It is not a legal score, it is a social score (both in theory and in practice)
I completely agree that it is stupid to send non-dangerous people to jail, but we should punish them with fines and possibly specific job restrictions decided on a per-case basis by a tribunal if there is a clear danger, but not by restricting their every aspect of their private, public, social and professional life.
The government can’t tweak at such a fine level but wherever it can, that’s what the system feels like from my very far and biased point of view.
The mental gymnastics people present for support on these policies is astounding to me.
That's what's disturbing here, the link to this other system that is, in itself, nightmarish.
What will a society look like where people aren't free to learn from their mistakes but are instead perpetually held back by them?
Compare this to a prison system based on punishment instead of prevention, leading to depressing recidivism.
I didn't realize the point system so subjective until I watched that clip you shared. How do they decide who becomes an "Information Collector?" Those positions will surely be highly coveted because they come with a massive amount of power and influence over their neighbors' lives. What concerns me about the payment system is that it seems like a fast-track to massive inequality - wealth, social, and justice. If someone can simply pay to erase their "bad" behavior then there's functionally one set of "rules" for those who can afford not to follow them and another set of rules that are actually enforced, in life changing ways, for everyone else.
I have the same thought behind UBI and drug decriminalization as well: thought experiments be damned, go try it and see.
It sounds like a step in the right direction. It feels less gross if you think of "social punishment" as a lighter version of "legal punishment". No need to send cheaters to jail, but don't let them off the hook either.
Assuming the system won't be abused for political (I'm sure it will), the detection is accurate (I'm sure it'll be hard), the social punishment is reasonable (we'll see), it sounds reasonable in theory.