News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by cenal on Saturday December 15, 2018 @02:45PM (#18689988)
Will this weaken the scientific community in China?

Will this cause researchers to become adverse to speaking out for fear of retaliatory attacks on themselves?

Seems like a major step in the wrong direction for Chinese society.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by chillacy on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:00PM (#18690068)
> Chinese leaders have been increasingly focused on scientific misconduct, following ongoing reports of researchers there using fraudulent data, falsifying CVs and faking peer reviews

It sounds like a step in the right direction. It feels less gross if you think of "social punishment" as a lighter version of "legal punishment". No need to send cheaters to jail, but don't let them off the hook either.

Assuming the system won't be abused for political (I'm sure it will), the detection is accurate (I'm sure it'll be hard), the social punishment is reasonable (we'll see), it sounds reasonable in theory.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by asituop on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:22PM (#18690160)
The social score in China is even worse than in Black Mirror, it defines everything you can access from bank, education, job, health, transport , social relationships, etc.

It is not a legal score, it is a social score (both in theory and in practice)

I completely agree that it is stupid to send non-dangerous people to jail, but we should punish them with fines and possibly specific job restrictions decided on a per-case basis by a tribunal if there is a clear danger, but not by restricting their every aspect of their private, public, social and professional life.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by chillacy on Sunday December 16, 2018 @09:13AM (#18693098)
It seems like a systemization of how a small society might shun an outcast. If you’re a rude asshole at school or work, people might intentionally make your life harder by refusing to do things for you, at a minimum they won’t be trusting you with any favors. In the extreme they won’t talk to you.

The government can’t tweak at such a fine level but wherever it can, that’s what the system feels like from my very far and biased point of view.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by BurningFrog on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:40PM (#18690234)
Fines will give you less money, which will restrict every aspect of your private, public, social and professional life.
Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by tuxxy on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:07PM (#18690107)
> It feels less gross if you think of "social punishment" as a lighter version of "legal punishment".

The mental gymnastics people present for support on these policies is astounding to me.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by monocasa on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:15PM (#18690134)
In the states, if you're known for scientific misconduct, will you get a job at a a state school?
Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by jrumbut on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:28PM (#18690184)
Probably not but you can still buy train tickets, get a mortgage, and live in Manhattan if you make some other career work out for you.

That's what's disturbing here, the link to this other system that is, in itself, nightmarish.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by elliekelly on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:54PM (#18690295)
Right, their system seems to presuppose that if a person does something wrong once they should carry the consequences of that "misconduct" indefinitely. That's awfully pessimistic and depressing to me. Everyone has done something "wrong" at one point or another. Most people learn and grow from those mistakes.

What will a society look like where people aren't free to learn from their mistakes but are instead perpetually held back by them?

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by chillacy on Sunday December 16, 2018 @09:16AM (#18693109)
Based on a YouTube documentary I saw it seems like you can redeem your score through payments (officially to charity, but it doesn’t look like it’s transparent): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dkw15LkZ_Kw

Compare this to a prison system based on punishment instead of prevention, leading to depressing recidivism.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by elliekelly on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:52AM (#18699254)
Thanks for sharing! That was really interesting! From your other comments it looks like you live in China? What has the reception been so far?

I didn't realize the point system so subjective until I watched that clip you shared. How do they decide who becomes an "Information Collector?" Those positions will surely be highly coveted because they come with a massive amount of power and influence over their neighbors' lives. What concerns me about the payment system is that it seems like a fast-track to massive inequality - wealth, social, and justice. If someone can simply pay to erase their "bad" behavior then there's functionally one set of "rules" for those who can afford not to follow them and another set of rules that are actually enforced, in life changing ways, for everyone else.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by tuxxy on Monday December 17, 2018 @12:04AM (#18696999)
You really don't see any negatives to this?
Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by chillacy on Monday December 17, 2018 @03:41AM (#18697674)
See my original comment, I see plenty of negatives! But it seems most commenters here are only downsides. References to Black Mirror and 1984 everywhere. I think that’s overblown, and it seems to me like a great experiment to run and learn from. If it turns out to be terrible then we know, if it has upsides but has trade offs in privacy that the west won’t like, then we know. But shouldn’t we find out?

I have the same thought behind UBI and drug decriminalization as well: thought experiments be damned, go try it and see.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by achamayou on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:30PM (#18690197)
But the flip side may be that since it is lighter than « legal punishment », individuals don’t benefit from the same due process and recourses they otherwise have.
Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by snaky on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:03PM (#18690088)
So it might be a wrong step in right direction - as the majority of regulations usually are.
Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by karmasimida on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:56PM (#18690307)
I would say it depends.

If you have to stereotype Chinese dominated community, I think one pattern might emerge, the disregard towards rules particularly if that leads to personal advantages. In other words, rules speak louder when employed for punishment rather than respected as means to obtain the greater good.

There is possibility such punishments could be abused, but as many things happened in China, the execution of such is contextual and selective, so only time will tell.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by qwerty456127 on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:05PM (#18690094)
> Will this weaken the scientific community in China?

It most probraly will because as soon as the system starts working the definition of "misconduct" will probably include ideologically-incorrect research results and subjects, failures to comply to the Chinese job etiquette etc.

And the Chinese Government reaction on Dr. He's breakthrough is an example of how policy can stand against science.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by jVinc on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:51PM (#18690276)
The scientific community is not strengthened in any way by those who falsify data and credentials. Quite the contrary, sometimes other scientists dedicate years to worthless pursuits because they are working in a "promising" direction set forth by others who fabricate impressive results in order to progress their carrier.
Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by TomMarius on Saturday December 15, 2018 @02:54PM (#18690043)
I thought that's what people wanted? Everyone said that the scientist who cloned a baby should be punished.
Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by whatshisface on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:02PM (#18690084)
The government handing out the punishments is itself untrustworthy, which is why every additional power they give themselves is a step in the wrong direction.

>dozens of government agencies will have the power to hand out penalties to those caught committing major scientific misconduct

The key insight here is that you are not being punished as a result of a long, careful process administered by judges and a jury of your peers (which has some problems but at least is designed to be careful and not political), but instead will be at the mercy of a few government agencies which must by their very construction be political.

In the US, there is a similar problem in a much smaller dose, where the government is likewise attempting to assign itself more power without introducing controls to let the citizens be the ones who ultimately decide what happens. One example would be the "secret courts" in the NSA problem. Although the US government is presently much nicer to its citizens than the Chinese government, the only reason this is true is because US citizens have more leverage on the US government than Chinese citizens do on theirs. This can change, and unsurprisingly the officials are trying to gain more authority.

Re:China introduces ‘social’ punishments for scientific misc... by PavlovsCat on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:05PM (#18690095)
It's not what anyone who wants that scientist to be punished automatically wants, no more than someone who wants a glass of water wants a tsunami.

Besides, the Chinese authorities already said what he did violates Chinese law, so what would introducing new laws achieve here, unless they're applied retroactively?

The last thing I heard was that he went missing, any updates on that?