I highly recommend the book. It's more like a science book about dieting than a diet book. Now that I understand that when I eat is as important as what I eat, I've been able to lose 20 pounds (and still going). And, yes, sugar (especially fructose) and refined carbs are bad.
Jason Fung sounds very interesting, I'm looking at: https://idmprogram.com/the-failure-of-the-calorie-theory-of-... where he provides some advice very relevant to this thread... "The [calories in calories out] model very useful because it efficiently flags <strike>idiots</strike> people who are not all that knowledgable about obesity, and I can safely ignore them. There are many of these people out there, and not everybody is worth listening to."
It has also been helping with portion control as a side effect. I dont eat as much anymore
https://idmprogram.com/idm-success-story-robert/
I've just found out they started a FB support group too thanks to the comments here (I haven't checked out his stuff in a while). The social support could be game changing for many struggling, hacking it out alone.
Very few fat people have that level of self control. That's why they're fat in the first place.
It's no surprise that people who put on 100+ pounds of extra weight once would tend to put on 100+ pounds of extra weight a second time. But it's silly to claim that there is an underlying medical reason it's happening.
The body gets used to whatever conditions you face. Human beings have thrived in the Arctic Circle, the North African deserts, and everywhere in between. Obese people have accustomed themselves to an obese lifestyle. If they can make a permanent break and embrace the lifestyle of a person with normal weight then they can stay skinny forever. In the end, most people just don't want to exercise 2+ times per day and limit their portion sizes. So they don't.
As for explanations of the obesity epidemic note the timing -- it really took off in the 1980s, together with the social and political changes that we call "globalization"
https://arxiv.org/abs/q-bio/0312011
one possibility is that it was a change in social stressors, another that it was some environmental chemical introduced around that time. (eg. neonictinoid pesticides or glyphosate)
There are also a variety of surgeries with varying side effects and risk profiles from sleeve gastrectomy to something like a duodenal shift.
It's definitely the case that this is not root causing the issue. There are probably many root causes to increasing obesity with many probably centered around the creation, easy availability, and marketing of calorie dense foods that do not satiate, however, bariatric surgery is something an individual can do while changing most of the root causes requires vast institutional changes.
Eat less garbage (sugar especially - cutting out soda and juice is a good start) and be more active. You'll almost certainly lose weight and be healthier.
The key is knowing what foods to eat and what to avoid. Then making it a lifestyle change, not bandaids or temporary diets.
The result was losing 40 pounds in 3 months and feeling a lot better.
Going to that extreme isn't necessary, though it did have some helpful side effects:
- It reset my taste buds. Afterward sugary things tasted ridiculously sweet.
- No longer craved sugar.
- Portion sizes got a lot smaller.
I distinctly remember feeling light on my feet and having a lot more energy.
This was a decade ago. I kept off most of the weight, but ended up regaining 10 of the 40 as I reintroduced too much junk food.
Why not?
There is not some amazing mystery to why so many people are overweight. They eat more food (energy) than there body uses. Possibly over a long period of time. Just look at people's shopping carts at the grocery store.
Yes we understand so little of the body's biological processes but that doesn't mean CICO is not an extremely useful idea and something to put into action.
How many calories are you expending? The answer is: It depends. How (warm|cold) is it? What's your average body temperature? How much clothing do you wear? What's your genetic makeup? Doing a lot of thinking? What's your current exercise regimen? Is your body in state X where it burns (more|less) calories than state Y? Are you sick?
Calories in and calories out sounds good on paper and seem obvious to an engineers mind, but if you can't tell how many calories are involved on each side of the equation, it's a meaningless measure.
We are not sending a rocket to the moon here. Just because something cannot be measured exactly doesn't mean it's worthless to measure.
If this were the case, Weight Watchers (which is at its core a calorie limiting system) should have a near 100% success rate. It doesn't. A casual perusal of Google shows closer to a 50% success rate for a 5% body weight change.
I can't think of many medical treatments where we go "yeah, a coin toss level of success is good enough for me."
As for the accuracy of the measurements - it does matter. Healthy weight loss rates are, mathematically, in the 10% calorie reduction range. That's less than the error rate for the caloric labeling of many foods.
First off - that's an astonishing success rate against a backdrop of an article saying, literally, surgery is the only reliable option.
Second off - You're assuming 100% compliance. I know people with personal trainers who are gaining weight because they don't stick to the program. I halfheartedly went through a weightlifting routine for years and got nowhere because I never really stuck to the program. 100% compliance in the field of weight loss is just not going to happen.
Incorrect. It's an imprecise measure. You said "Some studies show as much as a 20% difference in what was on the label and the actual caloric content". So then the labels are accurate within a 20% margin of error at worst.
Sounds like a pedantic little nag but then again
- "Star Spangled Blizzard - Mini" - 430 calories
- 1 serving of broccoli (1/2 cup, cooked) - 25 calories
A 50% margin of error would be fine given some of the choices out there. With that said, you usually don't pick between a dq blizzard or broccoli. More reasonable comparisons would be a blizzard vs water (0 cal) or broccoli vs french fries (regular size - 290 cal).
In a nutshell: if a thermostat's off by up to 10 degrees it can still ballpark whether the temperature's livable.
https://www.dairyqueen.com/us-en/Company/Nutrition/Treats/
https://www.dairyqueen.com/us-en/Company/Nutrition/Treats/
https://www.livestrong.com/article/402398-what-is-a-serving-...
Now then, if you were comparing a Starbuck's chocolate muffin and a Blizzard as a treat to fit into your diet without blowing it - could you?
If I'm having a "treat" then I'm already blowing my diet; regardless of if the number fits within a calorie goal.
A calorie budget is a bit like a financial budget. Just because I have allocated a point up to which I can "spend" each day, the long-term goals are a force to minimize day-to-day spend even within that allocation.
This is nonsense. It's like saying that not every kilogram is the same.
Would you consider a kilogram of gold "the same as" a kilogram of air?
Caloric content refers to the amount of energy released when you literally burn the food in question. But our bodies do not literally burn food. They metabolize it in a sophisticated chemical process that converts said energy into a form that the body can use to do work. The rate and effectiveness of this metabolism is clearly influenced by the type and composition of food. For more information, enter "glycemic index" into your favorite source of knowledge to learn why this measure is important for how food is processed. Just as a small glimpse into the complexity of the metabolism.
Would you consider a kilogram of gold "the same as" a kilogram of air?
More relevant would be, "is a kilogram of fat the same as a kilogram of muscle?"Still I'm hoping that some sense will prevail eventually and the sugar industry will be regulated. Before that happens though I'm afraid a lot more people will have to suffer from Type 2 diabetes.
https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2017/12/7/16587316/ba...
Not all bariatric surgeries are the same. The lap band doesn't perform well long term. The Roux-en-Y procedure is one of the very few obesity treatments that carry long-term success, where the patients keep the lost weight off.
Waiting around for a better understanding is crazy, given the health complications are occurring now.
Quality of life increases. Medications are eliminated or reduced. Long-term mortality is reduced (https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa066603 )
But.. you’re not 400 pounds with requirement to lose half your body weight, and keep it off for the rest of your life?
And this is a requirement that these patients have obviously never been successful at.
And they’ve probably done, and failed, long term, at most diets.
Even though I have never been overweight last year I lost 25 pounds in 3 months by eating more food, not working out, and vastly increasing my fat intake. The secret sauce was eliminating carbs 6 days a week and slightly increasing my water intake. Avoiding drugs also helps including caffeine and nicotine.
Weight loss isn't the fundamental issue at play - it's permanent weight loss.
Most individuals in their life are able to clean up their diets enough to lose weight, but maintaining that weight loss indefinitely for a lifetime, an overwhelming majority fail at it.
The long and short of it is that we understand far too little about the human body and what drives weight gain and difficulty losing.
For instance, there are complex health and immune issues (e.g., mast cell disorders) that can drive weight gain and difficulty losing in spite of healthy diets and high levels of activity (and researchers think mast cell disorders alone may affect 10% or more of the population, but was named only 5 years ago and is still poorly understood. What else could be similar that we just don't understand yet?)
Beyond this, what we put in our bodies (various medicines, antibiotics, ingredients in processed foods, various pesticides etc, even artificial light) may have effects on our physiology that we don't yet have a strong understanding of.
Our microbiomes are still a complete mystery to us, deeply impacting how and what we absorb from our food. The same food does not impact every body in the same way, period.
Bariatric surgery is a band-aid over a gaping wound. Until we understand the complexities of human physiology at a more sophisticated level than a high-schooler in physics class (calories in, calories out just doesn't cut it) -- we are going to continue seeing public health impacts in the form of fat and disease -- which may often have underlying causes that the fat is simply the most visible symptom of.
Edit: Seriously guys, is there any other area of science where people are so convinced that anecdotal and small-sample (both in terms of n and longitudinality) observations are valid? There's a huge market for delusion about fat, we're fighting that as much as we're fighting to learn more about the human body.