shouldn't take that entertainment and act like any of it can ever be real.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by stcredzero on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:18PM (#18703178)
At least since Einstein's Theory Of Relativity we've known that normal human narrative will not extend to space.

Meh. Human narratives have encompassed characters who live for hundreds of billions of years and who experience time warped in any number of ways. There are even successful mainstream movies that deal with such issues. Multiple ones going back decades.

Basically, people don't want their sci-fi stories to be too accurate. And I guess that's fine. Maybe it's all just entertainment.

You could totally re-tell the entire Star Wars and Star Trek canon in such a setting. It's not that people don't want it. Most people don't know enough to know they would want it. Heck, half of everyone seems to think "there's no gravity in space."

(EDIT: By "such a setting," I mean in just several cubic light years around Sol and Alpha Centauri.)

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by lkrubner on Monday December 17, 2018 @07:08PM (#18703468)
"You could totally re-tell the entire Star Wars and Star Trek"

Both of those are fiction, so they are not relevant. I think we all get why people like fiction -- it's entertaining and some of the better stuff is educational. But why do intelligent people want to believe that any such coherent stories can actually be told in real life? We all know it's impossible. Even basic questions such as "How old are you" become unanswerable. A person gets in a ship and travels at 1 G to another star, then turns around and comes back to Earth, they've aged 20 years, meanwhile on Earth 200 years have passed and all their friends are dead. Which timeline is real? How would any sci-fi tropes play out, in real life, in a universe of such inconsistencies?

Consider the issue of law enforcement. How could a central authority enforce its power, if people knew they could commit a crime, live a long life, and die before any forces from the central authority arrived? The notion of a political entity existing at more than solar system scales is ridiculous. Intelligent people know this, yet many of them still seem to want to believe that such a thing is a possible. Why is that?

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by stcredzero on Monday December 17, 2018 @07:28PM (#18703567)
But why do intelligent people want to believe that any such coherent stories can actually be told in real life? We all know it's impossible. Even basic questions such as "How old are you" become unanswerable.

Really intelligent informed people know the relative scales involved. So if all of Star Wars were re-imagined to occur using reasonable tech within the several cubic light years around Alpha Centauri, no speeds where severe relativistic time dilation effects are necessary for normal transportation. "How old are you" is readily answerable +/- a month for just about everyone, even most spacefarers. Heck, even the prequel trilogy makes more sense. (As Plinkett puts it, why are people on the planet of Naboo dying because they lack, "Space Supplies?" It would make a whole lot more sense if Naboo were an icy ball in the Oort cloud.)

A person gets in a ship and travels at 1 G to another star, then turns around and comes back to Earth, they've aged 20 years, meanwhile on Earth 200 years have passed and all their friends are dead. Which timeline is real? How would any sci-fi tropes play out, in real life, in a universe of such inconsistencies?

Another thing: I'm not an expert myself, but I can already tell that you don't even understand the big abstractions of relativity that well. The "Twin Paradox" is not actually a paradox. There is a global set of spacetime intervals which is consistent among all observers. It's only each observer's view of the spacetime interval which disagrees between observers. I'm probably saying that wrong, but the gist of that should be right.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFAEHKAR5hU

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1YFrISfN7jo

The "Spacetime Globe" by Minute Physics is the most helpful.

It's like you're a 2D flatlander declaring that a cube would be seen as a square by one person and a hexagon by another, so the 3D universe must be an inconsistent database. Uh, no. The universe is totally consistent. You, poor finite human, just have a slim, parochial view of it.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by lkrubner on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:26PM (#18703247)
"People lament the light speed barrier, because it seems to preclude vast space empires of Sci-fi."

Assume you are the Emperor of a vast interstellar empire. You order your best general to go and attack a star system 10 light years away. Your opponent possibly does the same. 20 years after you give the order, you are told that your general lost the battle (or won the battle). How would you verify that? It's not just that you have to wait another 20 years to verify it, it's that events will pile up in excess of what you can verify. The best way to understand the outcome of this battle is to read what Kyle Kingsbury has written about distributed databases:

https://aphyr.com/tags/jepsen

Because, for all practical purposes, the Universe is a distributed database with a serious network partition. It is not Eventually Consistent, but rather, it is Infinitely Inconsistent. The writes exceed the reads, and will continue to do so infinitely into the future.

How do you build an interstellar empire around that reality?

As an experiment, it might be fun to create a game that is deliberately inconsistent. That would appeal to a very small niche, because most people crave a consistent narrative experience. But a game designed around a database that is deliberately inconsistent would help people think correctly about the difficulty of building empires in space, or engaging in any other common sci-fi tropes.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by rlpb on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:23PM (#18704068)
> It is not Eventually Consistent...

If there's anything the universe is, it's Eventually Consistent. Nobody has ever found a case where it isn't. Relativity was predicted to exist because "eventual consistency" was assumed axiomatic in our universe. Essentially, eventual consistency is exactly why the universal speed limit exists.

> but rather, it is Infinitely Inconsistent

We will fall behind in knowledge of events, but causal knowledge of an event in our universe, if it exists, is always consistent.

Knowledge of events in our universe is like an immutable, append-only database (think git), not data that gets updated (like a key/value database).

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by stcredzero on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:51PM (#18704196)
> If there's anything the universe is, it's Eventually Consistent.

Please disregard this inconsistency guff! The Universe isn't Eventually Consistent. It's simply consistent. What's really going on, is that some programmers don't understand relativity. Relativity doesn't actually say that everyone gets their own reality. There is a consistent consensual reality. Spacetime intervals are consistent between all observers. The time ordering of events changes depending on the observer's POV and relative motion, but there is an underlying consistent reality that's the same for everybody.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFAEHKAR5hU

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1YFrISfN7jo

The "Spacetime Globe" by Minute Physics is the most helpful thing I've seen, flat out, for understanding relativity.

> Knowledge of events in our universe is like an immutable, append-only database

This is correct. Relativity just says that different users get different results, depending on how they query. The underlying database is the same for everybody. (Some parts of it are forbidden access, of course.)

Programmers have been causing physicists to facepalm since at least the USENET days. I should know. I was one of them!

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by rlpb on Monday December 17, 2018 @11:16PM (#18704488)
> Please disregard this inconsistency guff! The Universe isn't Eventually Consistent. It's simply consistent.

We agree except for what we mean by "eventually" which is just semantics. What I mean by "eventually" is that eventually all the information arrives for my (or anyone's) model of the universe to match reality, analogous to eventually consistent distributed databases. Like an eventually consistent database however we can never catch up completely, since new events are happening in the universe all the time. It takes time for this information to "replicate", but there is no inconsistency. I was following lkrubner's analogy.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by stcredzero on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:50PM (#18703376)
Assume you are the Emperor of a vast interstellar empire.

Your next few sentences disprove the viability of the sentence above. If you want a vast interstellar space empire, then control a whole bunch of settlements that orbit in the space between Sol and Alpha Centauri. It's certainly vast on human scales. It's also technically interstellar.

As an experiment, it might be fun to create a game that is deliberately inconsistent.

A friend of mine created such a space combat themed game, including paradoxes and rules for resolving them. I 3D printed pieces for it. It was indeed fun, so the answer to your conjecture is yes.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by lkrubner on Monday December 17, 2018 @07:10PM (#18703483)
"Your next few sentences disprove the viability of the sentence above."

Exactly. Going back to my original comment, why is that many intelligent people continue to act as if such things are possible, when they know better?

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by stcredzero on Monday December 17, 2018 @07:29PM (#18703577)
We like the lazur zaps and the shiny spaceship graphics. Also: awesome theme music!
Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by mc32 on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:42PM (#18704151)
Isn't that a similar problem to what seafaring empires had ~500 years ago and earlier? Perhaps the time delay wasn't as long, but news could take months or years to get back to "HQ" about what was happening in far flung lands.

Give them freedom to take action and eventually independence to act completely on their own.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by lkrubner on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:22PM (#18704309)
No, because on Earth one can reconcile time. If Vikings go to Newfoundland, fight a battle, and return to Norway 10 years after they left, both the people in Norway, and also the warriors who went to Newfoundland, will agree that 10 years passed. You don't end up with one group feeling that 1 year passed and another group feeling 10 years passed, and perhaps a different group that feels 100 years have passed.
Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by whatshisface on Monday December 17, 2018 @10:37PM (#18704352)
It doesn't matter whether 10 or 100 years have passed, the only thing that matters is causal order. After all, the King only needs to assign punishments and rewards, and those are based on what happened and why. "What happened and why" is the same in every reference frame.

Even things like 10-year jail sentences will still work, because you clearly are asking for 10 years from the perspective of the convict.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by ganzuul on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:43PM (#18703334)
An empire could be a culture.

There would need to be a vast reward function to motivate agents to seek consistency. Juxtapose SETI.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by mat4magic on Tuesday December 18, 2018 @03:44AM (#18705285)
Kind of sounds like the libertarian dream coming true. The vast distance give lots of freedom and makes central authoritarian control impossible
Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by ganzuul on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:33PM (#18703277)
The tools with which people construct narratives change. Exploration of space should bring with it new concepts such as for example might arise when an interstellar colony ship culture meets the culture of the earlier arrivals. Old concepts such as leaving for the New World will be relevant again.

These are opportunities for intelligent life to create new meanings to its existence. Sci-Fi was not born out of a vacuum.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by lkrubner on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:20PM (#18703207)
Why was this downvoted? It certainly is appropriate to ask why smart people want to believe that the kind of narratives we know here on Earth can be extended to space. Intelligent people know this isn't possible, so it worth asking why the desire to have these stories is so strong.

A narrative is a sequence of events that happen in a definite order. Humans can not have that kind of experience as they spread to space -- everyone's narrative will be relative to themselves, but they won't reconcile with each others narratives. This is well know. The question is why even smart people prefer fiction that ignores this fact. It's worth asking that question.

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by stcredzero on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:23PM (#18703219)
Why was this downvoted?

I didn't downvote you, but perhaps it's because the idea either lacks a good understanding of the scales involved, or has been effectively disproved by the Sci-fi corpus decades ago. (Just one example of many: Haldeman's Forever War.)

Re:Discovered: The Most-Distant Solar System Object Ever Obs... by ganzuul on Monday December 17, 2018 @06:37PM (#18703297)
Some users break HN's voting system. Often they either don't understand or disagree with what you are saying, and that in their value system means they should downvote.

It's not a very good system, IMHO.